Game Day Collingwood v GWS Giants - Preliminary Finals — Sat 21 Sep, 4:35PM AEST, MCG

[LoungeLizard]

Nah I think hes a Giant who has created a new ID less than 3 hours ago for trolling.
About as brave as Toby Greene - sniping from behind, trying to avoid being seen...

Maybe.

Then let him sook, poor bugger his god will be mia tomorrow

 

[The Filth]

Why you though - think very carefully....the fish rots at the head. Good luck Pies/Tiges GF good for footy. We both have to get there first Geel v GWS??? NOT THE SAME.

BBC1967 - How are you?
Whats your thought on tonights game?
Easy win or still some worries about the Cats who have been one of your bogey sides in the past?

 

[Fuelm18]

Nah I think hes a Giant who has created a new ID less than 3 hours ago for trolling.
About as brave as Toby Greene - sniping from behind, trying to avoid being seen...

Brave.

 

[BBC1967]

BBC1967 - How are you?
Whats your thought on tonights game?
Easy win or still some worries about the Cats who have been one of your bogey sides in the past?

Good - like you very nervous. After 2018 finals are a lottery.

 

[The Filth]

View attachment 749396


Brave.

Proved my point.
Back to the drawing board...
Suggest you use "Gouger" for your next fake Bigfooty ID - and maybe a Swans supporter instead?

 

[The Filth]

Good - like you very nervous. After 2018 finals are a lottery.

They are indeed.
As long as the Tiges don't come down with a bout of 'Preliminitus' you should be fine.
Good luck to you and the Tiges matey

 

[VicBased]

Apparently they would have had 3 ex gws players but sadly, you're a club with no history, no fans and really little place being in the competition. An AFL toy, handed cash on a platter, handed players privileges, draft picks, all placed in an area of Sydney that couldn't give a rat's about what you do.

Probably good to remember that there was a time when collingwood had no history either. Obviously humility is not your strong point.

 

[Gavin Excell]

Would Whitfield and Greene’s absence subconsciously affect Pies players?

 

[Gavin Excell]

Good - like you very nervous. After 2018 finals are a lottery.

Even when my club was flying 2007-09 I always felt nervous finals time, particularly at the pointy end

Anyone who says otherwise I question whether it’s more front than genuinely feeling ultra confident

 

[The Filth]

Even when my club was flying 2007-09 I always felt nervous finals time, particularly at the pointy end

Anyone who says otherwise I question whether it’s more front than genuinely feeling ultra confident

Are you thinking win or loss?

 

[Black white]

Probably good to remember that there was a time when collingwood had no history either. Obviously humility is not your strong point.

Like Fremantle, we were born from the community, gws and WC are an AFL creation. So the bias that the gws fan talks of are laughable.

 

[Gavin Excell]

Are you thinking win or loss?

Both

 

[The Filth]

Would Whitfield and Greene’s absence subconsciously affect Pies players?

Don't know - Greene played well on us last time we played them when they won. Maynard beat him in last years finals though (Greene only got 9 touches) playing tag team with Langdon. Up until this year Greene had only kicked 1 goal against the Pies in his 5 games he had played us.

Whitfield was more of a concern - has played well against us in the past.

Don't think the Pies will get ahead of themselves though. With Pendlebury, Sidebottom etc there should be enough experience and cool heads to cover that.

The concern is getting off to a good start after the weeks break. Got to get the momemtum early.
Lower the eyes and don't just bomb it into the forward line.
I think GWS will try and continue with the rough stuff, Greene or no Greene.
I just hope Mumfield doesn't "accidentally" injure Grundy.

 

[The Filth]

Both

Poor bastard...I hear ya!

 

[Black white]

View attachment 749396


Brave.

View attachment 749396


Brave.

 

[TW Sherrin]

Would Whitfield and Greene’s absence subconsciously affect Pies players?

No Greene means they dont need to wear safety glasses. That's a positive.

 

[Colonial]

Apparently they would have had 3 ex gws players but sadly, you're a club with no history, no fans and really little place being in the competition. An AFL toy, handed cash on a platter, handed players privileges, draft picks, all placed in an area of Sydney that couldn't give a rat's about what you do.

Did Eddie not give you your spanking today or something?
You seem salty.

 

[VicBased]

Like Fremantle, we were born from the community, gws and WC are an AFL creation. So the bias that the gws fan talks of are laughable.

Like WC breaking away from wafl, Collingwood were a breakaway club from the vfa to form vfl. WC helped kickstart AFL so we have a lot in common. Time creates history and mystique to a club and WC will have a solid history in another 50 years. By then Collingwood could be one of the few Melbourne teams left. Things change.

 

[Rotayjay]

Simple issue here is the 4 outs have the potential to get 120 disposals between them
Their substitutes Keefe Reid Daniels Hill lucky to get 40 .
That is too big a discrepancy.
Pies will win by lots.

Normally I'm not a fan of looking at possession numbers in isolation but this is a very good point.

 

[Colonial]

Like Fremantle, we were born from the community, gws and WC are an AFL creation. So the bias that the gws fan talks of are laughable.

Spoken like someone who has no clue about our club.

 

[PieLebo87]

Any objectively minded person would consider that based on a comparable analysis of the outs of GWS against the outs of Pies, GWS are starting behind the 8-ball. Nevertheless, both start the game with 22 players and injuries can go either way when the ball is bounced. Smart money though is on Collingwood for good reason.

As Wheatley and Riewoldt said like for like not in the same league and some comparsons downright embarrassing.Go back to corporate financing.Hope you are much better at that.

So when Pies talk about injuries, whether it’s 2018 or 2019, it’s no biggie, ok cool, I get it.

 

[Xtreme]

Did GWS drop a mirror, pat a black cat and walk under a ladder over the past week ?

Adding to their rotten luck apparently they've had a delayed flight today as well!!!

 

[zhoung]

Or it could be your football world continuing along with yet another GF choke....

The ultimate choke, is Tigers losing 3 grand finals in a row to the Pies
However we thank you for being the fluffers getting us all warmed up for our unmatched fourpeat...

 

[Colonial]

Did GWS drop a mirror, pat a black cat and walk under a ladder over the past week ?

Adding to their rotten luck apparently they've had a delayed flight today as well!!!

All the above.

 

[Tas]

After the Essendon mystery-syringe drama, how can the AFL sit back and allow one of their players, De Goey, flying to Germany to be injected with
Actovegin, an amino acid-rich concoction obtained from the blood of veal calves and contains, among others things, the natural lubricant thyaluronan sucked from the combs of dead roosters. It is injected directly into the damaged tissue along with “a mixture of homoeopathic substances”.

Collingwood should be subjected to the same standards that Essendon was when it comes to the health and safety of it's players.




by a connection of