- Nov 23, 2015
- 11,800
- 17,440
- AFL Club
- GWS
- Moderator
- #17
OK, let's leave the hair pulling and biffo on the field, and keep this thread free of trolling comments.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: St Kilda v Western Bulldogs - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Saints at 51% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Perhaps would have said yes at the start of the year, but not now. Reckon Keeffe's been pretty solid this year on top of a good end to last year and doesn't deserve to be axed. Maybe Buckley instead, except he's been pretty good too, and I'd be loathe to disrupt the development of what I think has been a pretty solid defensive unit.Thoughts on Hogan coming in pushing Harry into defence, Keefe out?
Nah I really like HH. I think he contributes so much. He is a tall that plays smallThoughts on Hogan coming in pushing Harry into defence, Keefe out?
In Like Flynn
Matt Flynn back for clash with Bulldogs, plus gun wingman recovers from glandular.www.gwsgiants.com.au
Perryman back in.
Whitfield to play VFL
Perhaps would have said yes at the start of the year, but not now. Reckon Keeffe's been pretty solid this year on top of a good end to last year and doesn't deserve to be axed. Maybe Buckley instead, except he's been pretty good too, and I'd be loathe to disrupt the development of what I think has been a pretty solid defensive unit.
Nah I really like HH. I think he contributes so much. He is a tall that plays small
still some work to do of course but he is a really good player
RiccardiFair enough. Hard to fit all these guys in when they return/debut
So who misses out regarding Hogan returning?
Think it is more likely to be Stone who comes out for WhitfieldPerryman & Flynn for mummy & Reid
Bruhn as sub
Whitfield in for Idun next week.
I’d be disappointed if that was the caseThink it is more likely to be Stone who comes out for Whitfield
Not to us. Needs another week.No hogan is very surprising
No hogan is very surprising
Whitfield isn't a defender. He just does a credible imitation every now and then because we've built our defensive squad on the ruins of an Indian burial ground or something. Put him on a wing and he's just as dominant, if not more.I’d be disappointed if that was the case
Leon’s issue since the start has been shoving the best players in the team rather than picking a team with balance.
8 backs in the side this week and Whitfield would make 9
What options do we have to listen to this game at the ground.
If it's on ABC that would be my preferred. Where are they on the dial.
Thanks
You are oversimplifying this a fair bit. most player play at least two positions on the whiteboard but the reality is the fast paced nature means players play multiple roles. Daniels plays midfield just like green plays forward. Whitfield, ash, buckley all play wing....I’d be disappointed if that was the case
Leon’s issue since the start has been shoving the best players in the team rather than picking a team with balance.
8 backs in the side this week and Whitfield would make 9
FM 106.3 used to broadcast all of the Giants games - but I don't know if they are doing so this year.Anyone
Anyone
Briggs for Keeffe???Whitfield for Haynes
Hogan for Riccardi
Briggs for keefe