I don't know why its so bloody hard for people on this board to understand why Freo have had the better of us over the past few years .
Freo have a midfield with Sandialnds,Fyfe,Mundy and Barlow in it plus a good support crew .Their midfield is too good for ours .
I was also at that game over in the Brownlow stand and I never heard anyone in the crowd say the coaching staff thinks we will win on merit .Players changed positions more than 20 times a quarter like the do in every game. Unless you have access to footage from the top of the grandstand on replay than your not going to pick up any structural changes.
Perhaps you can tell me what influence Chapman had once he came onto the ground ?
You guys have got no idea how to run a successful club , go and talk to Frank Costa and Brian Cook and they will tell you how important stability is at a football club .All you guys want to do is destabilise the club and turn it into a club that nobody wants to work at . If you guys had your way we would become and second rate club.
Freo have a midfield with Sandialnds,Fyfe,Mundy and Barlow in it plus a good support crew .Their midfield is too good for ours .
I was also at that game over in the Brownlow stand and I never heard anyone in the crowd say the coaching staff thinks we will win on merit .Players changed positions more than 20 times a quarter like the do in every game. Unless you have access to footage from the top of the grandstand on replay than your not going to pick up any structural changes.
Perhaps you can tell me what influence Chapman had once he came onto the ground ?
You guys have got no idea how to run a successful club , go and talk to Frank Costa and Brian Cook and they will tell you how important stability is at a football club .All you guys want to do is destabilise the club and turn it into a club that nobody wants to work at . If you guys had your way we would become and second rate club.
You argued that Fremantle had a superior midfield to us, yet in that game we still had premiership midfielders in Corey, Bartel, Kelly, Johnson, Selwood, Chapman, Stokes, Duncan as well as young players in Motlop, Caddy and Guthrie; Still pretty capable I think.
We were standing right behind the goals and trust me we saw everything that was happening or wasn't happening.
BTW Paul Chapman had 11 possessions and 5 tackles in a little over a quarter and the week after he was B.O.G against Port Adelaide so imagine if he had of played a full game....
I'm going to give you my honest appraisal of Chris Scott as a coach;
I think he did a great job getting the team up in 11' because I'm sure they would have been both physically and mentally drained during that offseason.
I think he needs to be more proactive as a game-day coach and stop playing players out of position.
Hopefully with these new inclusions, a healthy list and another preseason we will get a better indication of what our game plan is supposed to resemble.
Absolutely I think he can improve as a coach and I hope he becomes a multiple premiership winning one for this club, but i do not agree with your theory on him being flawless and not needing to accept any responsibility for our recent history.

