Chris Judd eye gauging Michael Rischitelli

[RuckRyder]

I wish Carlton's Captain was a diver who suddenly finds his legs and the courage to take out players with a gutless bump.

Or hitting three players using his armguard.

w***er.

What are your thoughts on this eye gouging incident from your captain?

 

[Chadwiko]

Doesn't look good boys.

In a contest like that, there is absolutely no need/reason to reach down and stick your hand in a blokes face.

With his history of this and the recent "the head is sacrosanct in AFL" policy, I can honestly see Judd getting 2-3 weeks for this.

 

[Illinois Nazi]

At least last time around Judd was on the ground and trying to get an opponent off himself - you could understand why he went the "facial grope". But this one, going over to a player on the ground and bending over him to grab at his face, it's just bizarre.

 

[Walshy_The_Goat]

Finger came close to the eye region, but looked more like a case of Judd pushing Risch's head into the turf.

Should be looked at, but nothing in it.

 

[Danog]

1 or 2 weeks.

 

[The Coach]

Doesn't look good boys.

In a contest like that, there is absolutely no need/reason to reach down and stick your hand in a blokes face.

With his history of this and the recent "the head is sacrosanct in AFL" policy, I can honestly see Judd getting 2-3 weeks for this.

Of course it was unnecessary and it does not look good but it was not as bad as your Photoshop effort LOL

He has done so much damage to Rischi's head do you think he will get off with only 3 LOL

 

[I LOVE THE CFC]

This will be my last ever post on BF (like anyone cares and it has nothing to do with the lead we coughed up) What Chris Judd did tonight is so low and if you are real human and seen where the ball was and where his fingers went you would come to realise what a dirty act that was. I am as passionate as the next man and have remained loyal and faithful through-out all our dark times but when I saw that, that was the end! I respect Judd as a great footballer and I will continue to buy a CFC membership and I know we are on the right track but I just cannot except that from someone that not only has prior history but is the leader of the club I love so much.

So say what you want and call me anything but if you think there is nothing in it, you are deluding yourself as far as I'm concered.


Goodbye Big Footy ---- R.I.P I LOVE THE CFC 6.9.09






Thanks for the memories

 

[The Coach]

This will be my last ever post on BF (like anyone cares and it has nothing to do with the lead we coughed up) What Chris Judd did tonight is so low and if you are real human and seen where the ball was and where his fingers went you would come to realise what a dirty act that was. I am as passionate as the next man and have remained loyal and faithful through-out all our dark times but when I saw that, that was the end! I respect Judd as a great footballer and I will continue to buy a CFC membership and I know we are on the right track but I just cannot except that from someone that not only has prior history but is the leader of the club I love so much.

So say what you want and call me anything but if you think there is nothing in it, you are deluding yourself as far as I'm concered.


Goodbye Big Footy ---- R.I.P I LOVE THE CFC 6.9.09






Thanks for the memories

Pt. 1 Footballers can seem like Gods but they are just human
Pt. 2 When the heat is on - we can all do silly things - that is all it was - nothing more, nothing less
Pt. 3 In the aftermath of a disappointing loss you are emotional and you too are behaving stupidly
Pt.4 There is a lot more to life than football

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Another Eagle who still has not got over losing him

yeah, it wouldn't have to do with the fact there's a photo with his finger in his eye, moron

 

[RoJo Junior]

Hes in big trouble i think. He wasnt even remotely in that contest to begin with, and he just happened to wander over and touch up Rischitelli's face while he was defenceless to block as he had a Carlton player wrapped up in a tackle. Quite odd thing to do and worthy of a couple of weeks i would've thought. Much worse than the incident with Campbell Brown.

 

[Tish]

if he gets weeks so does the bloke who drops his knees into a uncontested possession. If judd did do anything with the eyes, was to save his team mate who was getting roughed up

 

[Stig O'Hara]

So what.

This bloke is dogged from the second he turns up.

