Cuthrie or Zuthrie

[allrighty]

Zac is a better player than Cam ever was. And Cam was very very good. Won a Carji of course.

But Guthrie the younger is just so consistently reliable. Hardly puts a foot wrong.

 

[bulletproof]

Cam Guthrie is an All Australian, he was one of the best midfielders in the league from 2019-2022.

 

[Gazza Greatness]

Zac is a better player than Cam ever was. And Cam was very very good. Won a Carji of course.

But Guthrie the younger is just so consistently reliable. Hardly puts a foot wrong.

Not 'ever' allrighty:.... remember Cam playing in back half in a final when he was young and he showed so much talent even back then. Also, Cam was equal best and fairest winner along side Jezza in our 2022 premiership year which unfortunately has been his last full playing year and you don't win B & F's without being ultra, ultra consistent. Preferably allrighty: I'd rather for us to acknowledge how blessed we've been to have had these two great awesome brothers being such wonderful servants of this great club and with Zac to have many more great years ahead of him.

But yeah, the two brothers in Cam and Zac have been bloody awesome for this amazing club and PS allrighty: as it was through Cam and his Cam's dad that Blics was recommended to the club from junior footy days, so all up it's been one hell of a journey and ride with a win, win, win situation the moment Cam walked through the Cat doors as a kid all those years ago!

 

[allrighty]

Not 'ever' allrighty:.... remember Cam playing in back half in a final when he was young and he showed so much talent even back then. Also, Cam was equal best and fairest winner along side Jezza in our 2022 premiership year which unfortunately has been his last full playing year and you don't win B & F's without being ultra, ultra consistent. Preferably allrighty: I'd rather for us to acknowledge how blessed we've been to have had these two great awesome brothers being such wonderful servants of this great club and with Zac to have many more great years ahead of him.

But yeah, the two brothers in Cam and Zac have been bloody awesome for this amazing club and PS allrighty: as it was through Cam and his Cam's dad that Blics was recommended to the club from junior footy days, so all up it's been one hell of a journey and ride with a win, win, win situation the moment Cam walked through the Cat doors as a kid all those years ago!

Blitz - yes what a recommendation! The ultimate swiss army knife who Scotty has used as a template for much of the rest of the team, as Bucks and Piggy said in the weekend's commentary.

Comment of the day was them talking about Dempsey being 68 kg when he was drafted and Piggy said that was his weight when he was 4 years old.

And maybe it's time for another Blitz thread.

 

[Gazza Greatness]

Blitz - yes what a recommendation! The ultimate swiss army knife who Scotty has used as a template for much of the rest of the team, as Bucks and Piggy said in the weekend's commentary.

Comment of the day was them talking about Dempsey being 68 kg when he was drafted and Piggy said that was his weight when he was 4 years old.

And maybe it's time for another Blitz thread.

Heard, seen the bold too allrighty:, pissed myself laughing and yeah I'm all for another Blitz thread as what a magnificent player he has been for our club and I don't think there's been a better team man, completely selfless and only cares for the team and his team mates. And in regards to your 'ultimate swiss army knife' comment allrighty: I don't reckon there's ever been another player like him but also there's unlikely to ever be another player like him in the future, he's completely unique, a unicorn as some have described.

PS - We owe Cam and Zac Guthrie's dad so, so much.... one, for bringing Cam and Zac into the world but then to also have the foresight to recommend Bliz to the club, what a winner!

 

[Kardinia Boy]

I found myself thinking the same thing whilst watching the game on the weekend. I couldn't decide who was better in the end so I'm calling it a draw.

 

[allrighty]

I found myself thinking the same thing whilst watching the game on the weekend. I couldn't decide who was better in the end so I'm calling it a draw.

Probably a fair assessment and perhaps I am suffering recency bias. But gee Zac has come such a long way from that skinny kid at the start.

 

[iameviljez]

Zac is a better player than Cam ever was. And Cam was very very good. Won a Carji of course.

But Guthrie the younger is just so consistently reliable. Hardly puts a foot wrong.

He’s good, but he’s not as good as Cam at his best.

Yet.

Cam could probably do what Zac does. I don’t think the inverse is true.

 

[dazbroncos]

Probably a fair assessment and perhaps I am suffering recency bias. But gee Zac has come such a long way from that skinny kid at the start.

there was a Cats Hawks game where Roughy outmarked Zuth and goaled many years ago and this place went full Ken Bruce - the vitriol was acidic and plentiful about the mere existence of Zac.

Prob wasnt even Zac's man but he ended up on him and did his best which in this case wasn't good enoough.

However, Zuth has the last laugh.

Im guessing a few should head to the IWW thread......

GO Catters

 

[allrighty]

He’s good, but he’s not as good as Cam at his best.

Yet.

Cam could probably do what Zac does. I don’t think the inverse is true.

I was wondering about that. How he would go in the guts, not that I want to see him there.

 

[iameviljez]

there was a Cats Hawks game where Roughy outmarked Zuth and goaled many years ago and this place went full Ken Bruce - the vitriol was acidic and plentiful about the mere existence of Zac.

Prob wasnt even Zac's man but he ended up on him and did his best which in this case wasn't good enoough.

