Cooney or Walker

[gandaal]

All signs say McLean will be twice the player of West

ROFL!!

 

[The_Flying_Egg]

36 touches, but the scary thing is this.... he ain't even 100% fit (hence the extended time he spends on the bench).

McLean for PM.

And for the record Cooney is twice as good as Walker. But Brock > All.

And Cooney, Walker, Ray > Sylvia

Sure im being off topic but I didn't think this poll was about McLean either

 

[davey_magik]

And Cooney, Walker, Ray > Sylvia

Sure im being off topic but I didn't think this poll was about McLean either

I agree on Cooney and Walker > Sylvia atm, but not Ray. Sylvia's last two games vs Brisbane have shown more than anything I have seen Ray do.

 

[The_Flying_Egg]

I agree on Cooney and Walker > Sylvia atm, but not Ray. Sylvia's last two games vs Brisbane have shown more than anything I have seen Ray do.

U clearly haven't been watching Ray than. Since about round 10 Ray has established himself in our lineup with his run and skill. He's averaging about 19 touches in that period and in games against Carlton, Port and Freo he has been amongst our best. In most games in the 2nd half of the season he has been good

Sylvia on the other hand struggles to get doube figure disposals in half his games, and has made an impact on maybe 2 or 3 games at most this season. He is tough and has a dip, but he is not making an impact on games, and certainly not getting enough of the ball.

Ray has had a better season than Sylvia in a canter

 

[Hostage]

The cheese man for me

 

[SIR SAINT HOTDOG]

GEE I WONDER


Conney easily. Sure he is soft and will never be a leader, but he is a gamebreaker

Walker is simply a dud


But Mclean is better than both, so who cares

y would u bring that into this thread???

 

[Richo83]

IMO:

Cooney = McClean >> Raines > Ray > Walker > Sylvia.

As in Cooney IMO is just as good as McClean, but are good at different things are are different players.

 

[Top Dog]

U clearly haven't been watching Ray than. Since about round 10 Ray has established himself in our lineup with his run and skill. He's averaging about 19 touches in that period and in games against Carlton, Port and Freo he has been amongst our best. In most games in the 2nd half of the season he has been good

Sylvia on the other hand struggles to get doube figure disposals in half his games, and has made an impact on maybe 2 or 3 games at most this season. He is tough and has a dip, but he is not making an impact on games, and certainly not getting enough of the ball.

Ray has had a better season than Sylvia in a canter

Davey_Magic = Owned!

Ray has been far better than Sylvia this season. Every Dees supporter I speak to is constantly disappointed with Sylvias ouptut. In all seriousness I've only seen him play 3-4 good games, but then again I haven't watched every Demons game. I do however, keep an eye out on his stats etc after most games.

 

[Sylvia Saint]

No arguments from me re. Sylvia. He needs to lift.