MVP Ching Rd 11 v Melbourne

[dogwatch]

Disappointing effort.

See if you can find 5 players to give votes to. 5-4-3-2-1.

Pups tonight were

Butler​

McNeil​

Naughton​

Weightman​

B Smith​

Garcia​

​

And you can nominate a player for the Clay Smith if you like - the most courageous player.

 

[Testekill]

5. English
4. Keath
3. Roarke Smith
2. Macrae
1. Duryea

That's how bad we played. Roarke has to get votes because he was one of the few players that didn't lower his head.

 

[go you pups]

5. English (great return Timmy)
4. Roarke Smith (had a fair dinkum dip, got it 20 times, used it well)
3. Hunter (made himself an option forward of centre most of the night, no other mids wanted to present in space it seemed)
2. Naughton (worked hard all game)
1. Macrae I guess as I'm really struggling to find a 5th bloke who deserves a vote

Rebounders and mids behind the ball lost us this one, poor poor poor ball use, handed them easily their winning margin plus more in turnovers, went wide far too often and didn't want to take the game on

 

[Libba39]

Hard....

5. Naughton
4. English
3. Macrae
2. B.Smith
1. Dale (only because he kept running)

 

[threenewpadlocks]

5. English
4. Hunter
3. R. Smith
2. Macrae
1. Crozier

 

[VL3OJ]

5. English
4. Hunter
3. R Smith
2. Macrae
1. Derailleur

3. B, Smith
2. Naughton
1. Begrudgingly Flea

CS B. Smith

 

[StringyDog]

5 English
4 Macrae
3 Hunter
2 R Smith
1 Naughton

3 Naughton
2 Smith
1 Weightman

 

[WallyStringhaus]

5. Hunter
4. Keath
3. English
2. Naughton
1. Macrae

 

[Jeff 1975]

5 - J. Macrae
4 - M. Bontempelli
3 - B. Dale
2 - L. Hunter
1 - H. Crozier

3 - B. Smith
2 - C. Weightman
1 - A. Naughton

C - M. Bontempelli

 

[yebiga]

5 Hunter
4 Daniel
3 English
2 Dale
1 Macrae

 

[SayerTheCreator]

5 English
4 Macrae
3 Hunter
2 R Smith
1 Naughton

3 Naughton
2 Smith
1 Weightman

same

don’t know how Bont had 30 touches

 

[Triple Baileys]

5. English
4. Macrae
3. Bont
2. Naughton
1. Bailey Smith

edit: CSA: Roarke.

 

[Boyd oh Boyd]

5. Roarke
4. English
3. Macrae
2. Hunter
1. Naughton

3. Naughton
2. Weightman
1. N/A

Clay: Roarke

 

[dogwatch]

5. Macrae
4. Bont
3. English
2. Hunter
1. Dale

Pups
3. Naughton
2. Smith
1. Weightman

CSA: Roarke Smith

 

[Dogforever]

5. Macrae
4. English
3. Bontempelli
2. Naughton
1. Cordy

CS: Smith R

 

[bobs head soup]

English
Macrae
Dale
R.Smith
Bont

Naughton
Weightman
B.Smith

 

[Snarls Barkley]

5. Lachie Hunter
4. Roarke Smith
3. Marcus Bontempelli
2. Jack Macrae
1. Tim English

3. Cody Weightman
2. Aaron Naughton
1. Bailey Smith

 

[DognBones]

5 Macrae
4 Hunter
3 English
2 Bont
1 Dale

3 Naughton
2 B Smith
1 Weightman

 

[Mojorisin]

5. Hunter
4. R.smith (only two with a 4 qtr effort)
3. English
2. Dale (minus first qtr disposals)
1. Macrea (also minus first qtr brain fades)

 

[Walsh Bay]

5 Hunter
4 English
3 R Smith
2 Macrae
1 Crozier

Suspend the pups vote for a week, pickings too slim

 

[SirBont]

5 Bont
4 English
3 Macrae
2 Hunter
1 Naughton

Pups
3 Naughton
2 B Smith
1 Weightman

 

[Chalky White]

5 Hunter
4 English
3 R Smith
2 Macrae
1 Crozier

Suspend the pups vote for a week, pickings too slim

Exactly how my votes would be. Thought Hunter clearly our best.

 

[dogwatch]

...
1. Derailleur

...

I'm taking that to be Duryea.

 

[VL3OJ]

I'm taking that to be Duryea.

Yes dogwatch - a key cog last night and a chain player.

 

[dogwatch]

Yes dogwatch - a key cog last night and a chain player.

Well spoke. For a player normally considered in the bottom bracket he deserves having his tyres pumped up.