Could NAS be the best indigenous player ever?

[Freomaniac]

Are we still pretending that Nas is as good as Kossie?

Nope Liam Jurrah Trumps both of them lol

 

[AFLOnline]

Are we still pretending that Nas is as good as Kossie?

Definitely an amazing game but maybe you’ve already forgotten what Nas did to you guys last season?

Not trying to take away from Kozi’s game tonight. It was exceptional. But I’d love to see what Nas would do with no one anywhere near him at any point in the game like Kozi had tonight.

 

[Farm Boy]

Are we still pretending that Nas is as good as Kossie?

The eye test says no one is as good as Kozi. He is up there with Ablett jr as just absolute freakish talents.

 

[Former Decathlete]

Definitely an amazing game but maybe you’ve already forgotten what Nas did to you guys last season?

Not trying to take away from Kozi’s game tonight. It was exceptional. But I’d love to see what Nas would do with no one anywhere near him at any point in the game like Kozi had tonight.

Kosi had three huge games this season so far.

So it's not just tonight.

 

[AFLOnline]

Kosi had three huge games this season so far.

So it's not just tonight.

Against who? And who was playing on him?

Yeah he’s insanely good. He’s had 3 huge games. So he’s past Nas based off them 3 games now?

Nas game vs Melbourne last season was one of the best individual games on a historical level. Kozi played Richmond tonight, missing their best player…

 

[00Stinger]

Definitely an amazing game but maybe you’ve already forgotten what Nas did to you guys last season?

Not trying to take away from Kozi’s game tonight. It was exceptional. But I’d love to see what Nas would do with no one anywhere near him at any point in the game like Kozi had tonight.

Yeah not a game I would like to remember. That game would be Saints fans equivalent of a premiership I would imagine.
Waiting for them to release it on DVD so their supporters can put in the mantle piece silent to the Streak DVD or whatever it was called when they won 10 games in a row in the early 00's

Against who? And who was playing on him?

Yeah he’s insanely good. He’s had 3 huge games. So he’s past Nas based off them 3 games now?

Nas game vs Melbourne last season was one of the best individual games on a historical level. Kozi played Richmond tonight, missing their best player…

Seriously Nas had one good season and has done **** all this year.

The fact St kilda paid him $2m is exactly why they are in no man's land and effectively have taken North's place as the joke club throwing ridiculuos cash around that they shouldn't

 

[yulong]

Kosi had three huge games this season so far.

So it's not just tonight.

And not a bad 2025 either

 

[Former Decathlete]

Against who? And who was playing on him?

Yeah he’s insanely good. He’s had 3 huge games. So he’s past Nas based off them 3 games now?

Nas game vs Melbourne last season was one of the best individual games on a historical level. Kozi played Richmond tonight, missing their best player…

This is what annoys me about big footy folk

It's fine to support your own player but don't do it by lying and talking down another player

I said Kosi has had 3 HUGE games THIS SEASON.

Now you lie and pretend he's only had 3 good games his whole career and has done nothing before this season.

Kosi was in fact AA in 2025.

He hasn't gone past Nas because he was already ahead.

Nas has heaps of potential but he never went past Kosi in the first place.

Saints fans did something similar with Leek Aleer.
Rather than admit the club stuffed up his recruitment..saints fans decided to tell lies about him saying he couldn't get a game for gws

What actually happened is he had a bad groin injury and didn't do a pre season at all..

Talk up your own player and club sure but don't lie and shit can other players.

You are blocked.

 

[Chip Scab1]

This thread is pretty insulting to Franklin.

Yeah insulting to;

Lance Franklin (2nd best CHF all time)
Winston Abraham (pound for pound the best kick of a football ever)
Byron Pickett (champion, hard, fast and skilled)
Jimmy Krak (absolute gun)
Barry Cable (probably the best smaller First Nations player in history)

 

[demondavey]

If there is any indigenous player at the moment who can challange the Andrew McClouds, and the Goodes in this current era for the best Indigenous player every, I think it's NAS. As an U18 I thought it could be Rankine, but he wont now.

Would he need to have premiership glory like Macca and Goodes to get the crown?

I think you need to watch a lot more footy. There was a guy who wore no.23 for Hawthorn and Sydney who is probably the best indigenous and all round player ever.

There’d be 10 indigenous players that’ll be better than NAS. He isn’t even the best in it right now.

 

[demondavey]

Against who? And who was playing on him?

Yeah he’s insanely good. He’s had 3 huge games. So he’s past Nas based off them 3 games now?

Nas game vs Melbourne last season was one of the best individual games on a historical level. Kozi played Richmond tonight, missing their best player…

Great….. one game. Ok.

 

[demondavey]

This thread is pretty insulting to Franklin.

