Competitions Collingwood All Time Draft

[half_back_flank]

LINK TO TRICKSTERS SPREADSHEET

*Spots are all filled*

G'day,

Have been itching to post this ever since our season ended circa round 7, finally thought it would be appropriate to start the ball rolling now. After seeing something similar on the Saints board (https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/st-kilda-all-time-draft.1083920/) a few years ago, i'm hoping to find posters to participate in a draft, the pool being any person to pull on the black and white stripes. After everyone has selected a best 18, a poll will be created to determined which poster has the best team.

Rules
1. A player will only be judged on deeds done in the Black and White.

2. No time limit for picks. With regards to work commitments, it's probably unreasonable to assume that everyone can be on the same schedule and be able to pull the trigger on their next selection as soon as the previous selection has been made (myself included). If anyone is really dragging their feet, we will just rely on good old fashioned peer pressure through tagging. With 198 players to pick though it would be nice to move through the rounds quite quickly, after you've posted your selection, tag the next poster as a courtesy.

3. Feel free to write a few sentences to justify your selection! It'll make it easier to push your case for voting for the best team at the end.

4. All players, past and present, are eligible.

Draft order:

First round -

1. Raymond35 - Len Thompson
2. Jelly Bean - Gordon Coventry
3. South of the Yarra - Albert Collier
4. Tarkyn_24 - Peter Daicos
5. Trickster - Nathan Buckley
6. Magpies42 - Peter Moore
7. Half_back_flank - Bob Rose
8. iGNITER - Peter McKenna
9. Pie 4 Life - Syd Coventry snr
10 Cityslick1 - [PLAYERCARD]Scott Pendlebury[/PLAYERCARD]
11. Gouki88 - [PLAYERCARD]Dane Swan[/PLAYERCARD]

Second round -

12. Gouki88 - Harry Collier
13. Cityslick1 - Jack Regan
14. Pie 4 Life - Dick Lee
15. iGNITER - Gavin Brown
16. Half_back_flank - Ron Todd
17. Magpies42 - Murray Weideman
18. Trickster - Phonse Kyne
19. Tarkyn_24 - Darren Millane
20. South of the Yarra - Des Fothergill
21. Jelly Bean - Des Tuddenham
22. Raymond35 - Billy Picken

Third round

23. Raymond35 - Lou Richards
24. Jelly Bean - John Greening
25. South of the Yarra - Harold Rumney
26. Tarkyn_24 - [PLAYERCARD]Brodie Grundy[/PLAYERCARD]
27. Trickster - Charlie Dibbs
28. Magpies42 - Marcus Whelan
29. Half_back_flank - Travis Cloke
30. iGNITER - Phil Carman
31. Pie 4 Life - Wayne Richardson
32. Cityslick1 - [PLAYERCARD]Darcy Moore[/PLAYERCARD]
33. Gouki88 - Sav Rocca

Fourth round -

34. Gouki88 - [PLAYERCARD]James Clement[/PLAYERCARD]
35. Cityslick1 - Thorold Merrett
36. Pie 4 Life - [PLAYERCARD]Anthony Rocca[/PLAYERCARD]
37. iGNITER - Tony Shaw
38. Half_back_flank - Ted Rowell
39. Magpies42 - Barry Price
40. Trickster - Jock McHale
41. Tarkyn_24 - [PLAYERCARD]Chris Tarrant[/PLAYERCARD]
42. South of the Yarra - Frank Murphy
43. Jelly Bean - Dick Condon
44. Raymond35 - Mark Williams

Fifth round

45. Raymond35 - Rick Barham
46. Jelly Bean - Jack Monohan
47. South of the Yarra - Brian Taylor
48. Tarkyn_24 - Alby Pannam
49. Trickster - Alan Didak
50. Magpies42 - [PLAYERCARD]Steele Sidebottom[/PLAYERCARD]
51. Half_back_flank - Neil Mann
52. iGNITER - [PLAYERCARD]Simon Prestigiacomo[/PLAYERCARD]
53. Pie 4 Life - Mick McGuane
54. Cityslick1 - Bill Twomey Jr
55. Gouki88 - Ray Gabilech

