Opinion Commentary and media

Status
Not open for further replies.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Rooboys Rool

All Australian
Joined
Jan 25, 2016
Posts
844
Likes
2,233
AFL Club
North Melbourne
This is so predictable and lol worthy, but it's also a concern because it's from the players themselves. Makes us look like not a destination club for any of our key targets in the trade / free agency period. Hopefully our on-field performances this year change some minds, and before they've committed elsewhere.
 

lockheed

Club Legend
Joined
Oct 22, 2005
Posts
1,056
Likes
1,640
Location
Night Vale
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
North Melbourne
This is so predictable and lol worthy, but it's also a concern because it's from the players themselves. Makes us look like not a destination club for any of our key targets in the trade / free agency period. Hopefully our on-field performances this year change some minds, and before they've committed elsewhere.
I'm obviously in the minority, but, given a good run with injury, I'm confident we'll improve from last year.

It's going to be hard for us to be a destination club. We're not one of the 'old' traditional clubs, we don't play in front of huge crowds, and we don't have have the commercial backing to dangle the promise of additional commercial or career opportunities. If we want players to be interested in coming to play for us, we need to demonstrate that we're an improving team, and we need to show significant improvement from where we were at the end of last year.
 
Joined
Jun 9, 2001
Posts
20,862
Likes
50,116
Location
Windy Hill Safe Injecting Room
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
St Johnstone
Moderator #6,910
It's a bit like comparing Today Tonight & A Current Affair for me. I find them of a roughly equivalent level of totally shithouse
Fair enough. I wouldn't make an effort to watch the NRL footy show but if it's on in the background it's occasionally entertaining.

I would make an active effort to avoid the AFL footy show.
 

RobZombie

Premium Platinum
Joined
May 18, 2012
Posts
6,107
Likes
14,731
Location
Back In Town
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Jays, Leafs
Good. Let 'em take us lightly.
I'm obviously in the minority, but, given a good run with injury, I'm confident we'll improve from last year.
I can live with that POV. Given the team that played out most of the 2nd half of the season,

Higgins = Wells
McDonald >> Mullett
M Williams > McKenzie (still think Bread wasn't far off making it, but needed one or two of his 'better than serviceable' games to take the step up to 'breakout'. Anyway, Marley's better defensive work should be better for team balance and I'll hold my breath and cross my fingers when he has to kick it).
EVW < Firrito (but different. And by the end of the season could well be > what Spud had declined to)
Durdin = Loogie (not = fit and in form Loogie, but we don't see much of that)
Daw > Petrie (expecting to get some disagreement on this and still has to prove he can do the team things all day like Drew but has more strings to his bow)
Hrovat < Boomer (but looks like filling the role well enough and might actually run both ways)
Dumont = Dal (but needs to step up and get more of the ball, which I'm confident he will)
Goldy > Goldy (please be fit, and at least we can swing Preuss in for a game or two if he needs a rest)

Waite, Wood, Simpkin, Turner, Clarke also likely to fit in as positive contributors.

It's going to be hard for us to be a destination club. We're not one of the 'old' traditional clubs, we don't play in front of huge crowds, and we don't have have the commercial backing to dangle the promise of additional commercial or career opportunities. If we want players to be interested in coming to play for us, we need to demonstrate that we're an improving team, and we need to show significant improvement from where we were at the end of last year.
Has to be one of the themes for the season. Kids or not, sliding down the ladder or not, they can still go about it like a club people would want to be at.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Only Forwards

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 14, 2008
Posts
17,413
Likes
37,157
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Good. Let 'em take us lightly.
This is my view of this year. They can all write us off for all I care.

We lost a chunk of experience sure. We lost a player that will be a legend at our club.

It is like the media and most others have become totally fixated on this point and cannot see anything outside of it.

I find it completely baffling that there is a perception that a core of players that have all played for years together including in high end finals is going to dip so dramatically on the basis of 5 players.

Boomer is not some one who can be replaced automatically. There was questions on his defensive side though.
Had Wells stayed he would be exactly where he is right now, where he was in 2015.
NDS I agree with the comparision to Frog, Frog also a bit more defensive
Spud has caused us to reshuffle things, sure EVW is the heir there, but William, frees you Luke and Ats and our backline looks different before you even consider Spud. I think we will have a system to mitigate some of this loss.

