Chapman or Davey?

[Marns]

That's right, pr0n star. Calling davey inconsistent is a very uneducated guess. One thing missing in those stats would also be his tackles and 1%ers. He'd be one of the best in the league with them, and is a guy who can lift his teammates by doing them. Invaluable part of our team. Love'im.

Having said that, Chapman is a good player, but I dont watch enough of Geelong to vote in this one.

 

[ciaobella]

Perhaps watch Davey...then comment.

Don't be so spiteful and jealous.

What's your problem with people choosing Chapman over Davey RL? You say don't be so spiteful and jealous. We say don't be so bias and opinionated.

 

[catcozmo]

For me Chapman easily.
I under-rate him and im a geelong supporter. but watching his game agaisnt the Saints just shows how good this bloke is.
3 goals 27 touches handful of tackles and marks.
he has also been doing it for the best part of two years now.
Dont get me wrong im not sayin Davey doesnt do these things, and i can tell u as soon as he is near anyone with the ball i reackon he will tackle them.
But make sure you dont under-estimate Chapman's defenesive pressure, absolutly fantastic.
and if we talk about vision see Chapman's pass to ling in 3rd 3/4 just brillant.

But as others have said i dont see enough of Davey to apprecatie him fully. i do know he has massive amounts of talents, and class, but Chapman just bleeds geelong and its his spirit that is his best thing.

 

[RedLegs#5]

View Poll Results: Who would you take?
Chapman 36 60.00%
Davey 24 40.00%
Voters: 60. You have already voted on this poll

If you honestly believe the people on this site are a good indication of anything....then you're a sad person.

Well..I guess it is you.

Davey is better. Any club would pick him first. End of story.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Chapman's best is a lot better than Davey's.

Chapman's worse is also a lot better than Davey's

Chapman's average game sh1ts all over Davey's

 

[JUBJUB]

Davey is better. Any club would pick him first. End of story.

RedLegs,you've got to take this comedy tour of yours on the road.

 

[Unwritten_Law]

If you look half way down the page you will see a thread comparing Chapman and Guerra.

Can someone be around to bump this one up for me in a couple of years. Bloody hell.

 

[LongBomb]

Chapman is a good player...yes. However, anyone who would choose Chapman over Davey is either bias or knows little about football. Davey offers far more today and in the future.

Seriously people...

Someone is pretty new to the game by the sounds.

Chapman easily.

 

[goDees22]

Chapman's best is a lot better than Davey's.

Chapman's worse is also a lot better than Davey's

Chapman's average game sh1ts all over Davey's

Maybe, but you just cannot ing stand melbourne

 

[demondude]

haha fu geelong fans!! davey is a better player, the biasm coming from u ppl is tremendous..and no chapman does not sh*t all over davey, for those who have not seen davey he is f** brilliant

 

[RedLegs#5]

RedLegs,you've got to take this comedy tour of yours on the road.

Only if your forward line, coach and team spirit join me.

 

[Drummond]

Chapman by a long, long way.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Chapman proving time and time again, with every game, he is vastly superior to Davey

 

[afl genius]

Chapman is alot better than Davey for people to actully say Davey is better than Chappy you need to see a doctor, For those saying that chappy is better than davey must be bias shut the hell up. It is actully the Demons supporters that are bias surely you cant want a man who flash's out of games and does the easy stuff over a hard in and under player that marks and kicks goals that is one of the best tacklers going around

Case closed Chappy well ahead of davey

 

[captain subtext]

For those saying that chappy is better than davey must be bias shut the hell up.

Agree entirely genius

 

[The_Flying_Egg]

Davey is a lot quicker and more flashy and spectacular.

But Chappy is better. He's tougher, a better ball winner and a better midfielder. Nothing keeps him down, whatever happens to him he bounces straight up again

 

[Major Colvin]

Different players.

On the whole, Chapman is better. Does more damage on a consistent basis. However, I'd take Davey. Because as good as Chapman is midfield rover types like him are easier to come across than players like Davey who add something different to the side. Davey's adds a spark, offensive pressure and speed that makes opposition defenders uneasy.

So although Chapman is a little better, I'd take Davey.

 

[whirl]

I'd like to have them both, but I'd take Chapman first. I write this comfortable in the knowledge that the much vaunted Red Legs will think little of me, terrifying a prospect as that is.

 

[WeSt CoAsT EaGLeS]

Aaron Davey. Chapman's a player who works around the goals only, and the forward line is his only position. Meanwhile Davey, also around goal, can play midfield or back and has much more pace and height.

 

[Drummond]

Aaron Davey. Chapman's a player who works around the goals only, and the forward line is his only position. Meanwhile Davey, also around goal, can play midfield or back and has much more pace and height.

You're joking right? Surely.

Chapman always pushes up the groud, of his 32 possessions last night I'd say at least 10-15 were in the centre of the ground.

 

[Skeppersap]

Aaron Davey. Chapman's a player who works around the goals only, and the forward line is his only position. Meanwhile Davey, also around goal, can play midfield or back and has much more pace and height.

That is probably the most stupid, uneducated and ill-informed post I have ever read on Big Footy. When I see a post from you in the future I will know to skip over it because likelihood is that it will be pure rubbish like you just wrote.

Congratulations, you have proven yourself a pretender when it comes to talking about football.

 

[Skeppersap]

Aaron Davey. Chapman's a player who works around the goals only, and the forward line is his only position. Meanwhile Davey, also around goal, can play midfield or back and has much more pace and height.

Did you happen to see Chapmans lace out pass to Steve Johnson after running through the center of the ground last night? Then again, you probably do not know what lace out means?

 

[JUBJUB]

Aaron Davey. Chapman's a player who works around the goals only, and the forward line is his only position. Meanwhile Davey, also around goal, can play midfield or back and has much more pace and height.

Get your eyes checked.
You are waaaaaaaaaay off the mark,unless the opposition halfback line and the midfield counts as part of our forward line.

Just get a copy of last nights game and see how far off the mark you are.
If you've got any balls you'll come back and admit you got it horribly wrong.

 

[chapmanmagic35]

Aaron Davey. Chapman's a player who works around the goals only, and the forward line is his only position. Meanwhile Davey, also around goal, can play midfield or back and has much more pace and height.

Are you for real?

 

[chapmanmagic35]

haha fu geelong fans!! davey is a better player, the biasm coming from u ppl is tremendous..and no chapman does not sh*t all over davey, for those who have not seen davey he is f** brilliant

This guy is a moving comedy...have a look at all his posts everyone.

'Biasm"

Chapman is better by the length of the Nile River...