Sixth Round

56. Gouki88 - Ted Potter
57. Cityslick1 - [PLAYERCARD]Archie Smith[/PLAYERCARD]
58. Pie 4 Life - Des Healey
59. iGNITER - [PLAYERCARD]Scott Burns[/PLAYERCARD]
60. Half_back_flank - [PLAYERCARD]Leon Davis[/PLAYERCARD]
61. Magpies42 - [PLAYERCARD]Ben Reid[/PLAYERCARD]
62. Trickster - Craig Davis
63. Tarkyn_24 - Dale Thomas
64. South of the Yarra - Billy Libbis
65. Jelly Bean - Charlie Pannam Snr
66. Raymond35 - Michael Christian

Seventh Round

67. Raymond35 - Gavin Crosisca
68. Jelly Bean - David Cloke
69. South of the Yarra - Dennis Banks
70. Tarkyn_24 - [PLAYERCARD]Heath Shaw[/PLAYERCARD]
71. Trickster - Jack Beveridge
72. Magpies42 - Bill Proudfoot
73. Half_back_flank - George Clayden
74. iGNITER - [PLAYERCARD]Paul Licuria[/PLAYERCARD]
75. Pie 4 Life - Max Richardson
76 Cityslick1 - Dayne Beanms
77. Gouki88 - [PLAYERCARD]Nick Maxwell[/PLAYERCARD]

Eighth Round

78. Gouki88 - Scott Russell
79. Cityslick1 - [PLAYERCARD]Jordan De Goey[/PLAYERCARD]
80. Pie 4 Life - Terry Waters
81. iGNITER - Paul Williams
82. Half_back_flank - [PLAYERCARD]Jack Crisp[/PLAYERCARD]
83. Magpies42 - Ray Shaw
84. Trickster - L Hughes
85. Tarkyn_24 - Turner
86. South of the Yarra - Wright
87. Jelly Bean - Monkhurst
88. Raymond35 - Manson

Ninth round

89. Raymond35 - Margo
90. Jelly Bean - Leach
91. South of the Yarra - Jolly
92. Tarkyn_24 - Lamumba
93. Trickster - L Murphy
94. Magpies42 - Elliott
95. Half_back_flank - Strickland
96. iGNITER - Howe
97. Pie 4 Life - T Adams
98 Cityslick1 - Ian Graham
99. Gouki88 - Ian Brewer

Tenth round

100. Gouki88 - Paul Medhurst
101. Cityslick1 - Trevor Steer
102. Pie 4 Life - Harry Saunders
103. iGNITER - Rene Kink
104. Half_back_flank - Ben Johnson
105. Magpies42 - Ross Dunne
106. Trickster - Bob Makeham
107. Tarkyn_24 - Luke Ball
108. South of the Yarra - Shane Morwood
109. Jelly Bean - Gary Pert
110. Raymond35 - Leigh Brown

Eleventh round

111. Raymond35 - Tony Francis
112. Jelly Bean - Mick Gayfer
113. South of the Yarra - Ronnie Wearmouth
114. Tarkyn_24 - [PLAYERCARD]Brayden Maynard[/PLAYERCARD]
115. Trickster - [PLAYERCARD]Josh Fraser[/PLAYERCARD]
116. Magpies42 - Brodie Mihocek
117. Half_back_flank - Bill Serong
118. iGNITER - Graeme Jenkin
119. Pie 4 Life - Tarkyn Lockyer
120 Cityslick1 - Geoff Raines
121. Gouki88 - John Henderson