Dish was done. DONE. he can go prove whatever he is trying to in the west, but the bloke couldn't get separation or off the ground as a forward. It was too our detriment too, for any who are brave enough, go watch the first game vs the Hawks from last year, Boomer kicks it to Drew trying to bring him into the game, no separation means a spoiled mark. Boomer was 35-40 meters out, the bloke kicked 518 goals, he could have kicked it but didn't. He tried to bring a player into the game, if it was marked Dish would have had the shot from about 15 out. Its isolated and small, but it was there.

Anyway my ramblings aside, under rate us at your peril, we may not rock up and be premiers this year, but we ain't just gonna roll over and take it either.
 

Orange Peanut

Premiership Player
Joined
Feb 6, 2013
Posts
4,457
Likes
16,724
AFL Club
North Melbourne
This is my view of this year. They can all write us off for all I care.

We lost a chunk of experience sure. We lost a player that will be a legend at our club.

It is like the media and most others have become totally fixated on this point and cannot see anything outside of it.

I find it completely baffling that there is a perception that a core of players that have all played for years together including in high end finals is going to dip so dramatically on the basis of 5 players.

Boomer is not some one who can be replaced automatically. There was questions on his defensive side though.
Had Wells stayed he would be exactly where he is right now, where he was in 2015.
NDS I agree with the comparision to Frog, Frog also a bit more defensive
Spud has caused us to reshuffle things, sure EVW is the heir there, but William, frees you Luke and Ats and our backline looks different before you even consider Spud. I think we will have a system to mitigate some of this loss.

Dish was done. DONE. he can go prove whatever he is trying to in the west, but the bloke couldn't get separation or off the ground as a forward. It was too our detriment too, for any who are brave enough, go watch the first game vs the Hawks from last year, Boomer kicks it to Drew trying to bring him into the game, no separation means a spoiled mark. Boomer was 35-40 meters out, the bloke kicked 518 goals, he could have kicked it but didn't. He tried to bring a player into the game, if it was marked Dish would have had the shot from about 15 out. Its isolated and small, but it was there.

Anyway my ramblings aside, under rate us at your peril, we may not rock up and be premiers this year, but we ain't just gonna roll over and take it either.
Spot friggin on.
 

kangaspurs

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Jul 14, 2014
Posts
8,981
Likes
17,067
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Tottenham, Melbourne City FC
This is my view of this year. They can all write us off for all I care.

We lost a chunk of experience sure. We lost a player that will be a legend at our club.

It is like the media and most others have become totally fixated on this point and cannot see anything outside of it.

I find it completely baffling that there is a perception that a core of players that have all played for years together including in high end finals is going to dip so dramatically on the basis of 5 players.

Boomer is not some one who can be replaced automatically. There was questions on his defensive side though.
Had Wells stayed he would be exactly where he is right now, where he was in 2015.
NDS I agree with the comparision to Frog, Frog also a bit more defensive
Spud has caused us to reshuffle things, sure EVW is the heir there, but William, frees you Luke and Ats and our backline looks different before you even consider Spud. I think we will have a system to mitigate some of this loss.

Dish was done. DONE. he can go prove whatever he is trying to in the west, but the bloke couldn't get separation or off the ground as a forward. It was too our detriment too, for any who are brave enough, go watch the first game vs the Hawks from last year, Boomer kicks it to Drew trying to bring him into the game, no separation means a spoiled mark. Boomer was 35-40 meters out, the bloke kicked 518 goals, he could have kicked it but didn't. He tried to bring a player into the game, if it was marked Dish would have had the shot from about 15 out. Its isolated and small, but it was there.

Anyway my ramblings aside, under rate us at your peril, we may not rock up and be premiers this year, but we ain't just gonna roll over and take it either.
Quoted for truth.

Great post.
 

Kimbo

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Dec 14, 2002
Posts
18,040
Likes
24,861
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Sturt, Liverpool
Good. Let 'em take us lightly.

I can live with that POV. Given the team that played out most of the 2nd half of the season,

Higgins = Wells
McDonald >> Mullett
M Williams > McKenzie (still think Bread wasn't far off making it, but needed one or two of his 'better than serviceable' games to take the step up to 'breakout'. Anyway, Marley's better defensive work should be better for team balance and I'll hold my breath and cross my fingers when he has to kick it).
EVW < Firrito (but different. And by the end of the season could well be > what Spud had declined to)
Durdin = Loogie (not = fit and in form Loogie, but we don't see much of that)
Daw > Petrie (expecting to get some disagreement on this and still has to prove he can do the team things all day like Drew but has more strings to his bow)
Hrovat < Boomer (but looks like filling the role well enough and might actually run both ways)
Dumont = Dal (but needs to step up and get more of the ball, which I'm confident he will)
Goldy > Goldy (please be fit, and at least we can swing Preuss in for a game or two if he needs a rest)

Waite, Wood, Simpkin, Turner, Clarke also likely to fit in as positive contributors.
I see it similarly RobZ, but with this tweaking...

