TheWing121 my gut feel on the level Moore will reach is more your Cloke/ Hawkins output because he's a low possession high impact type, but if you can find a way to develop him into a consistent 15+ ppg type he could get to that next level given his dynamism and conversion. There are just so many factors to consider with it which is why you say no in the end, but to not even consider it isn't right to me.
FWIW another example Trent Croad at just 21 and a megastar in the making at Hawthorn goes out along with McPharlin. Incoming is Hodge and Mitchell the Hawks may have got lucky, but with an attitude of not even considering it they could be minus 4 flags, IMO.