Could Collingwood follow Richmond and the Bulldogs

Can Collingwood win the flag in 2018?

  • Yay

    Votes: 142 22.0%
  • Nay

    Votes: 503 78.0%

  • Total voters
    645

RobbieGray17

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Sep 19, 2007
Posts
10,697
Likes
5,167
Location
adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Thread starter #1
Quite clearly they have underperformed, they lost a lot of competitive games last season and don't seem too far off the mark. They appear to be in a similar frame to Richmond in 2016 with a crap game plan, crap implementation and not getting the best out of the team. Their list is relatively robust and have a number of excellent players.

The question is: do you think they can surprise and win the flag?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

blitzer

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Aug 27, 2006
Posts
5,502
Likes
5,588
Location
House
AFL Club
Essendon
#3
I can't see where they lose a game.

In seriousness - there is some similarities to those lists and certainly making finals is not out of the question. I can't see a flag in their current list though. I do think that if Elliot ever stayed fit for longer than 2 minutes it would completely transform that forward line into something pretty good which would be well supported by their excellent midfield.
 

JayJ20

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Aug 28, 2016
Posts
7,852
Likes
11,025
AFL Club
Essendon
#5
I think they can, but they'd need more to go right than Richmond to win it. They certainly have the midfield. They'd need to restructure their forwardline like Richmond did. Ultimately, I think their defence will stop them from reaching Richmond's heights. Richmond have an elite defence. Collingwood don't have that level of quality. Richmond's top end is also stronger than Collingwood's.
 

LB#16

Premiership Player
Joined
Mar 28, 2010
Posts
4,432
Likes
4,552
Location
Central Victoria
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Miami Heat
#6
Bulldogs fully rebuilt and played finals the year before their flag. Richmond played finals for years before dropping down and having a ‘reality check’ year in 2016, then they got it together and went all the way.

Collingwood have been flailing for years, I can’t see the similarity.
 

aussierulesrules

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jan 7, 2011
Posts
26,211
Likes
42,821
Location
Heaven. I mean Victoria.
AFL Club
St Kilda
#8
They won 8 of the 10 games that Daniel Wells played for them last season, but just 1 of the 12 that he didn't play :eek:, so clearly if he manages to stay out there this year they'll be a big show!

On a slightly more serious note, there is a bit of a similarity between them and Richmond of last year, in that Collingwood have also had a pretty big overhaul of their coaching department, and are also apparently going about things very differently this preseason, so there's always the chance that things could click, and I particularly liked to hear that they want to play more to their strengths this year, which is what I would think everyone should be looking to do.

If in previous seasons they've been trying to be something they're not, it's no surprise they haven't gone that well.

The likelihood of them winning the flag is extremely small tho, especially with so few who look like being able to kick a decent number of goals, and the main two by far both missing a big chunk of the preseason.
 
Last edited:

Dez!

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Posts
29,493
Likes
20,014
Location
Melbourne, Victoria
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Chicago Bulls
#9
Prior to Richmond doing it, I would have said "never". No chance.

But if Hardwick can suddenly turn out to be a decent coach, so can Buckley.
Well that has no logic to it at all.

Between 2016 and 2017 Richmond actually made moves to improve their list both of which significantly contributed to 2017, Prestia and Caddy.

Between 2017 and 2018 Collingwood have stood still and didn't make any significant change to their list, next year they are going to be relying solely on internal growth which limits their improvement compared to other teams being proactive and getting proven talent or taking a risk on something to go with the internal growth.

Dogs took a risk on Boyd which paid off at the right time.
Richmond secured proven AFL level talent in Prestia/Caddy to go with their expectation of internal growth/improvement.

Collingwood just seem to be floating by and not doing anything to help out the likes of Darcy Moore who is supposed to be a key piece of their future, they haven't found any help for him nor do they even seem to be trying to find help. If they were waiting on someone like Tom Lynch to hit FA and hoping he'd be the guy to slot in next to Moore that's fine but in the short term at least find someone who can give Moore some protection.

*I'm aware you didn't insinuate you'd win the flag next year*
 
Joined
Aug 18, 2010
Posts
1,295
Likes
2,819
Location
Melbs
AFL Club
Collingwood
#10
Well that has no logic to it at all.

Between 2016 and 2017 Richmond actually made moves to improve their list both of which significantly contributed to 2017, Prestia and Caddy.

Between 2017 and 2018 Collingwood have stood still and didn't make any significant change to their list, next year they are going to be relying solely on internal growth which limits their improvement compared to other teams being proactive and getting proven talent or taking a risk on something to go with the internal growth.

Dogs took a risk on Boyd which paid off at the right time.
Richmond secured proven AFL level talent in Prestia/Caddy to go with their expectation of internal growth/improvement.

Collingwood just seem to be floating by and not doing anything to help out the likes of Darcy Moore who is supposed to be a key piece of their future, they haven't found any help for him nor do they even seem to be trying to find help. If they were waiting on someone like Tom Lynch to hit FA and hoping he'd be the guy to slot in next to Moore that's fine but in the short term at least find someone who can give Moore some protection.

*I'm aware you didn't insinuate you'd win the flag next year*
Yeah, there are other issues like an assessment of the list that are separate.

My point was just that from outside, everyone assumed Hardwick was no good. Just like we assume Buckley is no good. But then Hardwick turned out not to be a problem. So, since a lot of the arguments against Collingwood succeeding are about Buckley's abilities as coach, and since it seems pretty clear that we're all bad judges of who's a good coach, I'm more open now to the possibility that we can do well.

