Daniher / O'Meara / Viney / Crouch Where too in this draft?

(Log in to remove this ad.)

TheSunGod

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Posts
9,634
Likes
11,227
Location
Bangsaphan Noi
AFL Club
Gold Coast
Other Teams
Team Buakaw Golovkin
#28
But it wasn't when Cotch was drafted/first year in the system so there is definitely a chance O'Meara could catch him up. O'Meara reminds me of a mix between a player like Cotchin and a player like Shuey.

A bit of Cotch's aerial ability, deft touch and balance, more than a bit of Shuey's explosiveness and ability to work quickly into space and go for long raking runs.

O'Meara is the kind of player that if he starts to deliver on potential, I would watch GC just to see him play.
For sure, that's why I said "at this stage". I'm very hopeful this will happen. Classy like Cotchin with Shuey's explosivenesss and grunt. Sounds like a little bald fella I know of.
 

Upgrayedd

A Vote for Clive is a Vote for Justice
Joined
Aug 11, 2006
Posts
29,579
Likes
20,729
Location
Perth
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
Timberwolves, Crystal Palace
#29
I may be biased but having watched the majority of the resevres games this year I am super excited about Jaeger. Speed to burn, hard at the ball and the man, he was clearly a step ahead of everyone else on the field.
It makes you completely sane, Giving up pick 4 for O'Meara was an absolute steal and unless another team had a higher pick (They did not) Giants were not intrested, infact they tried hard to manufacture a deal which about 4 teams got overs so they would snag him for themselves.

He doesn't really have much weakness right now, Build his tank and core Strength and i would put money down to be a Multiple AA winner and possible brownlow winner barring anything untowards happening to him and his development

Again, He'll draw people to the suns just to watch him play

thats how the 07 draft shouldve gone;)
Seriously, F**k off. Im sure given the time Cotchin had the chance he would go to the blues so he could play finals in his career.

See look at that, everyone can be a worthless troll, its nothing special, this is the draft board, Screw off
 

cotcha now

Team Captain
Joined
Jan 27, 2008
Posts
530
Likes
35
Location
victoria
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
mancher utd, Raptors nba
#31
Seriously, F**k off. Im sure given the time Cotchin had the chance he would go to the blues so he could play finals in his career.

See look at that, everyone can be a worthless troll, its nothing special, this is the draft board, Screw off
umm whats that got to do with cotchin wanting to go there? i stated that cotchin SHOULDVE gone first. idiot. if i was carlton with selection one in that draft i wouldve picked cotchin. if they had of picked him ofcourse theyd be playing finals with murph judd and cotch...obviously they didnt make finals this year and no doubt having cotchin wouldve made more of an impact than say kruezer to there finals chances. ofcourse players would have there club of choice theyd like to go to before the draft but as you should know the CLUBS draft them.
 

Upgrayedd

A Vote for Clive is a Vote for Justice
Joined
Aug 11, 2006
Posts
29,579
Likes
20,729
Location
Perth
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
Timberwolves, Crystal Palace
#32
umm whats that got to do with cotchin wanting to go there? i stated that cotchin SHOULDVE gone first. idiot. if i was carlton with selection one in that draft i wouldve picked cotchin. if they had of picked him ofcourse theyd be playing finals with murph judd and cotch...obviously they didnt make finals this year and no doubt having cotchin wouldve made more of an impact than say kruezer to there finals chances. ofcourse players would have there club of choice theyd like to go to before the draft but as you should know the CLUBS draft them.
On what basis? That he was the best young talent? He wasn't, The universal opinion was that Kruezer was, Infact he was voted the best player in the Northern Knights, same team Cotchin was a part of. The rankings of best players in the land who were under 18 were 1.Naitanui/2.Kreuzer/3.Cotchin, Every club judged this, Experts predicted this, You rank it in hindsight, Which is completely Irrational and A fair bit ******ed, And no in Carltons position you would of picked Kruezer, Your using hindsight and biast towards "your player" that he should of gone first, Nowdays yeah, Cotchin is the second best player from the draft right now, Good work,

The basis that Carlton needed a Ruckman far ahead of Midfielders since they selected Gibbs/Murphy the drafts before and the universal opinion that Kreuzer? Well no, Two things that Carlton were crying out for in 07 season was for a Ruckman or a Forward, Kruezer showed he excelled at both. In that time Kruezer has not bulked up, Done a knee so in that reguard Kruezer has struggled

In anycase You are either A piss poor troll or an idiot, Probably both. THis has nothing to do with it.
 

cotcha now

Team Captain
Joined
Jan 27, 2008
Posts
530
Likes
35
Location
victoria
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
mancher utd, Raptors nba
#33
On what basis? That he was the best young talent? He wasn't, The universal opinion was that Kruezer was, Infact he was voted the best player in the Northern Knights, same team Cotchin was a part of. The rankings of best players in the land who were under 18 were 1.Naitanui/2.Kreuzer/3.Cotchin, Every club judged this, Experts predicted this, You rank it in hindsight, Which is completely Irrational and A fair bit ******ed, And no in Carltons position you would of picked Kruezer, Your using hindsight and biast towards "your player" that he should of gone first, Nowdays yeah, Cotchin is the second best player from the draft right now, Good work,

The basis that Carlton needed a Ruckman far ahead of Midfielders since they selected Gibbs/Murphy the drafts before and the universal opinion that Kreuzer? Well no, Two things that Carlton were crying out for in 07 season was for a Ruckman or a Forward, Kruezer showed he excelled at both. In that time Kruezer has not bulked up, Done a knee so in that reguard Kruezer has struggled

In anycase You are either A piss poor troll or an idiot, Probably both. THis has nothing to do with it.
how am i a troll where im allowed to say what my oppinion is? 2nd best player from that draft right now? you a either delusional or just plain stupid. your thinking would say oh.. we drafted thorpe before you drafted riewoldt so hes better? yes obviously kruzer has done a knee, well what about cotchin? hes been managed through every preseason because of his achilles growing at different rates to his body. hes had 1 full pre season to date, is one year younger than kruzer(drafted bottom age) and is leading the richmond midfield copping the best tagger.
they drafted their ruckmen in hampson earlier. i wouldve gone cotchin.
it was stated that the eagles wanted the first round pick so that they could draft cotchin because they knew there was no chance in hell richmond would pass on him. so obviously they rated him higher than kruzer.
to sum it all up, id rather have cotchin who has had 1 full preason, leads the richmond midfield, cops the number1 tag, can go forward and kick goals and is a future captain of our club as opposed to ur CURENT best player from that draft, KRUZER. whos top 3 favourite for the brownlow again? your the troll...dont go fingerpointing
 

Upgrayedd

A Vote for Clive is a Vote for Justice
Joined
Aug 11, 2006
Posts
29,579
Likes
20,729
Location
Perth
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
Timberwolves, Crystal Palace
#34
how am i a troll where im allowed to say what my oppinion is? 2nd best player from that draft right now? you a either delusional or just plain stupid.
Patrick Dangerfield.[/quote]

you a either delusional or just plain stupid.
I could now copy/paste every spelling mistake, however i have work tomorrow morning

well what about cotchin? hes been managed through every preseason because of his achilles growing at different rates to his body. hes had 1 full pre season to date, is one year younger than kruzer(drafted bottom age) and is leading the richmond midfield copping the best tagger.
Cool, So managed pre-seasons is now as bad as copping an ACL injury?

they drafted their ruckmen in hampson earlier. i wouldve gone cotchin.
If Carlton were to rely on Shaun Hampson to carry the Ruck duties....jesus christ

it was stated that the eagles wanted the first round pick so that they could draft cotchin because they knew there was no chance in hell richmond would pass on him. so obviously they rated him higher than kruzer.
Because Carlton had commited to Kruezer? Jesus Christ you are stupid, Let me list you some mock drafts
Websites predicted Kreuzer
http://www.aflcentral.com.au/afl-central-mock-draft-picks-1-20/
Every Tom Dick and Harry Predicted Kruezer
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/tommyneus-phantom-draft-2007.391019/
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2007-phantom-draft-bachar_houli.395236/
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/armchair-guide-to-the-2007-national-draft.398074/#post-9536399
Mock Drafts from AFL insider before the Judd trade was done
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/midfielders-in-the-draft.372672/#post-9090222
Even Very well respected afl Journalists predicted Kruezer
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/matt-burgans-phantom-draft.397701/#post-9523012
Grab a copy of Emma Quayles "The draft" as well, Where she predicts Kreuzer to go number 1.

to sum it all up, id rather have cotchin who has had 1 full preason, leads the richmond midfield, cops the number1 tag, can go forward and kick goals and is a future captain of our club as opposed to ur CURENT best player from that draft, KRUZER. whos top 3 favourite for the brownlow again? your the troll...dont go fingerpointing
Same here, I've never said otherwise, I've said Kreuzer was rated pick 1 in 2007 by every man and his dog From club Recruiters to media to talent scouts to guys who watch football at the lower levels. Your childish "Yeah you carlton posters suck cuz ur team took Kreuzer LOL YOUR POST IS WORTHLESS" type attitude is immature as your writing and ability to deal when someone throws facts at you
 

bombermick

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
May 28, 2009
Posts
9,737
Likes
1,170
Location
Vermont South
AFL Club
Essendon
#35
Jaegar reminds more of Murphy than Cotchin. He's never going to be a great aerial threat like Cotch IMO, but he's so silky and balanced - much like Murphy.

O'Meara should have the better debut season, as Daniher will need to put on more weight.
 

Sunny_

Premium Platinum
Joined
Mar 18, 2011
Posts
15,915
Likes
10,032
Location
Everett
AFL Club
Gold Coast
Other Teams
New England Patriots
#36
From what I saw of Jaeger, his disposals by foot still need a bit of work. That's the only thing pulling him down right now though. Everything else I've seen him do is exceptional.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

cotcha now

Team Captain
Joined
Jan 27, 2008
Posts
530
Likes
35
Location
victoria
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
mancher utd, Raptors nba
#37
in all fairness, right now, cotchin or kruzer? all i said was id take cotchin and obviously a lot of people would NOW. i said one club didn't want kruzer they wanted cotchin, and that was west-coast, that's why they wanted pick one? many draft experts said it was hard to split either way, and would almost prefer not to have the first selection it was that hard? what did kruzer do this yr? he came back from his knee last yr correct, had a full pre-season and all? i believe he had 1 good game. dangerfield is a magnificent talent, but does he cop the best tagger? does he have better midfield support? is he always consistent? hey that's your opinion but cotchin is the best player from that draft, people like shane crawford rated cyril the best at one stage, hes dropped off. bigger body and bigger kick is the only difference i can see that cotchin doesn't have, more accurate set shot. but cotch would cover him everywhere else. dangers more like martin but obviously better for now.
 

volders

Team Captain
Joined
Feb 21, 2010
Posts
376
Likes
93
AFL Club
Melbourne
#38
As much as I love Cotchin I'm getting ridiculously sick of some 12 year old Richmond supporter bring him up in every other thread.

FWIW, WC wanted pick 1 because pick 1/2 (Kreuzer/Cotchin) were clearly ahead of the rest of the field, so pick 1 was vastly superior to pick 3; not necessarily because they wanted Cotchin, though they very well may of taken him.

Also @delerious1 many mock drafts attempt to predict drafting order not player rankings so it would make sense that Kreuzer was no.1 in many since everyone knew Carlton had committed to him. Doesn't necessarily mean that he was rated 1, though I'm sure some people did rate him 1.

On topic, I think Daniher and O'Meera are the top 2, depending on needs. Whitfield at 3. Then Viney/Couch close behind.
 
Top Bottom