Clement or Scarlett

[richyman]

Whos the better backman Clement or Scarlett

 

[Coin_Toss]

Clement without fear.

Scarlett is overrated.

 

[JUBJUB]

Scarlett without fear.

Clement is overrated.

 

[brett_go_cats]

Scarlett without fear.

Clement is overrated.

what he said

 

[Headless]

Clement without fear.

Scarlett is overrated.

What he said.

 

[Ozzie72]

scarlett without doubt will go down as one of the best full back's ever

 

[dids4]

you've really got to wonder how geelong suck so hard - their fans claim every player on their list is a 'star' or 'one of the best ever'.

LOL ling.

BTW - clement easily.

 

[richyman]

its very close but i actualy think scarlett

 

[Belly]

you've really got to wonder how geelong suck so hard - their fans claim every player on their list is a 'star' or 'one of the best ever'.

LOL ling.

BTW - clement easily.

You can't be serious, not one person who supports Geelong will claim Ling is a star. We have 3 "stars" Chapman, Ablett and Scarlett. Some others are good players, but these 3 are the only ones cats fans say are stars.

Stop making up bull****

 

[rumblah]

scarlett without doubt will go down as one of the best full back's ever

yeh i agree BUT this year hasnt been one that will go on his mantlepiece

 

[Inferno]

you've really got to wonder how geelong suck so hard - their fans claim every player on their list is a 'star' or 'one of the best ever'.

LOL ling.

BTW - clement easily.

hahahaha. Good one... Do you have anything to back that up or are you just taking a guess?

The only "stars" at Geelong are the 3 Belly said (GAJ, Chapman and Scarlett) and maybe Corey. Ling is will be a star when we play Scarlett at Full Forward.

Oh and on topic Scarlett even tho hes had an off year.

 

[richyman]

Scarlett- 6 Votes
Clement- 3 Votes

 

[dynasty]

clement by a mile scarlett is to overrated

 

[chapmanmagic35]

Hahahahahahahaha Hahahahahahahahaha Hahahahahahahahaha

Did I just see a couple of people post 'Scarlett is overrated'?

Oh dear me, that doesn't warrant an explanation.

I'd take Scarlett 10/10 - but Clement is a gun.

 

[duckboy]

One's a full back and one's a mid-size backman. Why are we comparing them? For me, they're both amongst the best in their position and probably deserve to be in and around All-Australian selection. Neither has had their best year though, although neither has had a bad year either. If I had to choose who I'd have, Scarlett, because we already have J Bowden to fill the Clement role.

 

[JUBJUB]

because we already have J Bowden to fill the Clement role.

Comparing Bowden to Clement.That's a sin.
That would be like comparing Kent Kingsley to Tony Lockett.

 

[JoffaMan]

Comparing Bowden to Clement.That's a sin.
That would be like comparing Kent Kingsley to Tony Lockett.

Whatever you reckon, you moron.

 

[catcozmo]

Well its obvious all us Geelong supports will say scarlett, while all the Pie supporters will say Clement, i reackon its the neautral supportors who will be the best way to gauge this.

 

[Kickin_Goals]

Wow a poll where I get to actually select the collingwood player....
Clement but only really a whisker in it.

Geelong have plenty of would be stars not performing, massive underachievers...