They nail him for that, big fizz,
lag in the rest of the dogs that hang off him.

**** 'em, he gets murdered every week.

 

[Tish]

wow, I watched the video again. All it is, is Judd pushing the guy by the face into the ground, or at least trying too...


Maybe if the umpires didn't hand Brisbane the game he wouldn't have cared?


Yes we were shit in the fina 1/4. but does not make up for bias.

Yes an EX AFL umpire even smsed me today ( who is my mate) and said it was terrible)

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Trace a camera on Judd for 100 minutes,
you will get 20 frees, and 3 reports.

Over his whole career, you will get that.

Frigging garbage.

 

[pinky951]

would be spewing if I had money on him for the brownlow, he's gone.

 

[Mr.Kennedy]

We were all worried as he had ****ed up... should have been rubbed out fortunately Brown purged himself and St Christopher got off... lucky break.

Still doesn't mean he was not guilty.

But your point is valid we were all happy he got off.

You bet , but he doesn't wear our jumper any more so we no longer care. Let the MRP take its course.

This time he will go ... aint karma a bitch.

WTF?

 

[Mr.Kennedy]

2 people I watched the game with say that Rischetelli had a hold of Judds balls. Personally I did not see this, IF true then I am glad he gave him a touch up. If untrue then I will take it back.

 

[Jisha]

Of course it was unnecessary and it does not look good but it was not as bad as your Photoshop effort LOL

This is why I love Carlton supporters.

 

[Murph_The_Smurf]

Hey no need to get feisty, you got to admit that was a dog-act, id never have thought he would do something like that, disgusting!!!

The funny thing is , he has and in an eagles jumper lol

 

[Murph_The_Smurf]

wow, I watched the video again. All it is, is Judd pushing the guy by the face into the ground, or at least trying too...


Maybe if the umpires didn't hand Brisbane the game he wouldn't have cared?


Yes we were shit in the fina 1/4. but does not make up for bias.

Yes an EX AFL umpire even smsed me today ( who is my mate) and said it was terrible)

o0o0oo0o Must of been rigged then

 

[DerpWerls]

2 people I watched the game with say that Rischetelli had a hold of Judds balls. Personally I did not see this, IF true then I am glad he gave him a touch up. If untrue then I will take it back.

Rischetelli grabbed his jumper above his shorts, there was no contact to Judd's plums. You can see it from both angles. Also it looks like he grabbed Judd's jumper because he wasn't happy about getting his eyeballs pushed in.

[youtube]HSd3YUxdp-U[/youtube]

if he gets weeks so does the bloke who drops his knees into a uncontested possession. If judd did do anything with the eyes, was to save his team mate who was getting roughed up

Mitch Clark? This comment probably has some merit to it, Judd gets off and somehow Mitch Clark gets suspended.. lol, eye gouging Rischetelli will not help Grigg in that contest I'm afraid.

 

[Rick2]

Trace a camera on Judd for 100 minutes,
you will get 20 frees, and 3 reports.

lucky for him they don't keep a camera on him!

 

[a_fighting_fury]

I think it will get looked at, looked pretty deliberate and its not the first time he has been accused of this either...

Yes.
Yes.
And unfortunately Yes again.

When I saw it I didnt think much od it as there was very little reaction from Rischitelli, so the MRP may dismiss it on those grounds. But I must admit it's something I never never expected to see from the Juddmeister! He's one of my fav AFL players.

 

[jonesy86]

You can't really argue he was pushing his head/face as it's quite clear the palm of his hand was elevated and his fingers were going to work all over his face.

 

[qldbluesman_43]

Because it's such a weird event wouldn't they have to get Rischitelli to at least say yes he eye gauged me? You can't actually truly tell what happened.

I would think for something like this to suspend him they would need Rischitelli to say yes he touched my eye because if he doesn't then the evidence is that Judd moved his hand towards Rischitelli's face and may or may not have done something.