Insulting to Franklin. And insulting to;
McLeod
Wanganeen
J Farmer
P Farmer
Goodes
Burgoyne
Long
Matera

Etc

 

[Former Decathlete]

I think you need to watch a lot more footy. There was a guy who wore no.23 for Hawthorn and Sydney who is probably the best indigenous and all round player ever.

There’d be 10 indigenous players that’ll be better than NAS. He isn’t even the best in it right now.

Nas just needs 1,000 more goals...

 

[SC_Power]

Against who? And who was playing on him?

Yeah he’s insanely good. He’s had 3 huge games. So he’s past Nas based off them 3 games now?

Nas game vs Melbourne last season was one of the best individual games on a historical level. Kozi played Richmond tonight, missing their best player…

Great….. one game. Ok.

One quarter really

I’m in the minority, but Nas v Melb last year was great because of the last quarter ending, but his first 3 quarters were good but unimpactful as his team fell 8 goals behind.

He’s a very good player and I’d love to have him at Port but let’s just all keep our privates in our pants, out of respect to all those listed above.

 

[windyhill]

Nas is a good, solid player. He’d get a game at every other club. His problem is THAT Melbourne game, the second half in particular, it was wild. Problem is it’s created a rod for his back, it’s what any other of his performances is compared to. ( in what was a dead rubber)
Best ever ??!! You are having a giraffe.

 

[00Stinger]

Yeah insulting to;

Lance Franklin (2nd best CHF all time)
Winston Abraham (pound for pound the best kick of a football ever)
Byron Pickett (champion, hard, fast and skilled)
Jimmy Krak (absolute gun)
Barry Cable (probably the best smaller First Nations player in history)

Winston Abraham stop it

 

[joe444]

Too young to see Polly Farmer play, so have always been curious as to exactly why he's regarded as the best?

He's in that very rare category of player who is regarded as having changed the game for two reasons. He was the first "leaping ruckman". He also used handball as form of attack, rather than simply to get out of trouble. Sometimes you'd see both at once - leaping at a boundary throw in and handballing in one motion. Plus, he could run. Very few ruckmen ran and bounced like he did.

 

[AFLOnline]

This is what annoys me about big footy folk

It's fine to support your own player but don't do it by lying and talking down another player

I said Kosi has had 3 HUGE games THIS SEASON.

Now you lie and pretend he's only had 3 good games his whole career and has done nothing before this season.

Kosi was in fact AA in 2025.

He hasn't gone past Nas because he was already ahead.

Nas has heaps of potential but he never went past Kosi in the first place.

Saints fans did something similar with Leek Aleer.
Rather than admit the club stuffed up his recruitment..saints fans decided to tell lies about him saying he couldn't get a game for gws

What actually happened is he had a bad groin injury and didn't do a pre season at all..

Talk up your own player and club sure but don't lie and shit can other players.

You are blocked.

Was Nas not AA in 2025?

Lol @ the rest of your post, just rambling about random stuff and then block someone for having a conversation hahaha

 

[Former Decathlete]

Insulting to Franklin. And insulting to;
McLeod
Wanganeen
J Farmer
P Farmer
Goodes
Burgoyne
Long
Matera

Etc

Winmar

 

[Chip Scab1]

Winston Abraham stop it

let's just take a look at 1 year of Winston's highlights. Just 1.

I'll accept your apology later!




Could have won Mark and Goal of the year multiple times. An insanely good player, retired at 27 due to that creep James Hird.

Winmar

absolutely. Was a gun.

 

[joe444]

Syd Jackson went okay.

 

[demondavey]

One quarter really

I’m in the minority, but Nas v Melb last year was great because of the last quarter ending, but his first 3 quarters were good but unimpactful as his team fell 8 goals behind.

He’s a very good player and I’d love to have him at Port but let’s just all keep our privates in our pants, out of respect to all those listed above.

When NAS does that in a final at the GABBA, let’s open dialogue

 

[00Stinger]

let's just take a look at 1 year of Winston's highlights. Just 1.

I'll accept your apology later!




Could have won Mark and Goal of the year multiple times. An insanely good player, retired at 27 due to that creep James Hird.

absolutely. Was a gun.

Not saying he wasn't good but he wouldn't be in the top 10 indigenous players

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Won’t even turn out to be the best player in his own family

 

[Chip Scab1]

Not saying he wasn't good but he wouldn't be in the top 10 indigenous players

Not going to argue as there have been some incredible indigenous players.

He was just incredible for us for a few years and retired way too early @ 27.

Carey's reaction to his goal against Collingwood in 1998 says it all really, even the duck went nuts and knew.

Micky O another who should be near this list IMO. Absolute cracker player. Him, Nicky Winmar and Winston criminally underrated by the general public.