Fantastic thread idea. Thinking that this year is a massive chance for us to try our talls and have a geezer at life post-Rance/Riewoldt. I think Garthy and Asters play lock-down roles, Grimesy and Broad make up the Rance slack while playing defensive roles, Vlas is our jack-of-all-trades, Houli and Short rebound with Ellis and Markov waiting in wings for when the structure needs. Honestly that's not a bad structure. If we match against the league's best forward line (Collingwood/WCE IMO):
Elliot JDG Mihocek
Vlas Grimes Garth
Stephenson Cox WHE
Broad Asters Markov (purely as in this situation, we'd need another backman)
Rioli Kennedy Ryan
Grimes Asters Vlas
Allen Darling Venables
Broad Garth Houli (as WCE don't have six very dangerous forwards like the Pies, Markov goes out and we move Houli here.)
So the defence is ok. Similarly forward (again I'll use Collingwood) I think even without Jack for a month we will be fine as we're able to chuck a back-up ruck in there to give Nank a chop-out, play smalls (who need to tackle by the way) and with Caddy (apparantly back this or next week) and Lynch our targets are there:
Maynard Roughead Howe
Caddy Lynch Rioli
Langdon Moore Crisp
Butler Balta Edwards
So we're ok to be honest. Issue will be more our mids than defence, forward line should (should) be OK with Lynch, Caddy, Balta around.
Elliot JDG Mihocek
Vlas Grimes Garth
Stephenson Cox WHE
Broad Asters Markov (purely as in this situation, we'd need another backman)
Rioli Kennedy Ryan
Grimes Asters Vlas
Allen Darling Venables
Broad Garth Houli (as WCE don't have six very dangerous forwards like the Pies, Markov goes out and we move Houli here.)
So the defence is ok. Similarly forward (again I'll use Collingwood) I think even without Jack for a month we will be fine as we're able to chuck a back-up ruck in there to give Nank a chop-out, play smalls (who need to tackle by the way) and with Caddy (apparantly back this or next week) and Lynch our targets are there:
Maynard Roughead Howe
Caddy Lynch Rioli
Langdon Moore Crisp
Butler Balta Edwards
So we're ok to be honest. Issue will be more our mids than defence, forward line should (should) be OK with Lynch, Caddy, Balta around.