Mod. Notice Competitions: READ BEFORE POSTING A COMPETITION

Remove this Banner Ad

akkaps

Community Leader
Mar 20, 2012
41,913
27,568
AFL Club
Carlton
Like a FJ&GD Survivor of sorts? I'm actually keen for it 😁
The issue with running a game of Survivor is that early on in the game you get rid of the weaker players as you make your team stronger. And only remove the stronger players past the merge when its individual.
I like the idea of elimination, but Survivor is more of a social game rather than skill game.

I'm sure everyone else will be thrilled with this! Think we had a similar idea to this in the past, based around State of Origin. Think it would be best done by putting designers of approximate abilities into pots and then drawing them all out to get even teams
I was thinking about randomly switching up groups every week or couple of weeks, so that everyone gets a chance with everyone, and so therefore it keeps the groups kinda even.

It might be an idea to dish out points after every round to the winning group(s), groups get shuffled, and a tally is kept for individual performance. Winner would the individual that wins the most weeks.
 

El_Scorcho

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 21, 2007
26,204
63,858
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Aston Villa, San Antonio Spurs
I think collaborative design is really difficult to do well on a forum like this, especially when requiring people to stick to timeframes over multiple rounds.

I do like the idea of process sharing and designing based on the brief and input of others though. Every single sports logo and uniform in existence was put together by a designer following someone else's brief.

I've long held an idea for a weekly comp where we go through the longer term, well established NAFL identities, choosing one each week as the subject where everyone can have a crack at doing their own interpretation of the Boomers, Wellington, Perth Phoenix, etc. Instead of a poll, the winner could be chosen by the team owner.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

cannavo

Yes. I am.
Aug 4, 2012
3,392
4,890
Nunya. Nunya Business
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Yes
After a brief 6 months since my last competition ended, man's itching for that weekly ting!
Brace yourself for.......
New-Team-Who-Dis.png

(Disclaimer: I think something like this has been done before but slightly different, happy to be corrected)
Each week a random Australian suburb will be given a team for the 2021 AFL Season
Location and colours will be chosen via random generators
Team nicknames and designs are completely up to the designer
Colours Gen: https://coolors.co/ Location Gen: https://www.getrandomthings.com/list-of-cities-in-australia.php
The winners get to choose how many times the generators will be used for the next team
Last time I asked for 3 kits, now the bare minimum is 1! (if you choose the Home to be the away as well)
Lets get the creative juices flowing again! Open to tweaks and ideas too​
 

cannavo

Yes. I am.
Aug 4, 2012
3,392
4,890
Nunya. Nunya Business
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Yes
After a brief 6 months since my last competition ended, man's itching for that weekly ting!
Brace yourself for.......
View attachment 893546
(Disclaimer: I think something like this has been done before but slightly different, happy to be corrected)
Each week a random Australian suburb will be given a team for the 2021 AFL Season
Location and colours will be chosen via random generators
Team nicknames and designs are completely up to the designer
Colours Gen: https://coolors.co/ Location Gen: https://www.getrandomthings.com/list-of-cities-in-australia.php
The winners get to choose how many times the generators will be used for the next team
Last time I asked for 3 kits, now the bare minimum is 1! (if you choose the Home to be the away as well)
Lets get the creative juices flowing again! Open to tweaks and ideas too​
Is it 10 likes or 10 reactions for the green light?
Anyway, for that bit of authenticity, I will screencapture the random generators being used and upload the footage to Youtube as unlisted so only you guys can see it. Rules are done, quick edit, it's a minumum of 2 jumpers now.
/AFLClashJumperPolicy
 

