If this deal goes through it might well be the most dissapointed i've ever been with our club, which comes after the press release which was as proud as i've ever been of us.
There is no 2 ways about it, we would be getting shafted.
Pick 5 - About just 50% of top 10 picks go on to play 150 games and maybe 15% turn into player like Beams.
Pick 25(Greenwood) - good player, not a star. Not even in the same stratosphere as Beams, will fill that void but we will still be losing alot.
Crisp - Sounds harsh but this guy is average, was taken pick 40 in the rookie draft and after 2 average NEAFL years he has doe nothing to prove he's worth any more than that. More chance of not being on a list in 3 years than he does of being a good first 22 player.