Chapman gone

[Badesumofu]

Take a deep breath mate, time to log out. Clearly petrified of the Cats next week.

Woooosh!

 

[Southern Urchins]

Clearly different incidents and levels of impact. Calm down.

Calm down? lol
I'm sitting here smiling, rather enjoying taking the piss out of the posters who were typing ridiculous bile in the Franklin thread.
You were happy for the game to be soft when Buddy did it, now a Chapman suspension would mean the Bump is dead and the AFL is corrupt I suppose etc etc.
I personally couldn't give a shit, but it's amusing to watch the defences being mounted.
Tom Harley an AFL/Hawthorn stooge too?

 

[ScoobySnacks]

Does he have a record? If so it will be a big influence between reprimand and a week

 

[Southern Urchins]

I'm pretty sure next week isn't a "head is sacrosanct" week. It's every 3rd week, right?

Rock, paper, scissors more like it.

 

[alfy!]

You were happy for the game to be soft when Buddy did it, now a Chapman suspension would mean the Bump is dead and the AFL is corrupt I suppose etc etc.

As I've said, two different levels of impact. Buddy deserved one week for his, but Chapman's was slower and less impact. The opponent popped straight back up. Play on.

 

[Damon_3388]

How about we all come to a consensus of zero weeks, so that the AFL can see that the public don't think that action is worthy of suspension?

 

[alfy!]

How about we all come to a consensus of zero weeks, so that the AFL can see that the public don't think that action is worthy of suspension?

Done. Lock thread please moderators.

 

[Southern Urchins]

In a two horse race, always back self interest.
At least you know it's trying.

 

[hawkman]

As I've said, two different levels of impact. Buddy deserved one week for his, but Chapman's was slower and less impact. The opponent popped straight back up. Play on.

Different impact, Chapman jumped into it though so more likely to be reckless

 

[The GOAT]

If he gets two down to one, will the cats roll the dice with the appeal? Will be interesting

 

[The King!]

Should get off with an early plea

 

[alfy!]

If he gets two down to one, will the cats roll the dice with the appeal? Will be interesting

No chance.

 

[Micksy]

It was just a fortnight ago some Geelong supporters were foaming at the mouth wanting such petty incidents to get 3 weeks.

Derp, and we warned Dawks supporters that if they rub out Kelly for bumping Goddard that they would be next.

Life goes on.

 

[Micksy]

Does he have a record? If so it will be a big influence between reprimand and a week

Expired last week. So you're saying he's in the clear. Very noble of you. You are a credit to your team.

 

[Simon_Nesbit]

WOW. Lucky the media are so pro-Geelong I guess.

Franklin was hung-drawn and quartered by the time the game over. Meanwhile Chapman will apparently be free to play.

In a curious twist of timing, Chapman had 60points carry-over last week, so would have been season over.

There should be massive outrage if Chapman plays. Instead, anyone who dares suggest it will be labelled a whinger.

 

[Purple Suit]

Why are the fox footy team trying to get Chappy off? Eddie was going hard at Mayne and Dawson when he thought he would be playing us. Now he's making excuses.

 

[Micksy]

Why are the fox footy team trying to get Chappy off? Eddie was going hard at Mayne and Dawson when he thought he would be playing us. Now he's making excuses.

Dude, we're a week off playing you guys. Wouldn't you want Chappy in to take the Dawks to the limit?

Or are you so hell-bent on keeping your perfect run of 0 premierships alive, and that trophy case empty?

 

[winty]

Why are the fox footy team trying to get Chappy off?

Probably because there was nothing in it.

 

[Mr Meeseeks]

Chappy left the ground too. Buddy didnt.

 

[Puddy]

Comes down to money, Chapman plays, bigger crowd. He will get a small fine

 

[rdhopkins2]

1 week given it was almost identical to the Buddy hit.
Players have to bear in mind that if you bump & get the bloke high, they will be rolling the MRP roulette wheel.

 

[Purple Suit]

Dude, we're a week off playing you guys. Wouldn't you want Chappy in to take the Dawks to the limit?

Or are you so hell-bent on keeping your perfect run of 0 premierships alive, and that trophy case empty?

I want you guys to win as I think it will be an easier GF, but I also want fair media coverage and MRP. He should get a week to be fair. He shouldn't get two. The Chappy hit was easily as bad as Buddy's.

It just annoyed me at the start of the week that there was a media cloud over Freo players yet no one even spoke about Enright. They even replayed the footage during the game and the commentators ignored it.

 

[Mr Meeseeks]

Good pic showing comparison on the hawks fb page.

Cant share it here but they are near identical

 

[Boxhead_31]

If he played for any other side bar Geelong he would have no case to answer for,but given how the MRP have done everything they can to get Hawthorn a flag he will get 5 weeks

 

[Simon_Nesbit]

If he played for any other side bar Geelong he would have no case to answer for,but given how the MRP have done everything they can to get Hawthorn a flag he will get 5 weeks

How did you get through the mirror?