It's notable, IMO, that while they made no real list changes they did make a bunch of coaching changes (although perhaps not enough). So they identified a problem and tried to fix it, or so I would guess, just like Richmond did.

Of cpourse, Richmond might be better at identifying problems and fixing them than we are... (probably this is the case).
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

THECHIEFTON

Premiership Player
Joined
Apr 25, 2011
Posts
3,284
Likes
4,713
Location
Launceston
AFL Club
Richmond
#12
Nah more likely to be Essendon. Tracking similar with making finals but not winning. Recruited some good players to add to a decent list.
 
Joined
Oct 23, 2015
Posts
1,658
Likes
3,376
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Baltimore ravens
#13
Yeah, there are other issues like an assessment of the list that are separate.

My point was just that from outside, everyone assumed Hardwick was no good. Just like we assume Buckley is no good. But then Hardwick turned out not to be a problem. So, since a lot of the arguments against Collingwood succeeding are about Buckley's abilities as coach, and since it seems pretty clear that we're all bad judges of who's a good coach, I'm more open now to the possibility that we can do well.

It's notable, IMO, that while they made no real list changes they did make a bunch of coaching changes (although perhaps not enough). So they identified a problem and tried to fix it, or so I would guess, just like Richmond did.

Of cpourse, Richmond might be better at identifying problems and fixing them than we are... (probably this is the case).
Actually just to point out hardwick was a big part of the problem as admitted by himself. He went away identified his faults and changed his direction ...new game plan, new philosophy,new assistant coaches, Balme, and three very good inclusions to the team in the off season... It's a rare fella who can admit to himself he got it wrong and then change essentially himself... Hardwick managed to do that... I hope for collingwoods sake Buckley has that in him
 

Bazza97

Premiership Player
Joined
Nov 17, 2016
Posts
3,060
Likes
2,954
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Melbourne
#14
I reckon Collingwood will at least improve but probably not enough to make the top 8. Can they win the flag? No I wouldn't think so. Can they improve enough to make the bottom half of the top 8? Yes, if a fair bit goes right they can potentially play finals next season but I think that's unlikely from where I see it atm.
 
Joined
Apr 18, 2005
Posts
17,647
Likes
13,504
AFL Club
Melbourne
#16
I don't know about a flag, but I definitely think they can make the 8 and cause some headaches. They have a very strong core list albeit for a lack of KPF depth.

I wouldn't be surprised at all if they made the 8, yet plenty of people on BF are conceding they don't have a good list at all .
 

Shazza_

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Jan 2, 2018
Posts
8,782
Likes
33,450
AFL Club
Richmond
#17
Nope

Their list is poor compared to ours at the end of 2016. We then added Nank, Prestia and Caddy.

They have a poor list and haven’t added anyone good + they have one of the worst clueless coaches in the league. No chance of winning the flag
 

Martyn_30_

Club Legend
Joined
Sep 14, 2007
Posts
1,863
Likes
2,261
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
#18
I don’t see any similarities. Richmond were terrible did a full rebuild gradually improved had one bad year then bounced back. The bulldogs become too old bottomed out brought in youth then got a better coach.

The only reason Collingwood would be considered as some sort of bolter is because they’re Collingwood, if North had the same list build they wouldn’t be talked up.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

Gavin Excell

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Apr 22, 2007
Posts
23,980
Likes
23,736
Location
Bentleigh
AFL Club
Geelong
#21
They won 8 of the 10 games that Daniel Wells played for them last season, but just 1 of the 12 that he didn't play :eek:, so clearly if he manages to stay out there this year they'll be a big show!

On a slightly more serious note, there is a bit of a similarity between them and Richmond of last year, in that Collingwood have also had a pretty big overhaul of their coaching department, and are also apparently going about things very differently this preseason, so there's always the chance that things could click, and I particularly liked to hear that they want to play more to their strengths this year, which is what I would think everyone should be looking to do.

If in previous seasons they've been trying to be something they're not, it's no surprise they haven't gone that well.

The likelihood of them winning the flag is extremely small tho, especially with so few who look like being able to kick a decent number of goals, and the main two by far both missing a big chunk of the preseason.
That stat on Wells interesting
 

juss

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Feb 23, 2009
Posts
14,604
Likes
17,644
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
New York Jets
#22
Looking at Collingwood’s list, they don’t have the top end talent of the Tigers. Martin and Rance are better than every player on their list and Riewoldt gives the Tigers a guns at both ends not mention Cotchin who was outstanding in the finals.

Maybe if Buckley had those 4 players, but he doesn’t have the same top shelf as the Tigers.
 

captain cotch 9

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Dec 5, 2012
Posts
10,486
Likes
25,933
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Knicks, Jets
#24
I don't see Buckley as the sort of person to take a big risk in regards to his game plan like Beverage or Hardwick did.
 

TerryWallet

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jan 27, 2008
Posts
10,470
Likes
22,216
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
#25
Rather than possibly emulating Richmond or Bulldogs, i see Collingwood possibly emulating my Club at times over this century.

Deluded, pig-headed, sleepwalking their list into no mans land.

I'm not a Pies hater, i'm a rare Carlton fan who doesn't really hate Collingwood or Richmond. I save that for Essendon and Hawthorn :). But as a witness of Carlton's demise, i see many similar traits at Collingwood. The place is pretty messy offield and onfield imho.
 
Top Bottom