Twelfth round

122. Gouki88 - Gordon Hocking
123. Cityslick1 - Mike Richardson
124. Pie 4 Life - Jack Murphy
125. iGNITER - Alan Atkinson
126. Half_back_flank - Michael Taylor
127. Magpies42 - R. Richards
128. Trickster - R. Dean
129. Tarkyn_24 - Wakelin
130. South of the Yarra - Curtis
131. Jelly Bean - Len Fitzgerald
132. Raymond35 - K Rose

Thirteenth round

133. Raymond35 - Phil Walsh
134. Jelly Bean - Nick Davis
135. South of the Yarra - Jack Hamilton
136. Tarkyn_24 - Peter Lucas
137. Trickster - P. Wilson
138. Magpies42 - Lardie Tullock
139. Half_back_flank - George Angus
140. iGNITER - Craig Kelly
141. Pie 4 Life - Percy Rowe
142 Cityslick1 - Wes Fellowes
143. Gouki88 - Frank Tuck

Fourteenth round

144. Gouki88 - Doug Barwick
145. Cityslick1 - Eddie Drohan
146. Pie 4 Life - [PLAYERCARD]Shane O'Bree[/PLAYERCARD]
147. iGNITER - Phil Manassa
148. Half_back_flank - Harry Chesswas
149. Magpies42 - Vin Doherty
150. Trickster - Percy Bowyer
151. Tarkyn_24 - Norman
152. South of the Yarra - Teddy Lockwood
153. Jelly Bean - Andy Krakouer
154. Raymond35 - Fellowes

Fifteenth round

155. Raymond35 - Peter McCormack
156. Jelly Bean - Dan Minogue
157. South of the Yarra - Mick Twomey
158. Tarkyn_24 - Treloar
159. Trickster - Horrie Edmonds
160. Magpies42 - Charlie Utting
161. Half_back_flank - Con McCarthy
162. iGNITER - [PLAYERCARD]Alan Toovey[/PLAYERCARD]
163. Pie 4 Life - Paddy Rowan
164. Cityslick1 - Bob Rush
165. Gouki88 - Mal Sedden

Sixteenth round

166. Gouki88 - Tom Drummond
167. Cityslick1 - [PLAYERCARD]Isaac Quaynor[/PLAYERCARD]
168. Pie 4 Life - Arthur Leach
169. iGNITER - Trav Varcoe
170. Half_back_flank - Jack Finck
171. Magpies42 - Fred Froude
172. Trickster - Ron Kingston
173. Tarkyn_24 - [PLAYERCARD]Nathan Brown[/PLAYERCARD]
174. South of the Yarra - Alf Dummett
175. Jelly Bean - Bob Nash
176. Raymond35 - Graeme Anderson

Seventeenth round

177. Raymond35 - Graeme Shephard
178. Jelly Bean - Frank Hailwood
179. South of the Yarra - Bill Twomey snr
180. Tarkyn_24 - Brian Gray
181. Trickster - Ron Reeves
182. Magpies42 - Harris
183. Half_back_flank - E. Wilson
184. iGNITER - Westcott
185. Pie 4 Life - Langdon
186 Cityslick1 - M Michael
187. Gouki88 - C Pannam jr

Eighteenth round

188. Gouki88 - J Pimm
189. Cityslick1 - R Byrne
190. Pie 4 Life - B Holland
191. iGNITER - D. Wells
192. Half_back_flank - M. Bone
193. Magpies42 - J. Ross
194. Trickster - P. Gibb
195. Tarkyn_24 - Brereton
196. South of the Yarra - B. Abernethy
197. Jelly Bean - B Davey
198. Raymond35 - C. Starcevich

 

[Pie 4 Life]

This sounds fun, I’ll be in

 

[Countrypie]

G'day,

Have been itching to post this ever since our season ended circa round 7, finally thought it would be appropriate to start the ball rolling now. After seeing something similar on the Saints board (https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/st-kilda-all-time-draft.1083920/) a few years ago, i'm hoping to find a maximum of 12 posters to participate in a draft, the pool being any person to pull on the black and white stripes. After everyone has selected a best 18, a poll will be created to determined which poster has the best team.

