club songs rate Top three/Bottom three

[Power Point]

Top three club songs
1.Freo - pretty good song for such a bad team
2.Port- as above
3.Richmond- as above above

Bottom three
1.Melbourne- nothing worse then copying american anthem tone
2.West Coast- I don't like my own teams song
3.Collingwood- just annoys me this one

 

[dave_27]

Geez Fremantle and Port Adelaide top 2?? Melbourne the worst?

Your way off!

 

[lions_den]

Top three club songs
1.Richmond - Can't beat it
2.Brisbane - The music is regarded as some of the very best ever written, thank you France
3.North - Pretty good

Bottom three
1.Fremantle - A joke really. Freo heave ho? lol
2.West Coast- Dead set sounds like a Wiggles song. I'm sure it would stimulate kids, but not much else. LOL @ the bass
3. Adelaide - Dull

 

[mighty tiges]

Top three club songs
1. Richmond .
2. North - the full version. Being Victoria's theme song as well helps
3. Sydney - shake down the thunder from the sky is a great line

Bottom three
1. Freo - heave ho
2. WC - must be tone deaf across the Nullabor
3. Adel - goes on and on with the same monotonous tone

 

[EagleMan87]

Top 3:

1. Richmond
2. Melbourne
3. Sydney

Bottom 3:

16. Port Adelaide
15. Fremantle
14. Adelaide

Even if West Coast's song is bad, I can't dislike it; it means we've won!

 

[RUNVS]

I always liked the Richmond song.

 

[J_Moore]

What a bizarre OP.

Best.
1) North Melbourne
2) Melbourne
3) Carlton

Worst
1) Fremantle
2) Port Adelaide
3) West Coast

 

[bluesforever]

Best

1. Carlton
2. Collingwood
3. Melbourne

Worst

1. West Coast
2. Fremantle
3. Port Adelaide

 

[Geoff]

Geez Fremantle and Port Adelaide top 2?? Melbourne the worst?
Your way off!

Victorians have no cultural standing what so ever.

[youtube]kK5XBaslNd0[/youtube]

 

[walhawk]

Top three club songs

Bottom three
1.Melbourne- nothing worse then copying american anthem tone
2.West Coast- I don't like my own teams song
3.Collingwood- just annoys me this one

Actually most of the traditional club songs are traditional anthems/battle songs.

1. Swans
2. Tiges
3. Hawks

14. Cats
15. Eagles
16. Dockers

 

[WCErevival]

Top 3

1. Richmond
2. Carlton
3. Sydney

Bottom 3

1. Freo
2. Collingwood
3. Bulldogs (cant be that good if i can never remember it)

Does the same person sing all the Victorian ones?

While I like the Eagles song it is a bit different to all the others. Seems a bit odd when I actually think about it.

 

[Ochre]

Best
1. Richmond
Daylight
2. Geelong
3. West Coast (the old version)

Worst
1. port
2. freo
3. crows

 

[StringyDog]

Best;

Richmond
North Melbourne
Geelong

Richmond easily best song, pity don't get to hear it much

Worst;

West Coast
Fremantle
Port Adalaide

Really Nothing comes close to those WA-nkers

 

[Rack Watts]

Best
1. North Melbourne - Just for recreations sake.
2. Richmond - Can't argue with it.
3. Melbourne - It's the anthem for me and for you. (even though it's rude for me not to put you first)
Swans' too, quite a catchy tune.

Worst
1. Fremantle - ARRRRRGH MY FACE!
2. Brisbane - France.... *spits*
3. Adelaide - Didn't mind it before finals

 

[The_JUDDERNAUT]

ill leave my team out for obvious reasons...

Best:
1: Richmond- actually requires willpower to not chant 'yellow and black' before the game, obviously its not heard after.
2: St Kilda- can't go wrong with jazz
3: Melbourne- not sure why but it seems to work, unlike Bailey's gameplan.

Worst:
1: Freo- self explanatory
2: Collingwood- cakewalk? excuse me??
3: Port- uninspiring piece of crap

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Freo comfortably the worst. Seems like it was a bit of a stop-gap for them to use initially while they were thinking of a song to make their own full time (like our embarrassing Here-we-go, Camry Crow one). But, fifteen years later.... still using it. Couldn't The Panics or someone pen something for them?

