Coughlan vs S.Black

[Skooks]

Both Perth boys

Who is and will turn out to be the better player?

 

[bettsie]

Future vs Past.
voted cogs, but i dont think he'll win a brownlow.

 

[meh]

IMO a fit coughlan is a much more damaging player than black.

But black is still a classy player.

 

[F/D]

Future vs Past.
voted cogs, but i dont think he'll win a brownlow.

Um Blacks 25 and Cogs is 23

How is thet future V past?

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Um Blacks 25 and Cogs is 23

How is thet future V past?

LOL

Black>Mitchell at the moment in their respective careers

 

[bradrowe#32]

I always get confused about these polls. Do we judge them on there careers? If so, Black would win hands down because of the individual and team honours he has. But if you judge it on the way they play, choosing Coughlan has some merit. I love the way he plays. Great skills and fearless.

 

[sante]

Coughlan the GUN

 

[Ricketts]

Black by so far.

 

[tigerT]

Black is a champion, premiership player and brownlow medalist but i wouldnt swap him for cogs

 

[celtic_pride]

Simon Black, Coughlan will never be half as good as the Brownlow medalist.

 

[cs61]

Black by so far its not funny. Shows how underated he his. 3 premierships, a brownlow and a norm smith medal... god imagine if Judd has this at his age...... he'd be making it big in hollywood with all the attention he gets.

Black has acheived an amazing amount for his age, and in my opinion is seriously underated.

 

[BulldogMike]

Simon Black.

 

[Bentleigh]

Black is a champion.

Wouldnt trade him for Cogs.

 

[Nightwolf]

Black is no.1 in the AFL IMO, Superstar!

 

[Syd Kennets]

Coughlan's disposal is so far inferior to Blacks.

Hence Black.

 

[windyhill]

Black by so far , call this one off.