Scratchy05
All Australian
- Sep 16, 2020
- 866
- 670
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I'd take him at the pies. desperate for a small forward and would be one of the better options out there, plus fits our age profile.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Disagree. We're probably the hardest team in the league to play as a small forward. Have you seen how hard our small forwards have to work with their chasing and pressure game so that blokes like Dusty can play their natural game.Richmond is the best team in the comp to play as a small forward. If he is struggling there he isn't coming good anywhere else.
He has great skills though. Would he be worth a go at half back?
If you have watched what the small forwards have to do at Richmond ( all of unrewarded running up and down the ground and covering space , Tackling like crazy and chasing players you most likely wont catch before they get rid of the ball ) Its not an easy game to play and very little reward or recognitionRichmond is the best team in the comp to play as a small forward. If he is struggling there he isn't coming good anywhere else.
He has great skills though. Would he be worth a go at half back?
Rioli defensive stats are worse than the small forwards from those clubs you mentionedIf you have watched what the small forwards have to do at Richmond ( all of unrewarded running up and down the ground and covering space , Tackling like crazy and chasing players you most likely wont catch before they get rid of the ball ) Its not an easy game to play and very little reward or recognition
Playing small forward for a team like West Coast / Geelong / Melbourne / Bulldogs etc would be so much easier as you would be that little goal sneak that just roves the packs and hunts opportunity with not so much defending.
I know which role i would rather play
Rioli defensive stats are worse than the small forwards from those clubs you mentioned
kozzie picket 21 pressure acts, 4 tackles, 1.8 tackles inside 50
Jamie cripps 22 pressure acts, 4 tackles, 1.5 tackle inside 50
Brad close 16 pressure acts, 3 tackles, 1.8 tackles inside 50
Rioli 14 pressure acts, 3 tackles, 0.9 tackles inside 50
Rioli actually puts on the least defensive pressure
Stats do not back up what you say at all
didn’t include the dogs as not sure who been playing ‘small forward’ for them this year McNeil and Scott?? But they’re first year players
Yeah, I agree.Stats don't tell you everything.
Best judge of a player's contribution to a team would be the coaches, particular the successful ones, and the guy who has coaches 3 of the last 4 flags continually rates him very highly and he does OK in the club B&F (usually ending up ~10-15th).
He's not a 'star', but he's clearly considered an important contributor, on and off field.
Yeah, I agree.
I'm sure West Coast, Melbourne, Geelong would say the same about their small forwards too.
The comment from THE_GUN was it is much easier to play small forward in other forward lines, you don't have to defend at all, you just crumb packs and kick goals. Stats are completely contra to the concept
Honestly surprised Charlie is so low.talk about his great pressure but official 2021 stats show 'pressure acts' are average for small forwards
Cripps 22.5
Butler 21.6
Rankine 16
Close 16
Schulz 15.1
Rioli 14.3
Bobby Hill 13.9
Rowe 13.6
Betts 12.9
Papley 12.8
Charlie Cameron 8.5
Has played over 100 games and still only 24, the triple premiership player
If you have watched what the small forwards have to do at Richmond ( all of unrewarded running up and down the ground and covering space , Tackling like crazy and chasing players you most likely wont catch before they get rid of the ball ) Its not an easy game to play and very little reward or recognition
Playing small forward for a team like West Coast / Geelong / Melbourne / Bulldogs etc would be so much easier as you would be that little goal sneak that just roves the packs and hunts opportunity with not so much defending.
I know which role i would rather play
What a sentence
Dont really know about his midfield ability as we have never seen him played in therecan he play midfield ? Or his he stuck as a small forward?
I agree Rich expectations would be differnt... although I think the ability cover ground is very important to the MC at geelong. I look at Miers for example, a key reason for him getting games is his ability to run. Talented...what would Rich expect for him. OOC.. probably forces hand a bit. Maybe used as part of the deal to get Cerra?
Rioli defensive stats are worse than the small forwards from those clubs you mentioned
kozzie picket 21 pressure acts, 4 tackles, 1.8 tackles inside 50
Jamie cripps 22 pressure acts, 4 tackles, 1.5 tackle inside 50
Brad close 16 pressure acts, 3 tackles, 1.8 tackles inside 50
Rioli 14 pressure acts, 3 tackles, 0.9 tackles inside 50
Rioli actually puts on the least defensive pressure
Stats do not back up what you say at all
didn’t include the dogs as not sure who been playing ‘small forward’ for them this year McNeil and Scott?? But they’re first year players
If you have watched what the small forwards have to do at Richmond ( all of unrewarded running up and down the ground and covering space , Tackling like crazy and chasing players you most likely wont catch before they get rid of the ball ) Its not an easy game to play and very little reward or recognition
Playing small forward for a team like West Coast / Geelong / Melbourne / Bulldogs etc would be so much easier as you would be that little goal sneak that just roves the packs and hunts opportunity with not so much defending.
I know which role i would rather play
I agree that Richmond require their small forwards to run more than most and this doesn't suit Rioli.Disagree. We're probably the hardest team in the league to play as a small forward. Have you seen how hard our small forwards have to work with their chasing and pressure game so that blokes like Dusty can play their natural game.
Obviously what a 'pressure act' is is hard to define, particularly in real time.Do you really think the stats accurately show things like 'pressure acts'?
The Richmond game is noted for it's pressure, especially forward pressure.
Yet Richmond forwards seem relatively low in such stats against other teams.
The obviously explanation for this is that the stats miss a lot of things that count in reality.
Yeah, they can be a good fit for your game style, completely agree.As others have mentioned stats dont tell every story
I have watched Daniel Rioli make 5-6-7 440-50 mtr runs to close off space so the opposition 'DONT' use that player on that side of the ground or run to create an alternative to drag the defender to him so his team mate has space to run through etc.
But Rioli is a very different player to your average small foward and its really the way we play
Who would put Rioli , Castagna , Aarts in the best 5 small fowards in the game ? Dont think anybody would but they are the most effective for what we need
and its been successful
That's the thing, it DOES suit Rioli as he came to the club with both elite speed and endurance. Part of the whole design of our gameplan was to utilise this running capacity of Rioli and others to close off the ground to the opposition with massive running efforts. Kamdyn McIntosh is exactly the same.I agree that Richmond require their small forwards to run more than most and this doesn't suit Rioli.
Well he's 24 now, and producing the same numbers he did at 18, when he was being picked on potential and the odd beautiful cameo. Currently outside the.best 22 and his club have just picked up Matt Parker in the MSD.That's the thing, it DOES suit Rioli as he came to the club with both elite speed and endurance. Part of the whole design of our gameplan was to utilise this running capacity of Rioli and others to close off the ground to the opposition with massive running efforts. Kamdyn McIntosh is exactly the same.
The players rarely get massive disposal numbers or stats playing this role, but it's a key part of the game plan.
Pressure coming from both Parker and MRJ. This can only be a good thing.Well he's 24 now, and producing the same numbers he did at 18, when he was being picked on potential and the odd beautiful cameo. Currently outside the.best 22 and his club have just picked up Matt Parker in the MSD.
Time to pull the finger out.
Already a premiership player so could move on for money or other reasons.
Back home to Eagles or Freo.
Hawks to play in the team Ciril became a hero in.
Carlton to learn under Betts.
North for money.