Ours is boring and completely uninspiring.

West Coast's also a dreadful song.

Love Richmond, Sydney and Brisbane's with the Bombers a close fourth.

 

[DrJon]

Actually most of the traditional club songs are traditional anthems/battle songs.

1. Swans
2. Tiges
3. Hawks

14. Cats
15. Eagles
16. Dockers

No, they're not, they're naff show tunes, music hall ditties or popular tunes from the early years of the century. Lily of Laguna, Yankee Doodle Dandy, The Toreador song from Carmen, Join in the Chorus and Goodbye Dolly Grey were the 'Hit Me Baby One More Time' or the 'Pump It' of their era. They aren't 'battle songs.

I appreciate it gives Richmond fans something to hang onto but do we really need another thread about rating the club songs? Everyone knows that 95% of BigFooty poster thinks Freo's song is sh*t.

 

[Huntercrow]

No, they're not, they're naff show tunes, music hall ditties or popular tunes from the early years of the century. Lily of Laguna, Yankee Doodle Dandy, The Toreador song from Carmen, Join in the Chorus and Goodbye Dolly Grey were the 'Hit Me Baby One More Time' or the 'Pump It' of their era. They aren't 'battle songs.

I appreciate it gives Richmond fans something to hang onto but do we really need another thread about rating the club songs? Everyone knows that 95% of BigFooty poster thinks Freo's song is sh*t.

Yeah its s**t but nothing a premiership can`t fix.

 

[cradle of filth]

Top 3
1. Richmond - Bangs out a very catchy and passionate chorus. You can sing this one loud.

2. Carlton - The slowest but still one of the best. Don't ask me why, but it's just so much better to boo during.

3. Melbourne - There's a pretty big gap after the first two, but this one is still famous.

Bottom 3
14. Port Adelaide - Just annoying more than anything else. "C'mon, Port Adelaide aggression!" haha it's just so weak.

15. West Coast - Could you get any wimpier than this? It's like the people who wrote it were just taking the piss the whole time. We're the big birds? um, what?

16. Adelaide - South Australians just don't get it. It's sung in this incredibly annoying monotone that feels like it's 'rubbing it in' or something. They might as well say "we're better than yooouuu, we're better than yooouuu"

But let's be honest, they're all pretty freaking terrible.

 

[hellfire]

Best:
1. North Melbourne
2. Richmond
3. Carlton [it hurts me to say it]

Sydney very unlucky.

Worst:
1. Freo
2. Port
3. Probably West Coast

 

[Jade]

Can already see a trend here, Richmond's is the best, Port and Freo in the bottom three.

 

[walhawk]

No, they're not, they're naff show tunes, music hall ditties or popular tunes from the early years of the century. Lily of Laguna, Yankee Doodle Dandy, The Toreador song from Carmen, Join in the Chorus and Goodbye Dolly Grey were the 'Hit Me Baby One More Time' or the 'Pump It' of their era. They aren't 'battle songs.

*t.

Huh? OK not most but many...

Hawks "Yankee Doodle" is a well-known Anglo-American song, the origin of which dates back to the Seven Years' War. It is often sung patriotically in the United States today and is the state anthem of Connecticut.[1]
Melbourne is a civil war song
Lions French Anthen
Swans The "Notre Dame Victory March" is the fight song for the University of Notre Dame.

 

[PortBrillance]

I dont think ours is that bad. I'd say middle ranked.

Best
1. Richmond
2. Carlton
3. North

Worst:
1. Gold Coast...LOL
2. Freo
3. Crows

 

[Gezim]

1.richmond- its just very good.
2.carlton- even though i'm a blue. but theres something about this one, its slow, but it gives me goosebumps
3.sydney- i like it, dont no why i just do

 

[erical]

1.West Coast-The original not the latter.
2.Richmond-Never heard anything like it after the 1995 semi final win over the Dons which I attended.Awe inspiring
All the rest are s**t basically.
Depending on how much you have had to drink