Again, I'm not everyone else. So don't bring it up the same shitty argument like it's facts. Also you keep bringing up the past, I'm talking future..
There is nothing in your posts that tell me why Scott is the man to lead us back up the ladder. You're just bringing up the past like it was last year. We have been poor in a lot of areas that matter for a long time and it's concerning we don't fix it.
Injuries, retirements all of those are things that ANY coach would have gone through with us. Yes he got us a flag, no one is deny that... BUT I"M TALKING NOW AND FUTURE. I have not judged Scott in this thread until last night, because now I share the concerns about our future and I question if Scott is the right man for the job.
Your post is illogical and extremely contradicting
1.
"don't bring it up the same shitty argument like it's facts"- it is a fact that we were 81 points behind early in the 3rd quarter of a prelim final with an old side that then went on to the lose the best player in the game.
2. "
Also you keep bringing up the past, I'm talking future.." - the makeup of a clubs list isn't based around decisions made over the previous 12 months but rather decisions made over the previous 10 years .For example our 2007-2011 premierships sides for the most part was based around decision made from 1999-2002.Conversly we are still feeling the impact of all those players we have lost over the past 5 years and being denied early draft picks for longer than any other club .
3.
"There is nothing in your posts that tell me why Scott is the man to lead us back up the ladder" The problem is your judging Scott and our side though the wrong lens. I suspect that the only evidence that your willing to except for Scott being the right man to coach us is evidence that suggest we are currently performing like a top 4 side .We are not a top 4 side , we are a 5th-8th side in transition who has been hit hard with injuries and been given a tough draw.
Most Geelong supporters can except that we are not a premiership contender but struggle to except the consequences of this .For example they get upset when we lose to sides who we should beat , they get upset when they see players playing in positions they are not idealy suited to , they get upset over players being selected who don't seem to be up to the required standard and they get upset when they see a pattern of mistakes. These are all common symptoms of a side who is in transition/rebuilding .
4
.With regards to your last paragraph I am also about the future , I strongly believe we are heading in the right direction .The reasons why you are not optimistic is because you are judging us though the lens of a side who is contending for a premiership rather than a side who is in a transition/rebuild stage.