Dale Thomas vs Kyle Reimers

[Red Black and Blue]

Nooo of course he isn't. He's far physically stronger than Reimers

What?

 

[smiddaz123]

What?

I was mocking all the Essendon fans in this thread who disagreed with me when I said Reimers is physically stronger than Thomas.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

I was mocking all the Essendon fans in this thread who disagreed with me when I said Reimers is physically stronger than Thomas.

Ok, though I don't understand how Reimers being stronger means he has less scope for improvement.

 

[smiddaz123]

Ok, though I don't understand how Reimers being stronger means he has less scope for improvement.

It isn't the only defining factor obviously....

 

[Red Black and Blue]

It isn't the only defining factor obviously....

Don't see how it can be even considered a factor in Daisy's favor?

 

[DoubleO7]

You sir, are a fool.

 

[efcboy]

dale thomas - the next shane kerrison although kerrison probably experienced something in october that thomas never will.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

You sir, are a fool.

Why? because you can't comprehend that individuals have different physical scopes for improvement?

 

[smiddaz123]

Don't see how it can be even considered a factor in Daisy's favor?

Being less physically developed and weaker?

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Being less physically developed and weaker?

Using the the alphabet as an example:

Say Daisy is at 'B' in physical growth and his maximum potential is 'F'

Say Reimers is at 'C' in physical growth and his maximum potential is 'H'

Just because Reimers is stronger now doesn't mean he won't develop further than Daisy.

Reimers has a much solider frame, IMO means more likely to bulk up even further than Daisy. Daisy will mostly keep a leaner frame to maintain his speed.

 

[smiddaz123]

Using the the alphabet as an example:

Say Daisy is at 'B' in physical growth and his maximum potential is 'F'

Say Reimers is at 'C' in physical growth and his maximum potential is 'H'

Just because Reimers is stronger now doesn't mean he won't develop further than Daisy.

Reimers has a much solider frame, IMO means more likely to bulk up even further than Daisy. Daisy will mostly keep a leaner frame to maintain his speed.

And it's very possible. But as I said before, that's just one factor.

 

[Lance Uppercut]

And looking at the photo Dale Thomas is a good looking young man. Veyr marketable. On the other hand Riemers is ugly and has terrible acne. Even though he has good skills and wears orange boots that are so bright they make your eyes squint he is not nearly as marketable or as good a footballer as Dale Thomas.

Daisy for me.

LOL didn't think looks would be a factor in assessing their worth!

 

[tin can sam]

Keimers is a nob, I'll take Thomas.

 

[vossdaboss]

Dale Thomas by the length of the Randwick Racetrack! (even though he plays for the scum)

Kyle Reimers has one year wonder written all over him. Will be delisted within the next 2 years!

 

[Kong]

Dale Thomas by the length of the Randwick Racetrack! (even though he plays for the scum)

Kyle Reimers has one year wonder written all over him. Will be delisted within the next 2 years!

alright, i'll take your word for it, and in two years if i'm still on bigfooty we'll bring this back up.

 

[Ando_4]

Thomas is the most overrated footballer in the AFL. Kyle gets my vote.

 

[Tomorrows_Nobody]

Dale Thomas by the length of the Randwick Racetrack! (even though he plays for the scum)

Kyle Reimers has one year wonder written all over him. Will be delisted within the next 2 years!

While you're at it, can you tell me who wins next year's Melbourne Cup?