craegus

A New Dawn has Broken
Aug 8, 2008
6,899
7,112
Campbelltown
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Arsenal
After a brief 6 months since my last competition ended, man's itching for that weekly ting!
Brace yourself for.......
View attachment 893546
(Disclaimer: I think something like this has been done before but slightly different, happy to be corrected)
Each week a random Australian suburb will be given a team for the 2021 AFL Season
Location and colours will be chosen via random generators
Team nicknames and designs are completely up to the designer
Colours Gen: https://coolors.co/ Location Gen: https://www.getrandomthings.com/list-of-cities-in-australia.php
The winners get to choose how many times the generators will be used for the next team
Last time I asked for 3 kits, now the bare minimum is 1! (if you choose the Home to be the away as well)
Lets get the creative juices flowing again! Open to tweaks and ideas too​
Is it 10 likes or 10 reactions for the green light?
Anyway, for that bit of authenticity, I will screencapture the random generators being used and upload the footage to Youtube as unlisted so only you guys can see it. Rules are done, quick edit, it's a minumum of 2 jumpers now.
/AFLClashJumperPolicy
I know you have the likes and all, but I totally forgot to reply to the original post with an edit that I would have suggested.

Basically my main concerns for this is that we have done so many things related to Australia, and I am worried that this could cross a bit too much into the realm of the NAFL where people may accidently design something similar to peoples plans for the upcoming season. It is unlikely with the randomised colours and locations, but it is possible that similarities could happen.

So my suggestion was going to be instead of making the competition an expansion of the AFL, that you take the ideas of an old "competition/workshop" called the IARP (International Australian Rules Premiership). It was an idea that myself and two other designers (Cory and Gava) had where the three of us competed against each other using international locations, team names, and colours suggested by others, and had to come up with a full brand for this team (kits and logos - though the logos were generally recolours).

If you were to make the change (where you could keep the random location and colour generation), you could base the idea on random international locations and colours where people may have never thought of to design for, and it would allow for some really interesting ideas that may have never been thought of before.

I am ok if you keep it in Australia, but this may just add a bit more creativity and thinking out of the box to the idea.

(Link to the original IARP Challenge)
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Freight Train

Board man gets paid.
Sep 12, 2015
5,860
11,765
The West
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Cherries, Glory, Marítimo, Raptors
After a brief 6 months since my last competition ended, man's itching for that weekly ting!
Brace yourself for.......
View attachment 893546
(Disclaimer: I think something like this has been done before but slightly different, happy to be corrected)
Each week a random Australian suburb will be given a team for the 2021 AFL Season
Location and colours will be chosen via random generators
Team nicknames and designs are completely up to the designer
Colours Gen: https://coolors.co/ Location Gen: https://www.getrandomthings.com/list-of-cities-in-australia.php
The winners get to choose how many times the generators will be used for the next team
Last time I asked for 3 kits, now the bare minimum is 1! (if you choose the Home to be the away as well)
Lets get the creative juices flowing again! Open to tweaks and ideas too​
Yeah Craegus brought up what I was also thinking, I’m a touch worried there will be significant overlap with NAFL, especially with the much larger NAFL competition this season, depending on how it’s approached.

I could just be overthinking it, tho.
 

Sparkle

#SwampratStyle
Oct 3, 2013
3,403
5,503
BigFooty
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
DJRTP, MELR, UTA, MCI
I know you have the likes and all, but I totally forgot to reply to the original post with an edit that I would have suggested.

Basically my main concerns for this is that we have done so many things related to Australia, and I am worried that this could cross a bit too much into the realm of the NAFL where people may accidently design something similar to peoples plans for the upcoming season. It is unlikely with the randomised colours and locations, but it is possible that similarities could happen.

So my suggestion was going to be instead of making the competition an expansion of the AFL, that you take the ideas of an old "competition/workshop" called the IARP (International Australian Rules Premiership). It was an idea that myself and two other designers (Cory and Gava) had where the three of us competed against each other using international locations, team names, and colours suggested by others, and had to come up with a full brand for this team (kits and logos - though the logos were generally recolours).

If you were to make the change (where you could keep the random location and colour generation), you could base the idea on random international locations and colours where people may have never thought of to design for, and it would allow for some really interesting ideas that may have never been thought of before.

I am ok if you keep it in Australia, but this may just add a bit more creativity and thinking out of the box to the idea.

