blue gunslinger
Hall of Famer
Would be even more of a problem if Judd Murph Gibbs or Kreuz were there seeing they did ok!
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

LIVE: Adelaide v Carlton - Rd 5 - 7:10PM Thu
Squiggle tips Crows at 82% chance -- What's your tip? -- Injury Lists » -- All Rd 5 Games
Soccer Notice Image
FA Cup Semi-Finals ⚽ 2026 FIFA Series A - Socceroos friendlies ⚽ Europa - Rd of 16 ⚽ The Matildas x 2026 Womens Asia Cup ⚽ Conference League - KNOCKOUTS! ⚽ Conference League - Rd of 16 ⚽ Socceroos Internat'l Friendlies ⚽ Champs League - League Phase ⚽
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Again I never doubted the validity of the thread but would like the full story
Thanks for the help but.
Not good enough IMOI am figuring you don't want to name the young ones - fair enuf
You all must know how hard some of our most successful players of the past used to party - Dominator, Bucks, Maclure ...
I think it has been part of Carlton's culture through good and bad.
I imagine that most clubs have your 'sociable' group and our boys seem to have made the mistake of being out in public. For all anyone knows the Hawks boys could have been getting pissed at Buddy's place that night
I don't know whether you can do it nowadays and be as good as Judd, Ablett etc but Cuz and Kerr used to manage it a couple of years ago
If, as the OP states, there were 8 players partying until the early hours of Monday morning, there would seem to be a couple of issues here. The first being the obvious one, that Fev, Hoops & Scotty have not matured as they have got older. The second issue is that there were 5 other players who were not levelheaded, mature or committed enough to opt out & go home at an acceptable time.
It is of major concern to me that we have another 5 players who have let the club down, yet the OP is protecting their identity, even though their behaviour is just as bad as the 3 who have been named. They are all responsible for their own behaviour & they are therefore equally as culpable as the other 3. They should not be protected, they should be named & shamed, either on this forum or in communication with the club.
What this alleged behaviour tells me is there is not enough discipline at the club. The club strongly voiced its displeasure with Carlos' well publicised misdemeanour in the pre-season, intra-club game, yet would seem to be sweeping some unacceptable off-field behaviour under the carpet. A little bit of naming & shaming might get the message across that this type of behaviour will not be tolerated & the players involved are not bigger than the club themself. The best thing that could have happened to Heath Shaw & Alan Didak was the public humiliation they suffered after their stupid actions.
I did hear some worrying reports about Murph during the summer but he came back in great shape and great form. Hope he has not tarnished that!Does anyone remember which thread after last week's match had a post by one of our own who bumped into a bunch of our boys out. Wondered whether it might be relevant?
It was a very interesting post - he told us that JR knew about the shit he cops and that Jammo told him he was going to have to carry his shoulder injury ....
I however would have to think that Gibbsy, Murph etc are the young crew most likely to be out with Fev
I'm not going to publicly name players for being out late and jumping in a cab to go wherever they ended up, my issue and original post was mainly with fev for not showing the maturity that he should have for allowing it to happen and in fact, as others have backed me up on, being the main culprit of having a rather large night, if people would like i will write a letter to the club naming players that were drinking until the last i saw of them which was 3-4 in the morning, the fact that as others have stated (not me as i was not a witness after that time) they were seen past the time that i saw them, i.e fev 8 in the morning, is not for me to bring up as i cannot guarantee the names of all players that were out past the last time that i witnessed, I only know that there were sightings past this time, which i do not doubt.
I mentioned hoops was drinking and his ommission from the team, considering that he wasnt playing all that bad, may have been a result of rocking up the next morning in a less than acceptable state, purely speculation on my behalf, but i found it interesting that he had a big night and was out of the team the following week.
Scotto was well behaved, he was having a drink (not illegal), he did leave with the rest of the group, once again can't guarantee he was out past that point.
My main concern is they were not planning on going home at that time from what i was hearing, as others have made reference to a few were seen past the last time i saw them. I see this as unprofessional and a slap in the face to the people who put so much time, effort and money into these guys that they compromise their preperation to follow a clown til all hours of the morning.
From what i've been hearing a few boys have been getting out on the town a bit to regularly, and somebody has got to put a leash on fev before he corrupts our young stars! End of story!