Higgins, Hrovat, Dumont, Clarke = Wells, Boomer, Dal Santo (and Swallow).

Higgins and Hrovat provide the more 'top end' play-making and class in disposal. Higgins has a better defensive side to him. The knock on Hrovat is him not being as good defensively, as he is offensively, but that may also be an age thing. Dumont's disposal numbers will go up imo (already have somewhat?), plus he brings a combination of tackling (covering Swallow), and a better inside/outside game. He can also tag a bit. Clarke covers Dal for mine, in disposals and while not the same class in disposal, it will improve, plus his endurance means he links better with run and is in positions to tackle.

Agree McDonald >> Mullett.
Agree M Williams > McKenzie, but add an extra >. Agree that Marley's better defensive work should be better for team balance, and Jmac and LMac (along with the rest of the backline) to ably clear it. (I think you're Bizarro Kimbo when it comes to Bread.)
EVW < Firrito (but different.) Yeah, it's not a like for like, is it. But what Spud did with a bigger body, EVW might do with smarts and reach. He won't offer the same offensive element as Spud (running through tackles, raking kick or long handball, but he seems smart getting the ball out.
Durdin = Loogie (not = fit and in form Loogie, but we don't see much of that) Durdin currently owns the 'concrete hands' award though. Those clean hands are Loogie's trademark.
Daw = Petrie. Providing Waite and Brown do their bit, I'd be happy enough if Majak is the 'decoy' forward (or third KPF option), applies good defensive pressure and, unlike Drew kicks the gimme goals, though this isn't guaranteed, based on past experience.

Upsides for me:
  • The general enthusiasm and 'ambition' of youth.
  • 2014 draftees, including Nielson, get their go and are at an age where they can begin to make a mark.
  • Similarly, Dumont and Clarke now have the chance to gain serious experience, but aren't debutants either.
  • JZ, Jmac, Tarrant, Thomas (and cohort) all at a good age to lead.
  • Injury-wise, we're better off than in the second half of 2016, and the gap between the lower end of best 22 and the next rung isn't as great as it was. (For example, Turner/Garner/Anderson/Wagner, Nielson/Hanson/Hibberd).
  • Some potential top-liners in Simpkin, Preuss, the new BMac and, in 2018, Ahern.

  • "Marley and Me." (Photo from Hrovat's personal collection.)
 

Kimbo

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Dec 14, 2002
Posts
18,040
Likes
24,861
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Sturt, Liverpool
This is my view of this year. They can all write us off for all I care.

We lost a chunk of experience sure. We lost a player that will be a legend at our club.

It is like the media and most others have become totally fixated on this point and cannot see anything outside of it.
As I have said previously, this will be the narrative for the first half of the year. Until they begin to 'notice' the next generation. The media is always 6-12 months behind the current reality. It's like the players and coaches. They put in a pre-season preparing and planning, but when the season starts, all they have is what they had at the start of the season.

Our media department are doing their bit by (over)using "exciting", but the media want specific players to be able to focus on. Kingy did his bit with Hrovat, Preuss is laying a claim. Unfortunately Dumont and Clarke will go largely unnoticed unless they can get among the goals.

Only Forwards said:
NDS I agree with the comparison to Frog, Frog also a bit lot more defensive
Fixed that for you.

Only Forwards said:
Dish was done. DONE.
Yep, Dish was over-cooked. You know this when adding spring onions doesn't improve the spring and the only beans the dish can handle are 'has beans'.
 

Jindrrk

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Oct 20, 2016
Posts
7,759
Likes
17,647
Location
Macau
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
*, St Dwarves, Lolmond
Gotta be 2-0.

Somehow beat the Eagles at home, really tough game but reckon it can be done and then get Cunners back and smash Geelong.

If 0-2, it's basically season over.
Oh please. 0-2 season over? rofl.

Huge exaggeration. I can see what you are trying to say.....but just no.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom