
Dan 24, Ive just been going thru some old posts prior to my joining Big Footy.
You really do suprise me, as most of your argument is strong, but a common thread you base all your argument on is population ,therefore greater population brings better performance. Servo dished up lots of logical well thought out arguments. All were refuted by you based on ..Well lack of information outside of your melbourne views..
Please this is not a personal affront, just a view based on reading your posts from the start of the year.
Keep up your posts, you are more often enlightening than not, though sometimes arguing with less than the required ammunition. I have said, though not in as many kind words previously ( keep your babble to those who dont understand )
I apologise !!!!!
What I mean is there are many who know quite abit out there as well, some with experience that encompasses all three main football states experience and well read fact as well!
Graced with all the information, without your hideous Bias, I believe you could even become a writer or journalist, such is your deft use of words.
Extend yourself young man, research, then look at the other side of the coin, dont just listen to the pack your in, go outside and visit others and LISTEN....
My young friend, I have records of VFL versus SANFL games that go back to the 1870's, 100's of them and in as many cases, as you thought VFL teams took their encounters as a lighthearted run, the same was considered by Adelaide based clubs.
The original thread here...Population equals sporting domination according to Dan24.... Australian cricket team, always dominant 18,000,000 people
India population nearly 1 Billion should be 1000's of time more skilful, dominant, uncomparable, highest wicket takers, fastest bowlers greatest batsmen. or even Pakistan should never lose to Australia, they should be Demi gods of cricket, omnipotent. super humans according to your rationale.
China- over 1 billion people, should dominate all sports they play
basket ball, soccer, etc they have more people playing these sports on any given weekend than virtually the rest of the worlds saturday basketball populations combined - they have professional clubs with tall atheletic players out of the 1 billion population one would expect China to dominate all Soccer world cups or even India, all play offs according to your population X theory would put these countries in a unassailable position of total control.
England, Italy, etc have much larger populations than Australia yet
constantly lose in Rugby against us.
As you define it...Is it because all these countries go in half heartedly against the smaller populations. your posts have said " I just cant believe that a VFL premiership team could lose to a SANFL premiership team " unquote. You have asked Servo in the past to prove it.....and when he gave you some instances you immideately said " They couldnt have been full strength Vic sides" or they played half heartedly.
I have seen many of those games here Dan, believe me when the Vic premiersFull strength sides were being knocked off by talented skilful faster harder SA outfits they began to lose their cool and ...Biffo ... You see Dan they also believed their own publicity........
Servo, I tip my lid to some of your old posts, I tip my lid to your loyalty to Centrals.
It is a shame that they couldnt win their premiership in the Old SANFL...but a premiership they have...I do think I know a number of your mates at Centrals.
Keep up the stoushes gentlemen.
PA1870
You really do suprise me, as most of your argument is strong, but a common thread you base all your argument on is population ,therefore greater population brings better performance. Servo dished up lots of logical well thought out arguments. All were refuted by you based on ..Well lack of information outside of your melbourne views..
Please this is not a personal affront, just a view based on reading your posts from the start of the year.
Keep up your posts, you are more often enlightening than not, though sometimes arguing with less than the required ammunition. I have said, though not in as many kind words previously ( keep your babble to those who dont understand )
I apologise !!!!!
What I mean is there are many who know quite abit out there as well, some with experience that encompasses all three main football states experience and well read fact as well!
Graced with all the information, without your hideous Bias, I believe you could even become a writer or journalist, such is your deft use of words.
Extend yourself young man, research, then look at the other side of the coin, dont just listen to the pack your in, go outside and visit others and LISTEN....
My young friend, I have records of VFL versus SANFL games that go back to the 1870's, 100's of them and in as many cases, as you thought VFL teams took their encounters as a lighthearted run, the same was considered by Adelaide based clubs.
The original thread here...Population equals sporting domination according to Dan24.... Australian cricket team, always dominant 18,000,000 people
India population nearly 1 Billion should be 1000's of time more skilful, dominant, uncomparable, highest wicket takers, fastest bowlers greatest batsmen. or even Pakistan should never lose to Australia, they should be Demi gods of cricket, omnipotent. super humans according to your rationale.
China- over 1 billion people, should dominate all sports they play
basket ball, soccer, etc they have more people playing these sports on any given weekend than virtually the rest of the worlds saturday basketball populations combined - they have professional clubs with tall atheletic players out of the 1 billion population one would expect China to dominate all Soccer world cups or even India, all play offs according to your population X theory would put these countries in a unassailable position of total control.
England, Italy, etc have much larger populations than Australia yet
constantly lose in Rugby against us.
As you define it...Is it because all these countries go in half heartedly against the smaller populations. your posts have said " I just cant believe that a VFL premiership team could lose to a SANFL premiership team " unquote. You have asked Servo in the past to prove it.....and when he gave you some instances you immideately said " They couldnt have been full strength Vic sides" or they played half heartedly.
I have seen many of those games here Dan, believe me when the Vic premiersFull strength sides were being knocked off by talented skilful faster harder SA outfits they began to lose their cool and ...Biffo ... You see Dan they also believed their own publicity........
Servo, I tip my lid to some of your old posts, I tip my lid to your loyalty to Centrals.
It is a shame that they couldnt win their premiership in the Old SANFL...but a premiership they have...I do think I know a number of your mates at Centrals.
Keep up the stoushes gentlemen.
PA1870