Chris Bryan vs Cam Cloke

[WEARECOLLINGWOOD!]

They are both hacks & have limited time in football..

The ket difference is that Bryan is a back up ruckman & not in the pies best 22, where as Cam Cloke is the blues CHF and easily in there best 22..

I think that says alot about where the two clubs are at!

 

[Marklar_33]

I voted Cloke, but Im happier with Bryan... go figure


PS. Its because Cloke was the biggest soft **** at the Pies

 

[mediumsizered]

They are both hacks & have limited time in football..

The ket difference is that Bryan is a back up ruckman & not in the pies best 22, where as Cam Cloke is the blues CHF and easily in there best 22..

I think that says alot about where the two clubs are at!

Which ruckman was he backing up? Wood was running around in the VFL while Bryan was in the seniors. Bryan played 17 games in the 2008 season, whereas he played a total of 16 games in his 2 seasons at Carlton. Hardly the record of someone who isn't in Collingwood's best 22.

 

[SouthSwans]

I'd take Bryan at Sydney before Cloke.

 

[pickman]

Bryan's a better ruckman but Cloke is the better all round player. While easy to bag both, Ithink both players have given their current clubs solid, if not spectacular service.

 

[Blue Dimension]

Neither.

I rated Bryan early in his career at the Blues but hasn't really gone far at all.

Cloke is an honest trier who gives his all but that's about it for mine. I have never really rated him as a player and don't think i will ever get to.

 

[Gozz]

I'd give the nod to Clokey based on his buff, ripped body.

 

[kingross29]

Cloke just but neither of these 2 are AFL standard

 

[Mrs Meddles]

They are both pretty average players. I'd go for chris just because he can drive his car without causing sh*t for the club! Just goes to show the lack of decent dinosaurs when these two get a game.

 

[notting18]

Cloke. If he had stayed fit I think he would've been a pretty good ordinary player...

 

[rotten pie]

Cloke: is an ok shot for goal but hardly the ruckman you can build around. It seems like he's taken all the loose change out of his purse witch has helped his shoulder stay in place at Carlton.

Bryan: very dodgy indeed. Only reason for him to be on the list this year is back up incase of injury or lack of form. With any luck Keeffe will go alright in his first year in the VFL and Bryan wont be needed from next year on.