(Link to the original IARP Challenge)
At least for me personally (but I'm sure others feel the same), designing for places outside Australia just doesn't have the same connection or realism, and I sometimes don't have the same enthusiasm as I would for somewhere in Australia. I feel like there might not be as much interest in designing for cities outside Australia as there would be for Australian cities

An idea to not encroach on possible NAFL ideas cannavo would be to do away with the random city simulator (which I played around on and brought up Geelong more than once) and instead create a list of small towns and suburbs (such as those with a population under 100,000) for either you or the winners to select from
 

craegus

A New Dawn has Broken
Aug 8, 2008
6,899
7,112
Campbelltown
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Arsenal
An idea to not encroach on possible NAFL ideas cannavo would be to do away with the random city simulator (which I played around on and brought up Geelong more than once) and instead create a list of small towns and suburbs (such as those with a population under 100,000) for either you or the winners to select from
That could actually encroach even more on the NAFL unfortunately. Especially with the changes happening in the NAFL this season.
 

Teen Wolf

Club Legend
Jul 5, 2011
2,852
4,203
Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Rancho Carne Toros
+1 for places outside Australia. Originality and creativity will be greater, even if participation is lower.

And another suggestion, instead of the same old boring 'Everybody Votes for a Winner' at the end of each round, what about a reverse-IARP where an esteemed panel of three judges pick the best design (or they even do a 3-2-1 Brownlow style). Makes it more prestigious!
 

fancyscum

I C O N
May 19, 2012
4,217
8,662
Melbourne
AFL Club
Adelaide
+1 for places outside Australia. Originality and creativity will be greater, even if participation is lower.

And another suggestion, instead of the same old boring 'Everybody Votes for a Winner' at the end of each round, what about a reverse-IARP where an esteemed panel of three judges pick the best design (or they even do a 3-2-1 Brownlow style). Makes it more prestigious!
Love this suggestion
 

cannavo

Yes. I am.
Aug 4, 2012
3,392
4,890
Nunya. Nunya Business
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Yes
I know you have the likes and all, but I totally forgot to reply to the original post with an edit that I would have suggested.

Basically my main concerns for this is that we have done so many things related to Australia, and I am worried that this could cross a bit too much into the realm of the NAFL where people may accidently design something similar to peoples plans for the upcoming season. It is unlikely with the randomised colours and locations, but it is possible that similarities could happen.

So my suggestion was going to be instead of making the competition an expansion of the AFL, that you take the ideas of an old "competition/workshop" called the IARP (International Australian Rules Premiership). It was an idea that myself and two other designers (Cory and Gava) had where the three of us competed against each other using international locations, team names, and colours suggested by others, and had to come up with a full brand for this team (kits and logos - though the logos were generally recolours).

If you were to make the change (where you could keep the random location and colour generation), you could base the idea on random international locations and colours where people may have never thought of to design for, and it would allow for some really interesting ideas that may have never been thought of before.

I am ok if you keep it in Australia, but this may just add a bit more creativity and thinking out of the box to the idea.

(Link to the original IARP Challenge)
Yeah Craegus brought up what I was also thinking, I’m a touch worried there will be significant overlap with NAFL, especially with the much larger NAFL competition this season, depending on how it’s approached.

I could just be overthinking it, tho.
At least for me personally (but I'm sure others feel the same), designing for places outside Australia just doesn't have the same connection or realism, and I sometimes don't have the same enthusiasm as I would for somewhere in Australia. I feel like there might not be as much interest in designing for cities outside Australia as there would be for Australian cities

An idea to not encroach on possible NAFL ideas cannavo would be to do away with the random city simulator (which I played around on and brought up Geelong more than once) and instead create a list of small towns and suburbs (such as those with a population under 100,000) for either you or the winners to select from
+1 for places outside Australia. Originality and creativity will be greater, even if participation is lower.

And another suggestion, instead of the same old boring 'Everybody Votes for a Winner' at the end of each round, what about a reverse-IARP where an esteemed panel of three judges pick the best design (or they even do a 3-2-1 Brownlow style). Makes it more prestigious!
Thanks for the 2 cents everyone!

NAFL didn't cross my mind but I can understand the possibility of design/location coincidences. So I will include international places too, and instead of the teams "entering the 2021 AFL season" I'll have these teams compete in like an international pre-season cup to make more sense. Then after say 32 teams have been done, I'll poll the teams playing a cup for an ultimate winner. Whether the next team will be Australian or International will rely on a coin toss (keeping that random factor in)
Thread will be up soon
 

Top Bottom