Rules:
1. A player will only be judged on deeds done in the Black and White; Dermie's 5 day and 5 night premierships won't count, despite his admirable job done mentoring Sav.
2. You will have 48 hours to make your choice after the preceding poster has selected. If you aren't posting or lurking most days, please think carefully about applying.
3. Initial draft order will be determined by random and subsequent rounds will follow snake order (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,12,11,10 ect.).
4. All players, past and present, are eligible.

Thanks, hopefully a few people are interested.

This seems like a great idea but I go hot and cold on this site. I'm all over it for weeks and then lose interest for months. I'll be watching with interest

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Sure

 

[iGNITER]

I will give it a go

 

[Jelly Bean]

I'm keen

 

[raymond35]

I would like to participate in your cunning plan

 

[gouki88]

I'd join in!

 

[magpies42]

G'day,

Have been itching to post this ever since our season ended circa round 7, finally thought it would be appropriate to start the ball rolling now. After seeing something similar on the Saints board (https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/st-kilda-all-time-draft.1083920/) a few years ago, i'm hoping to find a maximum of 12 posters to participate in a draft, the pool being any person to pull on the black and white stripes. After everyone has selected a best 18, a poll will be created to determined which poster has the best team.

Rules:
1. A player will only be judged on deeds done in the Black and White; Dermie's 5 day and 5 night premierships won't count, despite his admirable job done mentoring Sav.
2. You will have 48 hours to make your choice after the preceding poster has selected. If you aren't posting or lurking most days, please think carefully about applying.
3. Initial draft order will be determined by random and subsequent rounds will follow snake order (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,12,11,10 ect.).
4. All players, past and present, are eligible.

Thanks, hopefully a few people are interested.

Participants (Not in draft order) -
1. Half_back_flank
2. Pie 4 Life
3. Tarkyn_24
4. iGNITER
5. Jelly Bean
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.

Im in

 

[Trickster]

Yeah count me in!

Edit: Updated with team / position details below and by team / round further below:

 

[South of the Yarra]

Will have a go

 

[iGNITER]

Also mate, good idea for a bit of fun. Been a rough year for all of us Pies fans.

 

[magpies42]

So what’s the end goal here. To pick a balanced team that could compete in today’s game? Or just to pick the next best?

 

[half_back_flank]

Two spots left. If no one takes them by 1.22 am (24 hours since the creation of the thread) we will just go with 10 participants.

So what’s the end goal here. To pick a balanced team that could compete in today’s game? Or just to pick the next best?

Pick a best 18 that tries to be as true as possible to the position/s that the player made his name in. Within reason of course, no problems putting a Steele Sidebottom in a forward pocket, bit dicey if Jarryd Blair is lining up in the ruck though. Every player picked is judged against his contemporaries, not how they would perform in today’s game. Syd Coventry’s height in regards to modern ruckman is irrelevant, he was a champion ruckman in the 20s and 30s and is judged on that.

Also mate, good idea for a bit of fun. Been a rough year for all of us Pies fans.

Thanks mate.

 

[cityslick1]

yes please!

 

[half_back_flank]

yes please!

Lucky last mate.

Now that it’s been 24 hours since I created this thread, the 11 are locked in.

Thought we’d leave the weekend to get any queries and questions answered and clarified to make sure everyone on the same page. I’ll randomly assign the draft order Sunday night (https://www.draftordergenerator.com) and we can start Monday.

Thanks for everyone who has agreed to participate, any questions or suggestions on how to make this a success are most welcome.

 

[Trickster]

Lucky last mate.

Now that it’s been 24 hours since I created this thread, the 11 are locked in.

Thought we’d leave the weekend to get any queries and questions answered and clarified to make sure everyone on the same page. I’ll randomly assign the draft order Sunday night (https://www.draftordergenerator.com) and we can start Monday.

Thanks for everyone who has agreed to participate, any questions or suggestions on how to make this a success are most welcome.

