Coaches Votes 2025

Tarkyn_24 · Jun 3, 2025

mocamagic said:
Caleb Daniel ahead of Josh Daicos - what a joke

Caleb Daniel ahead of that Hardeman kid. What a joke.

thebaldfacts · Jun 10, 2025

Collingwood players year to date including Kings Birthday votes.

Nick leading with Steele just ahead of Josh. Love that we are having such an even spread this year.

45 Nick Daicos
45 Steele Sidebotton
43 Josh Daicos
34 Jamie Elliott
21 Ned Long
17 Jeremy Howe
12 Lachie Schultz
11 Darcy Cameron
11 Brody Mihocek
9 Dan Houston
9 Jack Crisp
7 Scott Pendlebury
5 Daniel McStay
5 Isaac Quaynor
2 Darcy Moore
2 Billy Frampton
1 Patrick Lipinski
1 Tim Membrey
1 Bobby Hill
1 Beau McCreery
1 Harry Perryman

thebaldfacts · Jun 10, 2025

Coaches votes for King's Birthday game. Already updated the Pies players in earlier post.

Melbourne v Collingwood
10 Josh Daicos (COLL)
8 Jeremy Howe (COLL)
4 Max Gawn (MELB)
4 Steven May (MELB)
2 Scott Pendlebury (COLL)
2 Steele Sidebottom (COLL)

thebaldfacts · Jun 10, 2025

Interestingly, Fly's coaches MVP was Jeremy Howe, yet they gave 5 votes to Josh.

Would have thought our MVP would be rated best.

3rdMan · Jun 10, 2025

Gawn and May fighting it out first third spot.

Jen2310 · Jun 11, 2025

thebaldfacts said:
Interestingly, Fly's coaches MVP was Jeremy Howe, yet they gave 5 votes to Josh.

Would have thought our MVP would be rated best.

Not always the case I've noticed with fly.

Jen2310 · Jun 23, 2025

Collingwood v St Kilda

10 Darcy Cameron COLL
8 Nick Daicos COLL
6 Patrick Lipinski COLL
2 Cooper Sharman STK
2 Callum Wilkie STK
1 Rowan Marshall STK
1 Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera STK

VinnieB · Jun 23, 2025

How did Cooper Sharman get 2 votes and Josh Daicos zip??? Or Darcy Moore??

PIEWITHSAUCE · Jun 23, 2025

I was expecting Rossy to stir the pot and give Windhager a vote

danielnajdek · Jun 23, 2025

VinnieB said:
How did Cooper Sharman get 2 votes and Josh Daicos zip??? Or Darcy Moore??

Ross Lyon special.

Tippy78 · Jun 23, 2025

VinnieB said:
How did Cooper Sharman get 2 votes and Josh Daicos zip??? Or Darcy Moore??

I actually thought mason wood deserved votes. Destroyed us there for a bit

thebaldfacts · Jun 23, 2025

Collingwood players year to date.

Both coaches agreed that the best 3 players were Cameron, Nick and Lippa. Let's see who gets the brownlow votes

Love that we are having such an even spread this year.

53 Nick Daicos
45 Steele Sidebotton
43 Josh Daicos
34 Jamie Elliott
21 Ned Long
21 Darcy Cameron
17 Jeremy Howe
12 Lachie Schultz
11 Brody Mihocek
9 Dan Houston
9 Jack Crisp
7 Scott Pendlebury
7 Patrick Lipinski
5 Daniel McStay
5 Isaac Quaynor
2 Darcy Moore
2 Billy Frampton
1 Tim Membrey
1 Bobby Hill
1 Beau McCreery
1 Harry Perryman

thebaldfacts · Jun 30, 2025

Collingwood v West Coast
6 Nick Daicos (COLL)
5 Harry Perryman (COLL)
5 Liam Baker (WCE)
5 Brady Hough (WCE)
5 Scott Pendlebury (COLL)
2 Darcy Cameron (COLL)
2 Jeremy Howe (COLL)

Interesting spread of votes. Nick looks to have got 3 votes from each coach, whilst 2 best on grounds got no votes from the other coach. Not sure who was BOG but the other 2 got 4 and 1 to make up the 4 lots of 5 votes.

thebaldfacts · Jun 30, 2025

Collingwood players year to date.

Love that we are having such an even spread this year.

59 Nick Daicos
45 Steele Sidebotton
43 Josh Daicos
34 Jamie Elliott
23 Darcy Cameron
21 Ned Long
19 Jeremy Howe
12 Scott Pendlebury
12 Lachie Schultz
11 Brody Mihocek
9 Dan Houston
9 Jack Crisp
7 Patrick Lipinski
6 Harry Perryman
5 Daniel McStay
5 Isaac Quaynor
2 Darcy Moore
2 Billy Frampton
1 Tim Membrey
1 Bobby Hill
1 Beau McCreery

nahnah · Jun 30, 2025

thebaldfacts said:
Collingwood v West Coast
6 Nick Daicos (COLL)
5 Harry Perryman (COLL)
5 Liam Baker (WCE)
5 Brady Hough (WCE)
5 Scott Pendlebury (COLL)
2 Darcy Cameron (COLL)
2 Jeremy Howe (COLL)

Interesting spread of votes. Nick looks to have got 3 votes from each coach, whilst 2 best on grounds got no votes from the other coach. Not sure who was BOG but the other 2 got 4 and 1 to make up the 4 lots of 5 votes.

