MVP Coaches Votes 2020

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

gab213

Premium Platinum
Aug 29, 2013
3,192
9,051
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Coburg VFL
The only way these votes are possible if Cripps got 5 votes from one coach and zero from the other. Hard to believe anyone watching that game didn't have Cripps in the best 5 on the ground.

I'm not all that surprised, it's a good sign, we had a lot of players who did well on Saturday Night. Even if you look at our own POTY on this board, 49 people have voted, 10 don't have Cripps in their votes.
 

GeoCoulthard

Debutant
Nov 18, 2018
67
343
AFL Club
Carlton
On my analysis, Cripps either got 5 votes from one coach and zero from the other or Weitering got 4 from one coach and zero from the other. I don't think other combinations are possible. Either combination means that one coach didn't rate Cripps and/or Weitering's game.
 

HARKER

Hall of Famer
Oct 15, 2008
49,694
85,784
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
The only way these votes are possible if Cripps got 5 votes from one coach and zero from the other. Hard to believe anyone watching that game didn't have Cripps in the best 5 on the ground.
NO -

Levi - 5 & 4 - No other way
Pitt - 2 & 5
Cripps - 3 & 2
Weit - 4 & 0
Betts - 0 & 3 - No other way
Rohan - 1 & 0 - Obvious
Doc - 0 & 1 - Obvious

This seems most likely to me.
 

HARKER

Hall of Famer
Oct 15, 2008
49,694
85,784
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
McGovern one vote?
Would have ECurnow and Murphy ahead.
Must have been a Teague 'Vote of Faith'

First four are hard to argue with, but who got the 4 & 4 :)
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Jeremias

Moderator
Sep 26, 2004
39,479
42,920
AFL Club
Carlton
ROUND 6

CARLTON VS WESTERN BULLDOGS

8 Jack Martin (CARL)
5 Ed Curnow (CARL)

5 Jack Macrae (WB)
4 Eddie Betts (CARL)
3 Alex Keath (WB)
2 Harrison McKay (CARL)
2 Michael Gibbons (CARL)

1 Bailey Smith (WB)

Would love to see who voted for who, because someone is having a laugh.
 

HARKER

Hall of Famer
Oct 15, 2008
49,694
85,784
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
ROUND 6

CARLTON VS WESTERN BULLDOGS

8 Jack Martin (CARL)
5 Ed Curnow (CARL)

5 Jack Macrae (WB)
4 Eddie Betts (CARL)
3 Alex Keath (WB)
2 Harrison McKay (CARL)
2 Michael Gibbons (CARL)

1 Bailey Smith (WB)

Would love to see who voted for who, because someone is having a laugh.
Martin - 4 & 4
Curnow - 5 & 0 - Teague
Macrae - 5 & 0 - Beverdige
Betts - 3 & 1...................This one decides how the rest went.
Keath - 3 & 0..................No other way
McKay - 2 & 0.................No other way
Gibbons - 2 & 0...............No other way
Smith - 1 & 0..................No other way

I feel it went this way.
 

new_blue

Team Captain
Aug 19, 2018
359
1,342
AFL Club
Carlton
Martin - 4 & 4
Curnow - 5 & 0 - Teague
Macrae - 5 & 0 - Beverdige
Betts - 3 & 1...................This one decides how the rest went.
Keath - 3 & 0..................No other way
McKay - 2 & 0.................No other way
Gibbons - 2 & 0...............No other way
Smith - 1 & 0..................No other way

I feel it went this way.
I felt it may have gone like:

Teague
1. Macrae
2. Gibbo
3. Martin
4. Betts
5. Curnow

Beveridge
1. Smith
2. Harry
3. Keith
4. Macrae
5. Martin
 

HARKER

Hall of Famer
Oct 15, 2008
49,694
85,784
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
I felt it may have gone like:

Teague
1. Macrae
2. Gibbo
3. Martin
4. Betts
5. Curnow

Beveridge
1. Smith
2. Harry
3. Keith
4. Macrae
5. Martin
There are possibilities, but hard to not have seen the value of Betts. 4 goals alone..........but then again.........who knows?
I can see why Teague may have favoured ECurnow though.

Best player shows up as Martin though and I wouldn't argue with that. :)
 

Remove this Banner Ad