I don't think he is far off Bont if behind at all. I will say I feel Bont is applauded more cause he tends to hit the scoreboard better.If he gets a NS he’s clearly better than Bont
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I don't think he is far off Bont if behind at all. I will say I feel Bont is applauded more cause he tends to hit the scoreboard better.If he gets a NS he’s clearly better than Bont
Imagine if he does it at GCS..Nope because he still won’t beat Dustys 2017 season of:
Brownlow, MVP, Coaches award, Gary Ayres award, NS, AA, B&F and a flag.
It will never be beaten.
Imagine if he does it at GCS..
I mean the last 20 years their has been some crazy good players you add forwards, defenders not sure Lachie Neale is getting in, but if it's the top 50 midfielders in the last 20 years than yeah he gets in.Most lions fans won't have him as the GOAT. I feel that's ridiculous. But anyone claiming he isn't top 50 of the last 20 years is just out and out stupidity.
He doesn’t even have a stand so he has no tiers.Then he’ll be 2 tiers better than the Ablett’s instead of 1
He doesn’t even have a stand so he has no tiers.
I know brownlow night can be controversial at times but he has won it twice. Very well could of been a 3 time brownlow medallist if it wasn't for an overturned decision (not saying right or wrong). He could poll top 3 if not win it this year too. That's a fairly sound effort that not alot of other players have done.I mean the last 20 years their has been some crazy good players you add forwards, defenders not sure Lachie Neale is getting in, but if it's the top 50 midfielders in the last 20 years than yeah he gets in.
lol no, Lauchie Neale isn't currently and won't be considered in the top 100 players to ever play by the time he's finished, silly thread, silly op, end of discussion, close thread.
More like he’s hocking those worthless trinkets to a pawn shop so he can make room for some from GC that will actually have merit.No but he’s a very generous man. I heard he is renting out his premiership medals to GAS so he can actually feel like a good player for a change.
Where do you rate players like Bont and Fyfe then? They are a similar tiers no?
Neale is a little underrated imo. Flag this year might change it if he plays well in the GF.
Agree. Probably the worst tattoos in the history of tattoos ..not just footy.Only thing he is GOAT of is shit tattoos.
He isn’t top 50. You got 25 forwards and backs joining the top 25 mids of the last 20 years ..and he’s not in it.Most lions fans won't have him as the GOAT. I feel that's ridiculous. But anyone claiming he isn't top 50 of the last 20 years is just out and out stupidity.
Makes up for the Cripps brownlow when he should have been rubbed out.His second awarded medal is a joke. But it’s not his fault the umpires are imbeciles.
Agree. Probably the worst tattoos in the history of tattoos ..not just footy.
Worse than Wow Jones ..but his suited him.
Neale kicks like a wounded mule and is a good hard running midfielder.
His second awarded medal is a joke. But it’s not his fault the umpires are imbeciles.
3 time Brownlow winner besides Reynolds, Skilton, Bunton and Stewart would be so incredibly cringeworthy it’s not even funny.
Ye but people always jump the gun and make GOAT threads all the time, it's embarassing imo.I know brownlow night can be controversial at times but he has won it twice. Very well could of been a 3 time brownlow medallist if it wasn't for an overturned decision (not saying right or wrong). He could poll top 3 if not win it this year too. That's a fairly sound effort that not alot of other players have done.
Add Lappin and there’s 5 by a country mile more damaging than NealeYe but people always jump the gun and make GOAT threads all the time, it's embarassing imo.
I can name 4 Lions that would be rated hands down ahead of him & that's just 1 club out of 18.
Michael Voss
Simon Black
Jason Akermanis
Jonathan Brown
I am probably missing somoene great from the Lions 3-peat but those 4 names that come to mind that are hands down above Neale.
All while statistically being beaten by Dangerfield in every important category.Nope because he still won’t beat Dustys 2017 season of:
Brownlow, MVP, Coaches award, Gary Ayres award, NS, AA, B&F and a flag.
It will never be beaten.
I think you are a bit harsh, but of course its about how you work out what makes a GOAT. Quality? Quantity? Do you include how versatile they were?Ye but people always jump the gun and make GOAT threads all the time, it's embarassing imo.
I can name 4 Lions that would be rated hands down ahead of him & that's just 1 club out of 18.
Michael Voss
Simon Black
Jason Akermanis
Jonathan Brown
I am probably missing somoene great from the Lions 3-peat but those 4 names that come to mind that are hands down above Neale.
Obviously this is a troll thread, but to those taking it seriously for some reason, Leigh Matthews is indisputably the GOAT and he never won a Brownlow or a Norm.