Recommitted Darcy Moore [re-signed]

[Seedsfan]

If Moore was wanting out why would he be pushing for a comeback and risking further injury for a club he doesn’t want to be a part off?

 

[Tbone McGraw]

If Moore was wanting out why would he be pushing for a comeback and risking further injury for a club he doesn’t want to be a part off?

All players want to play finals, whether or not they are staying.

 

[Apex36]

Apparently there is no sign of any soft tissue injury and it may be mental.

However, I will admit I would love to keep a fit Moore.

Scans are not the be all and end all of soft tissue diagnosis.

 

[Prochard123]

May is worth a top #10 this year and will be a Top #3 pick in 12 months
Moore looks to be around #20 this year with his injury issue's

Pies 1st Rounder will be roughly #20 + after all the compo (lyncg,Gaff) Academy bids and father sons
your not getting May for #20+

Cool, since Rance really isn't worth much, roughly #30 after all the compo (lyncg, Gaff) Academy bids and father sons, if you guys offfer us Rance + 1st round pick for Moore we will think about it okay? but probably nah...

 

[The Nostradamus]

Swans seems a good fit

They’ll play him every week and still in a decent side

 

[dunno4]

Swans seems a good fit

They’ll play him every week and still in a decent side

Swans are not clearing out mids to bring in a KPP


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Bramax]

Swans are not clearing out mids to bring in a KPP


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Very astute observation.

 

[JoondalupJ]

I think i speak for everyone on here that isnt a pies supporter....please let this happen!!! Can you imagimg big ed!

Well he's seriously injury prone, so big Ed may not care that much!

 

[The Nostradamus]

Swans are not clearing out mids to bring in a KPP


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Swans need mids no doubt but will still be looking at KPD with Grundy on his last legs will probably get phased out next year

 

[sherrif]

May is not worth Moore and a first, jesus christ. Take the first round pick out for a second and it's pretty fair

Yeah he is when the 1st round pick is 18 or 19. Moore's a terrific prospect, but May is a safer bet and his recruitment would sure up Collingwood's only weakness. If Kennedy or Darling have a good game tomorrow ill bet you anything you like Collingwood would part with Moore and a 1st rounder to get May.

 

[MisterMarcus]

Well he's seriously injury prone, so big Ed may not care that much!

Collingwood is going to get 15 first rounders in return, so Big Ed will be over the moon....

 

[newblueo]

If Moore was wanting out why would he be pushing for a comeback and risking further injury for a club he doesn’t want to be a part off?

Agree.need more top blokes like adam treloar who book themselves into a op without telling the club who were paying him.

 

[naturally north]

Pies fans look like their going to be in a rude shock for what they get for Moore going by this thread.

I hope you're not suggesting an injury prone footballer who averages 8 disposals per game isn't worth at least a top ten pick. Crikey this place has gone mad.

 

[THE_GUN]

He will stay at the Pies imo, Wants $$$ and Pies will pay him

 

[MagicGnome97]

He wasn't injured much at all in the last 2 seasons before this one. I don't recall 2015.

 

[lollol]

Been saying it for months, he is worth a second rounder and no more..... pardon the pun

 

[Prochard123]

Been saying it for months, he is worth a second rounder and no more..... pardon the pun

2nd rounder ranges over like 19 picks. If you're talking about like pick 20-25, I'd more or less agree.

 

[BPikkers]

He will stay at the Pies imo, Wants $$$ and Pies will pay him

I hope so. Yesterday showed how much we needed a tall defender/forward. If we get his hamstring right, he would be better (bar Hogan) than any other young KPP gettable in the market.

 

[THE_GUN]

I hope so. Yesterday showed how much we needed a tall defender/forward. If we get his hamstring right, he would be better (bar Hogan) than any other young KPP gettable in the market.

Big Big call with Lukosius & The King brothers in the draft
Lukosius will be a star

 

[BPikkers]

I hope you're not suggesting an injury prone footballer who averages 8 disposals per game isn't worth at least a top ten pick. Crikey this place has gone mad.

It may be more accurate to consider his disposals in the games he actually played the 4 qtrs. 4 games this year he only played 1 or 2 quarters. So closer to double the number you are suggesting.

No doubt Moore has the potential to be a great player. Obviously the biggest question mark is over his hamstring injuries.

I’m hoping the club does all they can to keep him and get him the right advice to manage through his injuries. He is only 22 and has a lot ahead of him.

 

[BPikkers]

Big Big call with Lukosius & The King brothers in the draft
Lukosius will be a star

I’m talking about the players pre-national draft that the Pies could realistically trade for.

In terms of the draft, Lukosius I agree with. The jury is out on the King brothers imo.

They tower over others in junior footy. Would like to see how they go when playing in the AFL against men with more footy smarts.

 

[THE_GUN]

Moore is worth more to the Pies than any other club, Unfortunately his injuries have hindered his progress and seems to have effected his belief in his body. His value in a trade would be at its lowest currently and not worth trading but that would mean satisfying him with a contract that above his output value.

If Moore stays this would mean that Pies will be paying him what he wants

 

[BPikkers]

Moore is worth more to the Pies than any other club, Unfortunately his injuries have hindered his progress and seems to have effected his belief in his body. His value in a trade would be at its lowest currently and not worth trading but that would mean satisfying him with a contract that above his output value.

If Moore stays this would mean that Pies will be paying him what he wants

Yeah or at least more than what others are willing to pay. I don’t think he will leave for $$ if he goes interstate.

Can’t see the Swans paying him much more than what the Pies are willing to offer him. They cant afford to have another KPP battling injury like they have had with Reid and Tippett.

After the GF, he can see exactly where he fits in and maybe the Pies will give him an extra $50k-$100k for the next 2 or 3 years because, as you said, he is worth a lot more to the Pies.

As an aside, will be interesting to see if the Doggies come out from left field with an offer. They did bid on him early in the draft which we had to match. They could do with a tall.

 

[The Nostradamus]

According to pickers he wants to stay just seems pies don’t rate him that highly otherwise more dollars would be on the table

 

[Soups]

According to pickers he wants to stay just seems pies don’t rate him that highly otherwise more dollars would be on the table

It has nothing to do with not rating him. He’s rated just about the highest of any of our youngsters. The fact is he just can’t get any continuity with his injuries. More dollars would just be negligent for a bloke that can hardly get on the park atm.