Toast Coaches Votes 2019

[Square Peg]

So Fyfe got 9 votes against the tigers! Pretty generous. I would have given BOG to MacIntosh personally, rarely do you see a guy smash his opponent so comprehensively.
All the rest of the votes went to Tigers players

 

[Nothing]

No Freo player with a 10 this year. 5 nines in total (Walter x2, Fyfe x2, Ryan x1).

 

[Belnakor]

pretty interesting Fyfe get 9 the rest of the team doesn't even get 1.

 

[kp junior]

pretty interesting Fyfe get 9 the rest of the team doesn't even get 1.

Pretty accurate assessment of the game


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Lach72]

So Fyfe got 9 votes against the tigers! Pretty generous. I would have given BOG to MacIntosh personally, rarely do you see a guy smash his opponent so comprehensively.
All the rest of the votes went to Tigers players

33 and 3 goals not enough for you?

 

[Belnakor]

So Fyfe got 9 votes against the tigers! Pretty generous. I would have given BOG to MacIntosh personally, rarely do you see a guy smash his opponent so comprehensively.
All the rest of the votes went to Tigers players

you must have been at a different game to me. Coaches gave him 2 votes which is pretty accurate.

 

[Nothing]

2nd week in a row only 1 vote getter.

Votes
8 David Mundy (FRE)
8 David Zaharakis (ESS)
5 Jake Stringer (ESS)
3 Zach Merrett (ESS)
2 Matt Guelfi (ESS)
2 Dylan Shiel (ESS)
2 Michael Hurley (ESS)

 

[Nothing]

Tally Name
36 Fyfe
26 Mundy
21 Walters
11 Ryan
9 B Hill
9 A Pearce
7 Taberner
5 McCarthy
3 Tucker
2 Langdon
2 Wilson
2 Hamling
1 Hogan

Mundy with his 4th game with votes. In all of 2016-2018 he only had 4 games each year where he got votes, with his tally this year higher than any of those other years. He is also 18th overall (Fyfe is 7th).

 

[Allikat]

2nd week in a row only 1 vote getter.

Votes
8 David Mundy (FRE)
8 David Zaharakis (ESS)
5 Jake Stringer (ESS)
3 Zach Merrett (ESS)
2 Matt Guelfi (ESS)
2 Dylan Shiel (ESS)
2 Michael Hurley (ESS)

I thought the 8 for Mundy's pretty generous.

 

[Okinakashi]

I thought the 8 for Mundy's pretty generous.

Really? 34 touches. 17 contested, 9 clearances and a Goal. That's a pretty handy game.

 

[Allikat]

Really? 34 touches. 17 contested, 9 clearances and a Goal. That's a pretty handy game.

Definitely a good game, I just expect the winning team to usually get BoG

 

[Okinakashi]

Definitely a good game, I just expect the winning team to usually get BoG

I think (without doing too much maths), that both coaches agree with you.

 

[Nothing]

Definitely a good game, I just expect the winning team to usually get BoG

That's where the coaches votes differ from the Brownlow. The coaches will often award the votes to the losing team, especially if there is one or two stand out performers.

 

[G Mus]

Really? 34 touches. 17 contested, 9 clearances and a Goal. That's a pretty handy game.

Career best game for Mundy according to the player rater

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

I've been wrong on this before but I'm pretty sure someone gave Stringer 5 and someone gave him nothing or am I wrong?

 

[Nothing]

I've been wrong on this before but I'm pretty sure someone gave Stringer 5 and someone gave him nothing or am I wrong?

You are correct. The 1 and 2 votes are taken care of by Guelfi, Shiel and Hurley. My guess would be from Lyon.

 

[Nothing]

vs Brisbane
10 Bradley Hill (FRE)
7 Nathan Wilson (FRE)
5 Harris Andrews (BL)
5 Hugh McCluggage (BL)
3 Luke Ryan (FRE)

Tally Name
36 Fyfe
26 Mundy
21 Walters
19 B Hill
14 Ryan
9 A Pearce
9 Wilson
7 Taberner
5 McCarthy
3 Tucker
2 Langdon
2 Hamling
1 Hogan

Hill with the first full 10. Wilson with his second highest vote scoring game for us. Ryan first season with 3 voting games.

Fyfe gets nothing for 26 possies, 17 contested, 7 tackles and a goal. Tough crowd.

 

[PurpleEyes]

vs Brisbane
...
Fyfe gets nothing for 26 possies, 17 contested, 7 tackles and a goal. Tough crowd.

I've always been a huge fan of Neale (and still happy seeing him do well at the Lions), but the poor fellow got schooled by Fyfe yesterday. Mundy was also awesome to have 12 clearances in a game and no votes. We are so very lucky to have Fyfe and Mundy. Our young team would be rudderless without those guys.

 

[Scham]

Hill didn’t even get a gig in the AFL Player Rating team of the week! Oli Florent was named on the wing instead

 

[PurpleEyes]

Hill didn’t even get a gig in the AFL Player Rating team of the week! Oli Florent was named on the wing instead

Yeah, that team of the week is simply based on AFL Player rating points. Florent & Scully, both named on the wings, got about 17 points & B.Hill 14 points for their games in Round 10.
I struggle with that AFL Player rating at times. According to it, Bontempelli was clearly best on ground in the WB vs NM game, yet he got no votes from either coach.

 

[apuchar]

Hill didn’t even get a gig in the AFL Player Rating team of the week! Oli Florent was named on the wing instead

Jezz. Did they select the team before we played or something

 

[Wizard]

vs Brisbane
10 Bradley Hill (FRE)
7 Nathan Wilson (FRE)
5 Harris Andrews (BL)
5 Hugh McCluggage (BL)
3 Luke Ryan (FRE)

Tally Name
36 Fyfe
26 Mundy
21 Walters
19 B Hill
14 Ryan
9 A Pearce
9 Wilson
7 Taberner
5 McCarthy
3 Tucker
2 Langdon
2 Hamling
1 Hogan

Hill with the first full 10. Wilson with his second highest vote scoring game for us. Ryan first season with 3 voting games.

Fyfe gets nothing for 26 possies, 17 contested, 7 tackles and a goal. Tough crowd.

I'm sure he will get votes later in the season for that game.

 

[Bender571]

Hill didn’t even get a gig in the AFL Player Rating team of the week! Oli Florent was named on the wing instead

The player rating system doesn't seem to like what Hill does. There was a game in 2017 where he smashed Essendon, had 37 disposals, 1 goal, 900 metres gained, 10 coaches votes, 2 brownlow votes. Yet the player ratings had him 6th worst on ground.

 

[UYD 4 Life]

The player rating system doesn't seem to like what Hill does. There was a game in 2017 where he smashed Essendon, had 37 disposals, 1 goal, 900 metres gained, 10 coaches votes, 2 brownlow votes. Yet the player ratings had him 6th worst on ground.

From memory i think it is heavily weighted to contested play (marks, possessions, clearances) and score involvements.

 

[Belnakor]

I'm sure he will get votes later in the season for that game.

Fyfe is a near lock to poll for any game where we win and he gets over 25 possessions. Games he played that we won last year he averaged 2.6 votes per game.