However, Zuth has the last laugh.

Im guessing a few should head to the IWW thread......

GO Catters

I was right behind him at the time. We were coming like a steam train and lost by Roughead’s point

 

[cats_09]

there was a Cats Hawks game where Roughy outmarked Zuth and goaled many years ago and this place went full Ken Bruce - the vitriol was acidic and plentiful about the mere existence of Zac.

Prob wasnt even Zac's man but he ended up on him and did his best which in this case wasn't good enoough.

However, Zuth has the last laugh.

Im guessing a few should head to the IWW thread......

GO Catters

I can still remember the still photo from that mark, and Stewart is trying to run his guts out to get back to the contest but was never going to make it

Roughead definitely wasn't Zach's man but he was trying to do the right thing and at least put a body on an open opponent

 

[standupand]

I can still remember the still photo from that mark, and Stewart is trying to run his guts out to get back to the contest but was never going to make it

Roughead definitely wasn't Zach's man but he was trying to do the right thing and at least put a body on an open opponent

I just rewatched the last 2 minutes of that game and Cam was actually the more culpable of the two brothers in the dying minutes, first for a htb that gave them possession and then for a terrible kick that turned the ball over. There was also a non-call on a clearly deliberate oob that was mind-boggling.

 

[allrighty]

I just rewatched the last 2 minutes of that game and Cam was actually the more culpable of the two brothers in the dying minutes, first for a htb that gave them possession and then for a terrible kick that turned the ball over. There was also a non-call on a clearly deliberate oob that was mind-boggling.

What was the game?

 

[standupand]

What was the game?

Easter Monday 2018. I assume that's the one. Roughy marks and scores the point to win the game. Same pocket as the Bartel one.

https://www.afl.com.au/video/184118/watch-the-last-two-minutes-geel-v-haw?videoId=184118&modal=true&type=video&publishFrom=1522657116001

 

[iameviljez]

I just rewatched the last 2 minutes of that game and Cam was actually the more culpable of the two brothers in the dying minutes, first for a htb that gave them possession and then for a terrible kick that turned the ball over. There was also a non-call on a clearly deliberate oob that was mind-boggling.

You're not wrong, that was a bad minute. Ironically the other bloke who turned it over was one J Selwood. Of all the players...

 

[iameviljez]

Easter Monday 2018. I assume that's the one. Roughy marks and scores the point to win the game. Same pocket as the Bartel one.

That game was the end of an attacking game plan for the GFC for the next few years, IIRC. We started to play the most boring football on earth till 2022.

 

[Mr Meow]

That game was the end of an attacking game plan for the GFC for the next few years, IIRC. We started to play the most boring football on earth till 2022.

We were quite dour 2014-2018 too I thought. Maybe moreso than 2019 onwards. The Covid years almost everyone played terribly boring football. Slowest/safest ball movement years Champion Data had on record. Ironically the two premiers - Richmond and Melbourne - were the teams that bucked the trend.

Most teams sped up and took more risks 2022 onwards, including Geelong.

 

[iameviljez]

We were quite dour 2014-2018 too I thought. Maybe moreso than 2019 onwards

We absolutely were, but I thought that 2019 was the absolute nadir of it. Sorry - I meant to write "any" attacking game plan.

We had this real bits-and-pieces backline, and I think we went too far in protecting it.

 

[Mr Meow]

We absolutely were, but I thought that 2019 was the absolute nadir of it. Sorry - I meant to write "any" attacking game plan.

We had this real bits-and-pieces backline, and I think we went too far in protecting it.

Interesting. I have a bit of a different view. We brought Rohan in, who livened the forward line up significantly. Ablett moved forward as an attacking creator. Miers came in. Kelly really exploded as an aggressive midfielder. Duncan had his most attacking year. Stewart was probably at his peak as a proactive rebounder.

I didn't see 2019 as overly defensive. We were the 2nd highest scoring team in the comp. I agree that our defence was a bit susceptible and our midfield/wings didn't really have much defensive grunt at all. Our pressuring ability was poor and Richmond's chaos style, with a few unstoppable weapons (Lynch was the difference in the prelim), was simply too much for us in finals.

 

[Vdubs]

Zac is a better player than Cam ever was. And Cam was very very good. Won a Carji of course.

But Guthrie the younger is just so consistently reliable. Hardly puts a foot wrong.

2 Carjis

 

[Wojcinski]

never really good at the same time, did Zac steal Cam's football powers?

 

[Mr Meow]

never really good at the same time, did Zac steal Cam's football powers?

2022.

The rare moments it coincides, we win a premiership.

 

[Lana]

Cuthrie could do what Zuthrie does if Zuthrie could do what Cuthrie did, they wouldn't be entertaining throwing Mullin through the middle.

 

[Mr Meow]

Cuthrie could do what Zuthrie does if Zuthrie could do what Cuthrie did, they wouldn't be entertaining throwing Mullin through the middle.

I disagree with that, given Zuthrie is taking over from Stewart. Cam was never even close to being a Stewart type player when he was in the backline. He could lockdown on players or be more of a Touhy/Duncan style neat rebounder. But he wasn't an aerial/contested interceptor.