Great idea HBF and thanks for organising! Looking forward to it.

Just a couple of questions, how / where do we keep track of our own team and how do we keep track of players chosen by others?

 

[iGNITER]

If anyone steals Rupert Betheras on me I will be filthy.

 

[half_back_flank]

Great idea HBF and thanks for organising! Looking forward to it.

Just a couple of questions, how / where do we keep track of our own team and how do we keep track of players chosen by others?

I recon everyone just keeps a track of their own team (copy, paste and update from their previous selection). That way you can chuck players in the positions you want. I’ll update the OP with everyones selections as they come in.

 

[Didak_attack]

Ill give it a crack, could be fun!

Edit: just to throw up some ideas
- instead of a fixed 48 hours should the time to make selection be end of following day (11:59pm)

E.g person X makes a selection and 5pm on Monday, person Y has until 11:59pm tuesday night.

Person Y makes a selection 10am Tuesday, person Z has until 11:59pm Wednesday

Person Z makes a selection 2pm Tuesday, Person A has the same deadline of 11:59pm Wednesday.

This will ensure atleast a pick everyday and means that as long as entrants look each day there will be no missed selections.

If someone misses their deadline, the next pick will be 24 hours, so person A hasn't submitted by 11:59pm Wednesday, person B has a cutoff time of 11:59pm Thursday.

Idea 2:
- People can prepare an auto-picked list of ~5-10 players. If they miss their deadline the list is checked and first player that is available is auto picked. This could be managed by someone who isn't an entrant that is willing to volunteer.

 

[Didak_attack]

Whoops didn't see it was full.

Ill gladly be an emergency if someone withdraws prior to starting.

I should of replied when I read this last night

 

[Trickster]

If anyone steals Rupert Betheras on me I will be filthy.

Or Athas Hrysoulakis!

 

[Trickster]

I recon everyone just keeps a track of their own team (copy, paste and update from their previous selection). That way you can chuck players in the positions you want. I’ll update the OP with everyones selections as they come in.

Or if you like I can update via excel and send an update every couple of days or so, more frequent potentially?

That way you can see all teams and which players have been chosen by whom side by side. I'll even list by position if everyone just adds that detail to their post...

Will also make it easier to collate at the end.

 

[half_back_flank]

Ill give it a crack, could be fun!

Edit: just to throw up some ideas
- instead of a fixed 48 hours should the time to make selection be end of following day (11:59pm)

E.g person X makes a selection and 5pm on Monday, person Y has until 11:59pm tuesday night.

Person Y makes a selection 10am Tuesday, person Z has until 11:59pm Wednesday

Person Z makes a selection 2pm Tuesday, Person A has the same deadline of 11:59pm Wednesday.

This will ensure atleast a pick everyday and means that as long as entrants look each day there will be no missed selections.

If someone misses their deadline, the next pick will be 24 hours, so person A hasn't submitted by 11:59pm Wednesday, person B has a cutoff time of 11:59pm Thursday.

Idea 2:
- People can prepare an auto-picked list of ~5-10 players. If they miss their deadline the list is checked and first player that is available is auto picked. This could be managed by someone who isn't an entrant that is willing to volunteer.

Sorry mate, but you are first emergency if anyone pulls out.

I like your first idea, it gives at the very least one pick a day, with 198 selections it’ll need to move reasonably quickly. A three strike method maybe, if you miss a deadline you get three seperate 24 hour extensions to make a selection. After the additional 24 hours is up and no selection has been made, the first poster not in the draft can respond and choose a player and what position they’ll occupy. For example Jason Wild can line up at FF.

 

[half_back_flank]

Or if you like I can update via excel and send an update every couple of days or so, more frequent potentially?

That way you can see all teams and which players have been chosen by whom side by side. I'll even list by position if everyone just adds that detail to their post...

Will also make it easier to collate at the end.

Mate that would be fantastic if you could maintain a spreadsheet.