Opinion D Swallow / Coniglio / Whitfield / O'Meara. Rank who will be best by career end.
- Thread starter The Bomb
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Jmac2225
Club Legend
- Jun 6, 2012
- 2,371
- 1,246
- AFL Club
- Geelong
How is anyone really meant to meant to have a clue? Answers basically just go off who the most highly rated of them are.
It's like saying who's going to be best out of Gibbs and Pendlebury after their first year. Everyone that's not Collingwood would say Gibbs.
It's like saying who's going to be best out of Gibbs and Pendlebury after their first year. Everyone that's not Collingwood would say Gibbs.
zorro1836
Cancelled
- May 24, 2012
- 199
- 26
- AFL Club
- GWS
this/ o'meara for sure.
Eastern Rangers
2015 Worsfold Medalist - Rowen Powell
O'Meara for his all round attributes shapes as the best prospect for me as well.
Then it gets a little harder, Swallow super midfielder but lacks the others extreme polish IMO.
Whitfield is more outside than the other three. Marks him down.
Congilio while he quick he isn't a feak athelete, he's just super smart and highly skilled.
Then it gets a little harder, Swallow super midfielder but lacks the others extreme polish IMO.
Whitfield is more outside than the other three. Marks him down.
Congilio while he quick he isn't a feak athelete, he's just super smart and highly skilled.
Omeara, Swallow, Coniglio, Whitfield. That's the order i would take them in.
- Banned
- #7
Bennell has actually shown a lot at AFL level.
O'Meara stresses me out on potential, so damn fast.
O'Meara stresses me out on potential, so damn fast.
He excites me
From what I've seen of Jaeger, that is spot on. Other players are considered very quick if they can get 5 metres clear of congestion before other players can react. Blink and O'Meara's more like 10 - 15 metres clear. Lightning off the mark. Bennell could also end up the best of the lot. Time will tell.
- Banned
- #9
Hopefully after a bit of time in the AFL system I think a few people are in for a shock with the speed in which he reacts and his athletic ability.He excites me
Both ahead at the moment which would be expected, who knows by the end of the season. Jaeger would be in the All Australian squad discussion at this early stage of the season. Maintains this form for the entire year and he will be right in the discussion with the other two.
I mean sure, two players crippled by the GC injury factory and two GWS players. GC managed to run Swallow, Bennell and O'Meara into the ground. Never see one club destroy so many first round picks.
Currently Cogs and whitfield 1 and 2, but helped by the fact they play in a great team with stars all over the park. Dare I say if O'Meara had been playing for GWS last 2 seasons, would be going veryyyy well indeed. Swallow is nothing compared to these blokes, major stuff up by the suns
Swallow isn't as good as these 3, but no way is he 'a major stuff up'. Bloke bleeds for our club, avg's 22 touches this season and the players at the club love him. Has also started kicking goals this year as well. Will never be a A+ mid, but is a combative competitive mid who can go forward and kick a goal. More than happy to have him at the club.
when i say major stuff up I just mean out of these 4 players swallow is clearly the worst. Good player, but whitfield is second to sicily as most influential defender in the league, and coniglio/omeara just better midfielders
Fair summation.
what happened with scrimshaw. Blokes gonna be a jet for us and barely copped a gig for you
Wasn't invested, was made evident to the club towards the beginning of last season he wanted to leave. Can only assume Dew didn't want him running around in the 1's for us.
fair call well your culture seems on track ill say that much
SSSSSS
Brownlow Medallist
- Apr 18, 2011
- 19,595
- 42,291
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Six decades of domination
JOM has all the talent to be the #1. Wouldn't even be a question if he didn't have those injuries. A player with his enormous talent and incredible resolve should be a brownlow medalist right now.
Hopefully his body holds up. Has had a huge year and still <100 games.
Right now it's no question
Coniglio > Whitfield > JOM > Swallow
Hopefully his body holds up. Has had a huge year and still <100 games.
Right now it's no question
Coniglio > Whitfield > JOM > Swallow
Agree with:
Coniglio > Whitfield > JOM > Swallow
JOM on an upward trajectory, and in the absence of Mitchell, may switch with Whitfield at some point.
Will be nice bump for us next year if that happens. Having 1 and 2 ;-)
Coniglio > Whitfield > JOM > Swallow
JOM on an upward trajectory, and in the absence of Mitchell, may switch with Whitfield at some point.
Will be nice bump for us next year if that happens. Having 1 and 2 ;-)
drviccles
Team Captain
Agree with this
