Cooney, Chappy or BJ

[Bombermania]

Tough question but I will go with Chappy, whilst peak Cooney and Goddard might be better players but they haven maintained their peak for as long as Chappy has maintained his. The other thing I like about Chappy is that he is every bit as good in the middle as he is when he goes forward.

In an ideal world I would have all three

 

[I Remember Bluey]

Tough question but I will go with Chappy, whilst peak Cooney and Goddard might be better players but they haven maintained their peak for as long as Chappy has maintained his. The other thing I like about Chappy is that he is every bit as good in the middle as he is when he goes forward.

In an ideal world I would have all three

Guess what.

 

[Andronicus]

This hypothetical is causing me far more inner angst than it should.

 

[Runk]

I don't know what a Cooney or Chappy is, but I'll take a BJ every day of the week thanks!

 

[akiva]

BJ in 2010, at his peak, was saints best midfield, best defender and second best forward (behind Riewoldt).

and thats when st. kilda were playing in grand finals..

 

[LB#16]

BJ in 2010, at his peak, was saints best midfield, best defender and second best forward (behind Riewoldt).

and thats when st. kilda were playing in grand finals..

It's sad that when people talk up Goddard it's always the St Kilda days. Hopefully there is still something special to happen at Essendon

 

[Ashton Agar]

BJ in 2010, at his peak, was saints best midfield, best defender and second best forward (behind Riewoldt).

and thats when st. kilda were playing in grand finals..

Lenny Hayes, Nick Dal Santo, Leigh Montagna... he had some good competition in the midfield...

 

[akiva]

Lenny Hayes, Nick Dal Santo, Leigh Montagna... he had some good competition in the midfield...

he did but i still think that during the 2010 finals he was unstoppable..