Opinion Charlie vs Weitering vs McKay

[Juddernaut08]

Charlie has been sensational in 2018 and is loved by the media and opposition alike.

McKay has been our best forward in 2019 and is leading the comp in contested marks.

Weitering is a boss down back, was the no.1 pick and is coming into his own.

Who you got?

 

[fizzkakz]

On current body of work, it's hard to go past Charlie. All have the potential to be multiple AA in their respective positions and have shown brilliance. But Charlie is the one who has done it more frequently to date. It's really hard to pick which one will go on to the be the best. Let's check in a decade...

Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk

 

[Jabba73]

What are we voting on?

Who we like?
Who is more important to the team?
Who is the best player?

 

[rampar]

Mckay will take the comp by the scruff of the neck.

 

[BigFrizz36]

Imagine if there was a list manager smart enough to nab all three of them in the one draft. That, my friends, would be something out of the ordinary.

 

[SurreyBlue]

They are all ours. That is all that matters.

 

[Juddernaut08]

What are we voting on?

Who we like?
Who is more important to the team?
Who is the best player?

Who you got? If you could only have 1 for the rest of their career.

 

[ferrisb]

Charlie McWeitering....

Almost impossible to choose, I can make a legitimate case for all three.

If I had to pick, maybe Curnow the Younger. Just.

 

[Jabba73]

In that case, Charlie.

Can play almost anywhere on the ground so can go get his own ball if the rest of it is not working. The others could be victims of the team around them, Charlie can change that with a stint on the ball or wing.

More than happy to have all three though

 

[Red Bull]

Walsh

 

[HARKER]

I have no idea but am happy to have Weitering in this conversation now........and maybe Cuningham eventually.

 

[BIGGUS 64]

Maybe I'm sucked in by the Kouta comparisons, but should Charlie achieve his full potential, he is a player who could make a significant impact wherever he is on the ground - forward, mid or back.

Having said that, it's such early days for all three. Who knows what will happen? Weiters could yet transition as a forward after all. Harry may end up a ruckman who rests in the forward line. What if Charlie has already peaked?

I'm just rapt we have all three and don't have to choose.

 

[Mr_Plow]

Refuse to choose. Should be a fun 10 years.

 

[Bearded Carpenter]

Battle Royale

 

[Robertio]

Battle Royale

I refuse to choose as well but the 2015 draft will bring us Premiership no 17.

 

[Iamcarlton]

Mckay in a landslide given time he's still blowing up imagine what he'll do when he's actually fit .
The attributes physically he has are astounding both now and even more given time .
Agility wise he's got it easily over the other 2 put another 3 or 4 kg on him get him fit with no ongoing injuries with another 20 or 30 games of development and its a no contest .
You can already see he's getting frees from the opposition player panicking when the ball gets kicked in front of him because of his height reach and agility .

 

[Arr0w]

Tough decision

While Charlie and McKay will always have more xfactor, I think Weitering will be more consistent and one day a future leader

Weitering for me

 

[HBF]

Agree with Arr0w on this one. Weitering is just having a cracking season in defence and is becoming the rock that will hold our defence together for years. I suspect he'll be more consistent than both Charlie and Harry.

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

I chose McKay but it doesn't feel right. Probably gonna change my vote when I do some more thinkin'.

 

[crazybear]

They are all ours. That is all that matters.

Safe to say SOS nailed that draft.

 

[RAPPA]

McKay over Charlie purely on form this year. if Charlie was playing like/building on last year, hard to go past him out of the two.

As for Weiters, we haven’t been competitive in our games this year because we’ve kicked big scores - it has been our defence keeping us in the game (yes we kicked a good score vs Dogs but our defense was solid in repelling attacks). He has been great this year.

Weiters+Jones & McKay+Curnow are/will be great partnerships at either end of the ground

 

[OnceWeWereKings]

Premierships are built around rock solid defence, Weitering could be the diamond amongst the rocks.
If he continues to improve he will be our most important player.

 

[Mr_Plow]

I am with arr0w on this. Weitering's combination of on and off field professionalism, consistency, leadership and maturity will only be surpassed by Walsh.

You build teams around those 2 rocks.

 

[thylacine60]

McKay, to the wing position on the member's stand side.

 

[thylacine60]

think results may be skewed by recent events.....