Coaching or recruiting

[Eagle Number1000]

Just a few trades we have done for some of our premiership players or emerging stars, and a few of my favourites bolded

Fraser Gehrig to St Kilda <<>> Pick 18 (Daniel Kerr)
Pick 8 (Luke Brennan) to Hawthorn <<>> Daniel Chick
David Hynes to Geelong <<>> Pick 20 (Sam Butler)
Pick 12 (Danny Meyer), 28 (Chad Gibson) to Adelaide <<>> Tyson Stenglien
Paul Johnson to Melbourne <<>> Pick 29 (Matt Rosa)
Chad Morrison to Collingwood <<>> Pick 37 (Mark LeCras)
Daniel McConnell, Pick 18 (Max Bailey) to Kangaroos <<>> Pick 13 (Shannon Hurn), 29 (Ben McKinley)
Chris Judd, Pick 46 (Dennis Armfield) to Carlton <<>> Pick 3 (Chris Masten), 20 (Tony Notte) and Josh Kennedy
Mitch Morton to Richmond <<>> Pick 22 (Scott Selwood)

The lesson learned here is that its better to trade for higher draft picks then already established players.

We have done pretty good- impressive.

 

[Black Ball]

If any of you are of the opinion that our recruiting has been suspect and you want confirmation, get along to Subiaco tomorrow and watch this years rising star favourite in action and imagine him in purple which he would've been in if our recruiters hadn't stuffed up.

 

[WCE57]

If any of you are of the opinion that your recruiting has been suspect and you want confirmation, get along to Subiaco tomorrow and watch this years rising star favourite in action and imagine him in WCE colours which he would've been in if your recruiters hadn't stuffed up.

Ah... you obviously forgotten that you turn down Mr Rich aswell. How good would have Rich been in Freo colours.

Happy with Nick Thanks regardless.

Nice troll.

 

[Eagle87]

If any of you are of the opinion that your recruiting has been suspect and you want confirmation, get along to Subiaco tomorrow and watch this years rising star favourite in action and imagine him in WCE colours which he would've been in if your recruiters hadn't stuffed up.

G'day black balls.... good to see you remain a complete dick. As you are WELL aware, NN was always going Top 2 and was the one you guys wanted. You were faced with a choice at 3 and you passed on Rich because, allegedly you already had a "similar" player in Palmer....

Freo chose Hill over Rich, time will tell how wise that was.

 

[Black Ball]

Ah... you obviously forgotten that you turn down Mr Rich aswell. How good would have Rich been in Freo colours.

Happy with Nick Thanks regardless.

Nice troll.

The difference is that we made a terrible decision your lot made a good one. We were always going to take Rich but our lot changed their minds and will have to live with that stupid decision forever.

 

[Black Ball]

G'day black balls.... good to see you remain a complete dick. As you are WELL aware, NN was always going Top 2 and was the one you guys wanted. You were faced with a choice at 3 and you passed on Rich because, allegedly you already had a "similar" player in Palmer....

Freo chose Hill over Rich, time will tell how wise that was.

Must be quiet in the international business world at the moment given the inordinate amount of time that you have been exercising your ego on BF over the last several days.
The only reason that Naitanui was going to go at 2 is because Melbourne's bunch of incompetents were conned into thinking that Watts was the best player in the draft. Naitanui was always the player that Freo wanted first.

 

[Eagle87]

Must be quiet in the international business world at the moment given the inordinate amount of time that you have been exercising your ego on BF over the last several days.
The only reason that Naitanui was going to go in the Top 2 is because your bunch of incompetents were conned into thinking that he was the best player in the draft. He was never the player that Freo wanted first.

Keep telling yourself that Black Balls.....

Must be ****ing freezing in that depressing town you haunt. All the best.

 

[Keys]

Poor blue balls seems confused

 

[Black Ball]

Poor blue balls seems confused

And I was under the impression that Mods were supposed to moderate. If the truth of my post was too much for you why didn't you just delete it?

 

[Keys]

And I was under the impression that Mods were supposed to moderate. If the truth of my post was too much for you why didn't you just delete it?

Or I could have given you a card for trolling a team board.

 

[Eagle87]

And I was under the impression that Mods were supposed to moderate. If the truth of my post was too much for you why didn't you just delete it?

bwahahaha....

King troll has thrown his toys out of the pram!

 

[larrikin]

And I was under the impression that Mods were supposed to moderate. If the truth of my post was too much for you why didn't you just delete it?

Somewhere an angel is crying

 

[Crimson King]

G'day black balls.... good to see you remain a complete dick. As you are WELL aware, NN was always going Top 2 and was the one you guys wanted. You were faced with a choice at 3 and you passed on Rich because, allegedly you already had a "similar" player in Palmer....

Freo chose Hill over Rich, time will tell how wise that was.

Rich certainly did very well tonight. Even with the horrid weather displayed quality skills while on the other hand Hill fumbled around, another fail of a troll from Black Ball.

 

[Ted38]

Every time I see Rich play I wonder what might have been! An opportunity lost.

 

[mitchzz]

Every time I see Rich play I wonder what might have been! An opportunity lost.

Kinda the same feeling.

But wait a few years. Rich was ready made and a smart midfielder, Naitanui has alot to learn and ruckmen take longer to blossom.

In a few years Naitanui could be dominating every game.

 

[greennick]

Poor blue balls seems confused

hehehe

 

[tesseract]

I wonder if we should run a poll about whether there are more trolls around this year or if they are really stupid eagles supporters?

I think our board has been infiltrated by pretend Eagles supporters. Trolls with West Coast as their team.

Although even some Eagles supporters have been quick to deride their own team. The state of this board is sickly. We have to many front runners for supporters.

 

[MrTripleC]

Maybe i should reword the question to take any bias out.

Who is more to blame for West Coast's poor last two seasons.

Coaching

Or

Recruiting






(And for those that want to say Judd and Cousins, that comes down to the coaching department, and their ability to keep all players dedicated to the ultimate goal of a premiership.)

 

[tesseract]

Maybe i should reword the question to take any bias out.

Who is more to blame for West Coast's poor last two seasons.

Coaching

Or

Recruiting






(And for those that want to say Judd and Cousins, that comes down to the coaching department, and their ability to keep all players dedicated to the ultimate goal of a premiership.)

You're stipulation as to choosing coaching makes it a loaded question.
You've taken away the other options to get your desired result.
Your over simplifying the matter to the point where it'd be incorrect to chose either.
I choose none of the above given the options and terms you've provided.

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

Somewhere an angel is crying

Larri can we make it a automatic red card if Black Ball ever posts on our board just for being him please ?