Well to use a Rumsfeldism there are known knowns and known unknowns - Scott not getting us a flag IMO is a known known, our next coach getting us a flag is a known unknown. I'd rather not be certain of success with the possibility of it under a new coach than the tiresome certainty we won't be there with Scott again.
Do you know what I know?
That posters like you and BiggyBoy are complete dickheads!
You have never given Chris Scott a chance, not even from day one. Of course you think Chris Scott has failed, because you will never admit it if he had succeeded.
If Scott coached Geelong to ten flags in a row, you and BiggyBoy would still want him sacked. You hate the man's guts, for God knows what reason, and you will never admit that he has made some good decisions.
Go on, I challenge you. Name me one thing that you give Chris Scott credit for (and no smarmy, backhanded compliments). I mean a decision that you actually agreed with him doing.
What, you can't. Didn't think so, because even if you did, you would never admit it. Since you know everything about coaching Geelong, don't you?
You call yourself "BlightyCats". What, you want Malcolm Blight to still be coach? That time is past. I was a fan of Blight, but he failed us in three Grand Finals. Chris Scott has "won" a flag for us.
Would you prefer Bomber to still be there? Well, guess what. Bomber didn't want us anymore. It isn't like the club sacked him. He CHOSE to leave. If you want to blame someone for us having Scott as coach, then blame Bomber, since if he hadn't left, the coaching job wouldn't be there for Scott to take over.
Besides, you bag some of the youngsters who didn't go onto anything under Scott. What about Bomber, who saw something in spuds like Charlie Gardiner, Henry Playfair and Mark Blake? Wasn't David Loats recruited under Bomber's watch as well?
No, Bomber preferred to leave us to be Hird's bum sniffer at the Injectors, and it all turned to dust. The kharma bus couldn't hit Bomber hard enough.
What, you want Ken "One-Trick Pony" Hinkley? A guy who promised so much and delivered so little, and became the Port Adelaide players' bitch in the process.
Any moaning you make about how Scott has let us down falls on deaf ears to me, because you and BiggyBoy complain about him, no matter what.
What you should want, is for Chris Scott to prove you wrong, and coach us to more flags, because any coach taking us to flags is a good thing, rather than wanting Scott to fail, and someone replace him. But then, you refuse to even credit him with the 2011 flag.
So why don't you and BiggyBoy save yourself the frustration, show your true colors, and go join another club instead? No true Geelong supporter would want a coach to fail, because then that means that the team and the players fail as well. I hated Gary Ayres, but I still would have rather have had him win me over by coaching us to a flag in 1995, than have him fail and get sacked. True supporters want success, not hope for failure so that a coach they don't like will get sacked.