Ching - Round 5

[wedesweiler]

1 westy (master)
2 crossy (and apprentice)
3 darce (master)
4 big will (and apprentice)
5 harro (master)

 

[OldSchool]

Please explain yourself!

Sorry I thought it was deliberate.
Your votes didn't follow the normal 5, 4, 3, 2, 1. I think it went 5, 4, 3, 4, 5.

 

[The Doctor]

5. Darcy
4. West
3. Grant (the inspiration)
2. Minson
1. Harris

Pups

3. Minson
2. Cross
1. McMahon

 

[(910)]

5. Grant
4. Darcy
3. West
2. Johnson
1. Smith

Pups

3. Minson
2. Cooney
1. Cross

 

[Turtleman3]

5. Darcy
4. West
3. Cross
2. Minson
1. McMahon

 

[stmookeyj]

5. Darcy
4. Minson
3. West
2. Johnson
1. Giansiracusa

 

[wedesweiler]

5. Darcy
4. West
3. Cross
2. Minson
1. McMahon

I watched the game again & was thinking I should have put Jordie in the best
players too. Good call Turtleman3

 

[MrChristo]

I watched the game again & was thinking I should have put Jordie in the best
players too. Good call Turtleman3

I don't think I could pick out 5 'best', but definately want to acknowledge McMahon and Guido.

I've said they'd both been ordinary so far, but worth were very good yesterday.
Hopefully they can get some consistancy now and perform every week.

 

[dlanor the dog]

5 Darcy
4 Minson
3 West
2 Cross
1 McMahon

PUPS
3 Minson
2 Cross
1 Cooney

 

[C.E.Lovett]

By OldSchoo;
Sorry I thought it was deliberate.
Your votes didn't follow the normal 5, 4, 3, 2, 1. I think it went 5, 4, 3, 4, 5.

Reason accepted and votes amended.

 

[C.E.Lovett]

Nice to see somebody put McMahon amongst the votes. He did play a great game but he doesn't get amongst the votes very often. He seemed to try very hard and gave us a lot of drive through the centre with good run.

Even last year when he played most games he got practically least votes per game on average than any player.

Good game Jordie!

 

[Gilbee]

Nice to see somebody put McMahon amongst the votes. He did play a great game but he doesn't get amongst the votes very often. He seemed to try very hard and gave us a lot of drive through the centre with good run.

Even last year when he played most games he got practically least votes per game on average than any player.

Good game Jordie!

He was great indeed. Had a terrific piece of play in defence where he put his body on the line, preventing a McLeod goal, and then got the ball out which resulted in a goal down the other end. Kicked well with his right and left foot as well.

 

[Borgsta]

5 Darcy
4 West
3 McMahon
2 Minson
1 Smith

Pups
3 Mison
2 Cross
1 B. Murphy

 

[angry steve]

so hard this week!


5. Darcy
4.Westy
3.Minson
2. Guido
1.McMahon

 

[amnesiac]

5. Darcy - game breaking performance
4. West - 38 touches, bad luck to miss out on the bog
3. Cross- hard at the ball all night. top game
2. Giansiracusa - underated game by many. did well. provided drive
1. Johnson - splendid as always

Bad luck to murph, gilbs and bubba. great games

 

[X_box_X]

I think Smith is stiff not to be receiving many votes.

5) Darcy
4) West
3) Minson
2) Smith
1) Giansiracusa

3) Minson
2) Cross
1) Cooney

 

[Raw Toast]

so hard this week!

Oh to have it be so hard every week, for the same reasons of course

5. Darcy
4. West
3. Guido
2. Johnson
1. Minson

Apologies to Smith, Cross and Harris.

Pups
3: Minson
2: Cross
1: McMahon

 

[Templeton31]

Finally got time to watch the video.....

5 Darcy
4 West
3 Minson
2 McMahon
1 Johnson

Pups
3 Minson
2 McMahon
1 Cross

 

[Dogs 13]

So difficult that our match report on AFL.com named 12 in our best, but we can only have 5.

5. Darcy - the big target we should have as much as possible
4. West - West being West
3. Cross - great job under the packs
2. Minson - allowed us to have a big target in front of goal and we didn't really lose anything in the ruck
1. Johnno - not having to be the go to man up forward, the combination working the way it should. Icing on the cake.

Apologies to sooo many others.

Pups
3. Minson
2. Cooney
1. Morris

Are Cross and Jordy pups ?

 

[Captain Sensible]

5 Darcy
4 West
3 Minson
2 McMahon
1 Cross


Pups
3 Minson
2 Cross
1 McMahon

 

[Dog Town]

5-Darcy:
4-West:
3-Cross:
2-Minson
1-Johnson

 

[scooter600x]

Are Cross and Jordy pups ?

Yep. Both born in '83.

 

[Top Dog]

5. Big dog Darcy
4. Wild Westy
3. The Monster
2. Crossy
1. Smurf

PUPS
3. The Monster
2. Cross
1. McMahon

 

[Palace03]

5. Darcy
4. Cross
3. West
2. Minson
1. Morris

Pups
3. Cross
2. Minson
1. Morris