Cuved's top 30 phantom draft

[cuved9]

Here's my crack at this years draft. Much harder then last years!

1 Essendon - Hugh McCluggage
2 Greater Western Sydney - Andrew McGrath
3 Gold Coast Jack Bowes (Bid by Brisbane)
4 Brisbane Lions - Ben Ainsworth
5 Greater Western Sydney - Will Setterfield (Bid by Carlton)
6 Carlton - Sam Petrovski-Seton
7 Gold Coast - Tim Taranto
8 Fremantle - Griffin Logue
9 Gold Coast - Will Brodie
10 Sydney Swans - Jy Simpkin
11 Gold Coast - Oliver Florent
12 Greater Western Sydney - Harry Perryman (Bid by North Melbourne)
13 North Melbourne - Jack Scrimshaw
14 West Coast - Tim English
15 Adelaide - Jarrod Berry
16 Port Adelaide - Josh Battle
17 Brisbane Lions - Jordan Gallucci
18 Port Adelaide - Will Hayward
19 Western Bulldogs - Todd Marshall
20 Sydney Swans - Alex Witherden
21 Essendon - Sam Powell-Pepper
22 Brisbane Lions - Daniel Venables
23 Brisbane Lions - Brennan Cox
24 St Kilda - Shai Bolton
25 Greater Western Sydney - Issac Cumming (Bid by Geelong)
26 Geelong - Tom Stewart
27 Carlton - Patrick Kerr
28 Western Bulldogs - Cedric Cox
29 Richmond - Jordan Ridley
30 Collingwood - Sam Walker

 

[year of the cat]

No chance we take Stewart with our first! Wells would be hung, drawn and quartered if he tried.

 

[cuved9]

No chance we take Stewart with our first! Wells would be hung, drawn and quartered if he tried.

has met with 12 clubs and cats very keen! watch this space!

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

We won't take Stewart with our first.

 

[year of the cat]

has met with 12 clubs and cats very keen! watch this space!

Doesn't mean he'll be taken at 24. They do talk to players they intend to draft with other picks

 

[cuved9]

Doesn't mean he'll be taken at 24. They do talk to players they intend to draft with other picks

No it doesn't but Geelong have shown in the past they pay whatever to get the player they want which maybe higher than where keyboard experts rank them!

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

No it doesn't but Geelong have shown in the past they pay whatever to get the player they want which maybe higher than where keyboard experts rank them!

It won't be at our first pick.

 

[cuved9]

It won't be at our first pick.

my sources says he won't be there by their second pick so if they want him as i understand they do it is with the first pick.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

my sources says he won't be there by their second pick so if they want him as i understand they do it is with the first pick.

Was that the same source that was on the money below?

Will have a crack at a second round tonight. Heard from reliable sources accommodation already sorted for Maynard that's how much Crows rate him.

 

[year of the cat]

my sources says he won't be there by their second pick so if they want him as i understand they do it is with the first pick.

I'd put my house on it not happening. And that's even knowing that Wells can pull a seemingly strange call on draft day.

 

[adammania9]

No it doesn't but Geelong have shown in the past they pay whatever to get the player they want which maybe higher than where keyboard experts rank them!

What would you consider yourself?

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

nope. But seems like you've got plenty of time have a crack at one yourself!

Sorry but I'm too busy picking apart your phantom draft.

 

[cuved9]

What would you consider yourself?

keyboard expert

 

[Seadog]

Tim English? Not happening, I don't know why most of the phantoms think it will.

 

[cuved9]

Tim English? Not happening, I don't know why most of the phantoms think it will.

tossed up with this one. i think North could take him the pick prior but considering the fragility of the ruck stocks at WC i see him as a nice fit for depth.

 

[Bic]

Great job, hope you are correct in that Carlton will have the choice out of Taranto or SPS.

I have Taranto 51/49 SPS. So can't really see us losing either way, both types of players fill a critical need for us.

 

[winalotroos]

tossed up with this one. i think North could take him the pick prior but considering the fragility of the ruck stocks at WC i see him as a nice fit for depth.

Guess again North won't take English with their first, I bet my balls it will be a Mid.

 

[loki04]

Tim English? Not happening, I don't know why most of the phantoms think it will.

A lot of clubs really rate him, Pies tried to get him to nominate in last years draft cheap but he knocked us back.

 

[loki04]

Great job, hope you are correct in that Carlton will have the choice out of Taranto or SPS.

I have Taranto 51/49 SPS. So can't really see us losing either way, both types of players fill a critical need for us.

SPS imho is the best player in this draft, will be whether his work rate and attitude match his skill/athleticism.

 

[Scullywag]

Here's my crack at this years draft. Much harder then last years!

1 Essendon - Hugh McCluggage
2 Greater Western Sydney - Andrew McGrath
3 Gold Coast Jack Bowes (Bid by Brisbane)
4 Brisbane Lions - Ben Ainsworth
5 Greater Western Sydney - Will Setterfield (Bid by Carlton)
6 Carlton - Sam Petrovski-Seton
7 Gold Coast - Tim Taranto
8 Fremantle - Griffin Logue
9 Gold Coast - Will Brodie
10 Sydney Swans - Jy Simpkin
11 Gold Coast - Oliver Florent
12 Greater Western Sydney - Harry Perryman (Bid by North Melbourne)
13 North Melbourne - Jack Scrimshaw
14 West Coast - Tim English
15 Adelaide - Jarrod Berry
16 Port Adelaide - Josh Battle
17 Brisbane Lions - Jordan Gallucci
18 Port Adelaide - Will Hayward
19 Western Bulldogs - Todd Marshall
20 Sydney Swans - Alex Witherden
21 Essendon - Sam Powell-Pepper
22 Brisbane Lions - Daniel Venables
23 Brisbane Lions - Brennan Cox
24 St Kilda - Shai Bolton
25 Greater Western Sydney - Issac Cumming (Bid by Geelong)
26 Geelong - Tom Stewart
27 Carlton - Patrick Kerr
28 Western Bulldogs - Cedric Cox
29 Richmond - Jordan Ridley
30 Collingwood - Sam Walker

Good job mate, must say I don't see Scrimshaw getting past Sydney but apart from that I can't fault you.

 

[cuved9]

I'd put my house on it not happening. And that's even knowing that Wells can pull a seemingly strange call on draft day.

 

[year of the cat]

Can't read your link but assume it's Twomey's mock? Must have read your thread I reckon?! Still won't happen.

 

[Greendogg]

Good job mate, must say I don't see Scrimshaw getting past Sydney but apart from that I can't fault you.

I'd take this for Suns, but we would definitely take The Scrim ahead of Florent at 11... been linked to him for a while..
Other than that, great effort!

 

[Bicks]

Guess again North won't take English with their first, I bet my balls it will be a Mid.

How will you handle the squeaky voice if you're wrong?

 

[cuved9]

Can't read your link but assume it's Twomey's mock? Must have read your thread I reckon?! Still won't happen.

Cal tweeted Stewart could go as early as second round to cats or pies