Analysis Combined 22 (Premiership Teams)

[Supreme_Chancellor]

Thought this would be a fun thread for everyone to get involved in.

The premise is simple. Create a 22 out of 2 combined premiership teams. Choosing which players you would have over others. The only rule is that you can only pick from the 22 that played on the day.

Some suggestions:

1996 North Melbourne - 1975 North Melbourne
1983 Hawthorn - 2013 Hawthorn
1990 Collingwood - 2010 Collingwood
2000 * - 2009 Geelong
1980 Richmond - 2017 Richmond
1981 Carlton - 1995 Carlton
2006 Meth Coast - 1992 Meth Coast
1954 Footscray - 2016 Footscray

(Sorry if I couldn’t think of better examples).

 

[Gumble Frankieton]

North Melbourne
B:	34 Ross Henshaw	23 David Dench (vc)	38 Frank Gumbleton
HB:	8 Brent Crosswell	15 Malcolm Blight	5 John Rantall
C:	27 Keith Greig	11 John Burns	40 Peter Chisnall
HF:	20 Wayne Schimmelbusch	6 Arnold Briedis	4 Sam Kekovich
F:	28 Gary Farrant	2 Doug Wade	18 Paul Feltham
Foll:	22 Mick Nolan	32 Barry Davis (c)	44 Barry Cable
Res:	10 Barry Goodingham (dvc)	13 Gary Cowton
Coach:	Ron Barassi

[TD valign="top"] North Melbourne

B:	8 Robert Scott	4 Mick Martyn	11 Glenn Archer
HB:	2 Wayne Schwass	6 Ian Fairley	12 John Blakey
C:	34 David King	37 Adam Simpson	7 Dean Laidley
HF:	17 Glenn Freeborn	18 Wayne Carey (c)	33 Brett Allison
F:	24 Craig Sholl	31 Corey McKernan	27 Darren Crocker
Foll:	16 Matthew Capuano	3 Anthony Rock	10 Anthony Stevens
Int:	5 Stuart Anderson	22 Mark Roberts	26 Peter Bell
Coach:	Denis Pagan

Here are the teams as named according to Wikipedia. Blight at CHB?[/TD]

 

[davefromjerra]

Okay here goes.

Archer Dench Gumbleton
Rantall Blight Schwass
Grieg Simpson King
Crosswell Carey Kekovich
Allison Wade Crocker

Nolan Davis Cable

McKernan Scott Laidley Stevens

 

[Gumble Frankieton]

Here's my attempt at selecting the combined '75/'96 team not based on their overall career but purely based on how they played in the GF (as far as I can recall anyway).
I've tried to pick the team as close to their position as is reasonable.


FB. Gumbleton Dench Archer
HB. Crosswell Fairley Rantall
C. Greig Burns Schwass
HF. Briedis Carey Freeborn
FF. Feltham Wade Allison
FOLL. McKernan Stevens Cable
INT. Nolan Davis Rock Kekovich

Unlucky to miss: Laidley, Schimma, Sholl, Roberts, Crocker, Chisnall etc