Game Day Collingwood v GWS Giants - Preliminary Finals — Sat 21 Sep, 4:35PM AEST, MCG

[timokane]

Collingwood will win it and why not please give me valid reasons not just some biased dribble

 

[Colonial]

No one has given a valid reason why lies can’t win it’s basically based on bias

Lol

 

[PieLebo87]

What impact will Greene’s suspension have on the Giants?

 

[juss]

What impact will Greene’s suspension have on the Giants?

As the underdog outside the top 4, I think Giants needed everything to go right for them to win this week. As such, I'm even more confident this will be the blowout prelim and the Pies will win well.

 

[Billy ray]

Rigged

 

[Adz]

What impact will Greene’s suspension have on the Giants?

Not sure they win without him.

 

[dean33]

I think GWS and Geelong both represent the bridesmaid over the last 3-4 years. Both made PF and bombed out, I really feel that one will grab the opportunity. I think the Giants are right in the mindset to win, playing very aggressive and unsociable footy. Pies will need to be on to stop them. Their SF effort this year was a lot better than last years effort.

Giants for me

You picked the pies for the flag only yesterday??

 

[Black white]

Rigged

True, shouldn't be allowed to play in gf should they make it. Should have been 3 weeks,4 for previous. Hawkins the same

 

[craffles]

Collingwood will win it and why not please give me valid reasons not just some biased dribble

I think GWS will win because they will score more total points than Collingwood over the duration of 4 quarters of football resulting in them being in front when the final siren blows.

 

[demondavey]

You picked the pies for the flag only yesterday??

?

 

[dean33]

?

You didn’t? I’m sure I read one of your posts this week saying you thought the pies would win the flag? Unless I have you confused with someone else which is possible I suppose... I am getting old...

 

[demondavey]

You didn’t? I’m sure I read one of your posts this week saying you thought the pies would win the flag? Unless I have you confused with someone else which is possible I suppose... I am getting old...

At this point I really don’t know who’ll win it. Anyone but Collingwood.

 

[dean33]

At this point I really don’t know who’ll win it. Anyone but Collingwood.

I stand corrected, you never said pies would win the flag, I must have confused you with ol potato head and for that I apologise.

 

[demondavey]

I stand corrected, you never said pies would win the flag, I must have confused you with ol potato head and for that I apologise.

I’d be happy with Tigers getting up. Been out of the spotlight for 30+ years or so, so good for the supporters who stay loyal. Bit like Geelong in 07 breaking the drought since 1963.

 

[Boppo]

Not sure they win without him.

Makes the AFL call to ban him from playing without committing an offence verging on match fixing. I'm in for a pretty decent payout should GWS win the title and whilst betting isnt the driver for decision making it feeds into the narrative that any bans need to be legal and defensible.

 

[Colonial]

Makes the AFL call to ban him from playing without committing an offence verging on match fixing. I'm in for a pretty decent payout should GWS win the title and whilst betting isnt the driver for decision making it feeds into the narrative that any bans need to be legal and defensible.

Even more so when 3 ex pies sat in on the decision.

 

[South of the Yarra]

Even more so when 3 ex pies sat in on the decision.

Oh Please

 

[Adz]

Whitfield out.

 

[RAPPA]

Whitfield in hospital with appendicitis. Greene will get off now to even things up

 

[dean33]

Giants no chance without Whitfield and Greene... pies one foot in the grand final.

 

[Jizzy_Wizzy]

Leon Cameron Confirmed - Whitfield Out. Massive.

 

[NOBBYS]

Got $2.70 for Richmond Collingwood double early in week.
Money for jam.
Bali here I come.
Collingwood vs GWS absolute blow out.
Not good for the game.

 

[dean33]

Leon Cameron Confirmed - Whitfield Out. Massive.

No Greene, no Whitfield, no ward, no coniglio, probably 4 of their best 5 players. Giants would need a Carlton 99 upset to get up.

 

[Ghost of Punt Road]

Wow. Collingwood has been kissed on the Schlong this week. I wish the Tiges could swap prelim

 

[matey]

Was listening to SEN and Healey goes to Bucks live on air along the lines of, “tell me what your thoughts are to what I am about to tell you. It’s reported that Whitfield is in hospital with appendicitis”. Bucks pauses and says, “not good for Lachie”. Come on Bucks is that the only thing that crossed your mind!