Changes vs the Saints - 4 changes

[Toump Ass]

Don't really understand the dropping of Frost. Pedersen in defence??

Looks like we're bringing out the 2009 playbook!

 

[schmuttt]

Don't really understand the dropping of Frost. Pedersen in defence??

If Goody really wants to make a statement he should drop Watts for Weideman.

Could still happen, just wait 24 hours.

 

[BG32]

I assume O Mac takes Bruce. Who plays on Membrey?

Pretty big statement from Goody - reckon there was a few players in worse form than Salem and Frost.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Jetta

 

[dee_mac]

Clear the defensive 50 and leave Jetta one out

 

[PerfectFooty]

I like this statement, but i wasn't thrilled with Pedersen's game as a forward last week. Would prefer if he was dropped and Frost stayed in the side.

Then again St Kilda won't have the largest forward line with Roo out

 

[Proper Gander]

I missed the last two games for work. Clearly jinxed us so I'm going this time.

 

[Dancing Potato]

Strange week.

Would like to see a bench of Gus, Stretch, Maynard and...someone. Not fussed who the fourth is from those options.

 

[booshboy]

Mitch Cleary saying Watts has been dropped

 

[schmuttt]

Mitch Cleary saying Watts has been dropped

Doesn't surprise me, you'd say Weid has to come in.

 

[Mad Prophet]

Mac & I guess TMac in defence against Membrey & Bruce frightens me. I think one of those two will kick a bag.

 

[demondavey]

Sam Frost and Christian Salem out. Nick Riewoldt isn't playing so don't know why Frost would be dropped. Watts needs a spell though.

 

[demondavey]

Don't really understand the dropping of Frost. Pedersen in defence??

If Goody really wants to make a statement he should drop Watts for Weideman.

I'd have Watts out for Weidemann

 

[djpaulydemon]

Salem likely not 100% so i'm fine with him being out. Frost pretty stiff, might be in the VFL to work on a specific thing without the pressure. Seemed like he needs to work on reading the ball in the air.

Interesting who they have back, probably Tmac. Not sold on Wagner i think Membrey wouod kick a bag on him.

 

[Sellout Scully]

Sounds like Pedo will play defence and Petracca will play mostly up forward. I like Petracca better as a half forward

 

[dylan93]

I dunno if anyone is watching the shambles that is The Footy Show, but Eddie supposedly said earlier the mail is Watts to play for Casey.

 

[Crusty Demon]

Salem likely not 100% so i'm fine with him being out. Frost pretty stiff, might be in the VFL to work on a specific thing without the pressure. Seemed like he needs to work on reading the ball in the air.

Interesting who they have back, probably Tmac. Not sold on Wagner i think Membrey wouod kick a bag on him.

Yeah, it has a feeling of bringing in Viv Michie, Dean Terlich or Rohan Bail when we are naming players like Wagner.

 

[Tulip]

Disgraceful changes

 

[schmuttt]

Disgraceful changes

In what way?

 

[Topkent]

Dropping frost seems very strange. Even out of form he could play on a small and use his pace to shut down running goals. Going to be hideously slow down back now.

 

[Topkent]

Also we have one bloke who has looked any good as a forward all year and it looks like we are going to send him back again

 

[rhaz]

IMO Hunt has played no better than Frost recently. I'm really surprised Frost was dropped and I don't see the point. He's still an inexperienced KPD and we need more games into him.

It says something that Salem was dropped and none of us are up in arms about it. He needs a big big big preseason where he stays fit, and a full season of stringing games together.

 

[Topkent]

IMO Hunt has played no better than Frost recently. I'm really surprised Frost was dropped and I don't see the point. He's still an inexperienced KPD and we need more games into him.

It says something that Salem was dropped and none of us are up in arms about it. He needs a big big big preseason where he stays fit, and a full season of stringing games together.

Frost has been a hell of a lot better than Hunt.

Salems a little at the cross roads for mine. Nice kick but still has a hell of a lot to work on to become a good footballer

 

[Bazza97]

Surprised Frost was dropped. Have really valued his speed in defence this year when defending and rebounding out of the D50. But there's obviously something he needs to work on in the VFL. Hoping he can come back in the side before the year is out.

 

[schmuttt]

Surprised Frost was dropped. Have really valued his speed in defence this year when defending and rebounding out of the D50. But there's obviously something he needs to work on in the VFL. Hoping he can come back in the side before the year is out.

Needs to actually use his height rather than playing as an oversized rebounding HBF. I've been saying it for a month now and obviously the coaches agree, Omac may be as slow as they come but Frost drops regulation uncontested marks and is a non-factor when competing against a tall in the air. Felt like his rebound has dropped off and last month he has had 39 disposals all up, needs to be doing better in that area too.

 

[Topkent]

Needs to actually use his height rather than playing as an oversized rebounding HBF. I've been saying it for a month now and obviously the coaches agree, Omac may be as slow as they come but Frost drops regulation uncontested marks and is a non-factor when competing against a tall in the air. Felt like his rebound has dropped off and last month he has had 39 disposals all up, needs to be doing better in that area too.

He was instrumental in the Carlton and Port wins. Down on form since but the absolutely pitiful midfield pressure hasn't helped. Also dropping him for not being a good full back is the same as dropping Watts for not being a good key forward.


Brayshaw in is bloody good news If true