Collingwood should be fined big time

[froars]

MMM reports that Cameron Cloke had received concussion prior to the Hall incident, AND WAS THEN ALLOWED BACK ON THE GROUND, is very ordinary and brings the game into disrepute lol

No serious, it's bad that a player already with concussion was allowed back on the ground, when generally when a player does get it, normally doesn't play the next week. You only had to look at the dope's face to see he was off with the fairies.

Discuss lol

 

[Harvey Leadpipe]

Not too sure what the protocol is there froars, but he was obviously not with it if Halls contact put him down. Everyone around me at the ground started moaning and groaning when they saw the replay of it. Very, very soft touch from Rayzor, and if contact like that can put a bloke down, then he was an obvious mess. Quite funny though, because Cloke looked like the biggest blouse actor after going down, even though he was in trouble. He shouldn't have been out there.

 

[roo_stew]

I agree. It looked so soft. I would have thought Malthouse would be less than happy with that assessment by the medical team let alone the team as a whole being in breach of the Duty of Care to a player. Sheehan went crazy about Macguire being allowed to play the next week, hell at Collingwood its straight back on the ground! I wonder what Mr & Mrs Cloke think?

 

[julzqld]

Can't a club be fined for allowing an unfit playing back onto the field?

 

[Infamy]

50 grand fine usually

 

[beaver's army]

should west coast be fined aswell after embley came back onto the field after he looked like he didnt have a clue what was happening?

 

[froars]

should west coast be fined aswell after embley came back onto the field after he looked like he didnt have a clue what was happening?

I reckon if a doctor's had a look at them, and they've said he is a bit concussed and the player goes through all the tests and is a bit dodgy, i think they're being negligent if they send that player back onto the field. So yep, if Embley was concussed - or any player - give them heaps.