Collingwood's biggest rival?

[lihei]

I guess you would have a hatred for Carlton given the Colliwobbles have not beaten Carlton in a Grand Final in your past 5 clashes (1915, 1938, 1970, 1979 & 1981). Also in our last clash in a finals game in 1988 as well.

Throw in to the mix as well the greater number of head-to-head wins Carlton has as well.

Gee, I thought the New Year's Eve clash some years back may have made your list

 

[gaelictiogar]

I guess you would have a hatred for Carlton given the Colliwobbles have not beaten Carlton in a Grand Final in your past 5 clashes (1915, 1938, 1970, 1979 & 1981). Also in our last clash in a finals game in 1988 as well.

Throw in to the mix as well the greater number of head-to-head wins Carlton has as well.

Fair enough johnny but surely you are not bragging about beating the Pies in finals...everyone does that. Richmond during the Tiger Train years got fed up doing it. They'd do well against us H and A then turn up before 100,000 at the G with the Tiger hordes in full voice in finals and piss themselves time and time again. Same will happen when we or you get back to finals as well, Richmond and Carlton scare the daylights out of the little Birdies in finals and have since living memory.

 

[zorbadunde]

sorry guys i am going totally the opisite way and saying port adeliade, they are always spiteful and both supporter groups hate each other.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Fair enough johnny but surely you are not bragging about beating the Pies in finals...everyone does that. Richmond during the Tiger Train years got fed up doing it. They'd do well against us H and A then turn up before 100,000 at the G with the Tiger hordes in full voice in finals and piss themselves time and time again. Same will happen when we or you get back to finals as well, Richmond and Carlton scare the daylights out of the little Birdies in finals and have since living memory.

Well, in fairness, we haven't had the chance to test that phenomenon out lately since you've only made the finals twice in the last 24 years...

 

[tess]

i really cant stand st.kilda either for some reason

It's bred into you as a Collingwood person, call em by their proper name if ya want. St Blunda, as you'll see with Carlton as they rise again the Blue-baggers will not Blunda their way through Finals like only St Blunda can.

sorry guys i am going totally the opisite way and saying port adeliade, they are always spiteful and both supporter groups hate each other.

Because they are like a little brother, it would be like playing Williamstown if they ever played in the AFL. We requested their first game be played against us at the MCG, we beat em by 57 points as we taught em a Magpie Style Footy lesson.

They hate us because we ARE the Magpies...
the Mighty Mighty Magpies...
and they are not.

 

[Shellz]

Because they are like a little brother, it would be like playing Williamstown if they ever played in the AFL. We requested their first game be played against us at the MCG, we beat em by 57 points as we taught em a Magpie Style Footy lesson.

They hate us because we ARE the Magpies...
the Mighty Mighty Magpies...
and they are not.

haha love that story, such a good way to welcome them to the AFL. Playing with the big boys now1

 

[Nesian]

Hmmm for me it has to be Brisbane, still scarred by 2 grandfinals and a number of terrible losses since then to them, most memorable being in 2005 and not scoring in the 1st half at the gabba......it just enhanced my hatred.....though i dislike essendon and carlton too, i cant say i hate them the way i passionately hate brisbane

 

[Tzimara]

Surely not! blues4flag. The big 4 in this name, refers to the next 4woodenspooner.

 

[AsianWithAFro]

Carlton the supporters are very scummy and I hate em. Dad and I accidentally got put with the Carlton Cheer squad it was the biggest nightmare ever. They call Whitnall the big red fire engine. I refer as the unorthodox orangutan. The funny thing is his the only player I hate from Carlton so yeah.

 

[Frederlick]

Carlton the supporters are very scummy and I hate em. Dad and I accidentally got put with the Carlton Cheer squad it was the biggest nightmare ever. They call Whitnall the big red fire engine. I refer as the unorthodox orangutan. The funny thing is his the only player I hate from Carlton so yeah.

I think the only reason I didn't get bashed 2nd game last year was my 2 daughters were with me. Serious. That was the game where they dragged guys out for fighting at half time, and a Carlton supporter was arrested throwing a bottle from behind the Jollimont goals in the final quarter, they lost it on and off the field. They turned on us when they realised the Pies had em by the short and curly's on the field. Loved every second of it.

 

[Frederlick]

I love the fact that all three supporters have said Richmond Big 4?

Look at crowds last year. Richmond are very much big 4. Top 4 in AFL for crowds.