Fly:
5 - Pendles
4 - Perryman
3 - Nick
2 - Howe
1 - Hough

Eagles coach:
5 - Baker
4 - Hough
3 - Nick
2 - Cameron
1 - Perryman

Vankri · Jun 30, 2025

nahnah said:
Fly:
5 - Pendles
4 - Perryman
3 - Nick
2 - Howe
1 - Hough

Eagles coach:
5 - Baker
4 - Hough
3 - Nick
2 - Cameron
1 - Perryman

If that was really the breakdown then McQualter is a peanut for two reasons: firstly giving Pendles no votes, secondly for picking two of his players at 5 and 4 in a 29pt loss. Though I haven’t played with all possible combinations to be sure.

Kirby · Jun 30, 2025

Vankri said:
If that was really the breakdown then McQualter is a peanut for two reasons: firstly giving Pendles no votes, secondly for picking two of his players at 5 and 4 in a 29pt loss. Though I haven’t played with all possible combinations to be sure.

Shades of Hinkley in late 23 giving Butters 5 every game when he was close to the lead in the MVP, just to make sure he got the chocolates.

Vankri · Jun 30, 2025

Kirby said:
Shades of Hinkley in late 23 giving Butters 5 every game when he was close to the lead in the MVP, just to make sure he got the chocolates.

Wait did McQualter get Perryman and Pendlebury mixed up and meant to give him 5 votes (giving Pendles the perfect 10)? Still a peanut move but more forgivable.

Cousin of Daicos · Jun 30, 2025

thebaldfacts said:
Collingwood v West Coast
6 Nick Daicos (COLL)
5 Harry Perryman (COLL)
5 Liam Baker (WCE)
5 Brady Hough (WCE)
5 Scott Pendlebury (COLL)
2 Darcy Cameron (COLL)
2 Jeremy Howe (COLL)

Interesting spread of votes. Nick looks to have got 3 votes from each coach, whilst 2 best on grounds got no votes from the other coach. Not sure who was BOG but the other 2 got 4 and 1 to make up the 4 lots of 5 votes.

This feels like a mistake was made somewhere here

Pendles was pretty clear best on ground. Daicos only getting 6 to me just further reinforces the error, as well as Perryman getting 5 lol

I suspect McQualter pressed 5 for PErryman instead of PEndlebury

CheckerTrade666 · Jun 30, 2025

Interesting set of votes. I must’ve missed Perryman’s game because I can’t really remember any key moments he had. Granted he always goes under the radar and plays his role well, but I can’t seem to remember much about his performance.

Glad he got recognition either way.

Kirby · Jun 30, 2025

Vankri said:
Wait did McQualter get Perryman and Pendlebury mixed up and meant to give him 5 votes (giving Pendles the perfect 10)? Still a peanut move but more forgivable.

Could be. I liked Perryman's game but it was his typical reliable good game. I can't see how anyone could give him 5. Strange

Tarkyn_24 · Jun 30, 2025

Next minute Perryman 10 votes, Pendlebury 0

Jen2310 · Jul 7, 2025

Carlton v Collingwood

10 Nick Daicos (COLL)
8 Darcy Moore (COLL)
5 Darcy Cameron (COLL)
5 Jamie Elliott (COLL)
2 Daniel McStay (COLL)

LEADERBOARD

69 Noah Anderson (GCFC)
69 Nick Daicos (COLL)
66 Bailey Smith (GEEL)
64 Jordan Dawson (ADEL)
62 Zak Butters (PORT)
62 Caleb Serong (FRE)
61 Ed Richards (WB)
59 Hugh McCluggage (BL)
59 Connor Rozee (PORT)
58 Tristan Xerri (NMFC)
55 Max Holmes (GEEL)
54 Max Gawn (MELB)
50 Touk Miller (GCFC)

Jen2310 · Jul 7, 2025

Also its been corrected that Pendles got the 10 votes v Eagles. And was a mix up with Perryman

danielnajdek · Jul 7, 2025

Hinkley loves keeping his best mate Butters near the top.

Log In or Create New Account

Coaches Votes 2025

Okeydoke7 is [redacted]

Club Legend

Club Legend

Club Legend

Premiership Player

Premium Platinum

Premium Platinum

Collingwood v St Kilda​

Norm Smith Medallist

Premiership Player

Hall of Famer

Club Legend

Club Legend

Club Legend

Club Legend

Hall of Famer

Club Legend

Shambolic Rube

Club Legend

HEY MAGPIE ARMY!

All Australian

Shambolic Rube

Okeydoke7 is [redacted]

Premium Platinum

Carlton v Collingwood​

LEADERBOARD​

Premium Platinum

Hall of Famer