Defence - Rioli or Palmer

[Mitchell Madness]

part 3 of the Palmer vs rioli threads.

This includes interception ability, spoiling and defencive pressure (such as tackling)

would have to think Rioli would get this one....

 

[Mitchell Madness]

come on, let your opinion be known, clearly you think yourselves are idiotic if your voting for Palmer in Defence, haha... anybody in their right mind knows Rioli is better

 

[Dippers_Mullet]

What a bunch of pointless and tiresome comparisons.

The players haven't even finished their first season at their respective clubs, let alone forged a career. Then there's the fact they don't even play the same position.

Wait a few years, or put Cotchin in there instead of Rioli.

 

[Mitchell Madness]

What a bunch of pointless and tiresome comparisons.

The players haven't even finished their first season at their respective clubs, let alone forged a career. Then there's the fact they don't even play the same position.

Wait a few years, or put Cotchin in there instead of Rioli.

\well, it will last forever these comparrisons unless they are broken down. Hawks will always say overall Rioli is better, but Freo fans will always say Palmer is better... least this way we can see just where each player is better

 

[FFC_]

come on, let your opinion be known, clearly you think yourselves are idiotic if your voting for Palmer in Defence, haha... anybody in their right mind knows Rioli is better

um, then why have the poll?

Suggestion: Don't make a poll and then attack 50% of the options by saying that anyone who votes for them is an idiot

 

[FFC_]

oh, and THIRTEEN three over here!

wow

 

[Vegas.]

Hawks will always say overall Rioli is better, but Freo fans will always say Palmer is better...

And the VAST majority of the rest will say Palmer is better.

A large number of that vast majority will agree that a comparison is totally irrelevant, as one is a midfielder and one is a small forward.

Again, the vast majority will agree that an elite mid is more important than an elite small forward anyway, rendering this debate useless.

The incredibly vast majority of anyone on this forum will agree that you need to stop making STUPID threads trying to get 'one-up' on everything possible. The footballers will sort it out mate, polls on BigFooty have absolutely no meaning. Hell, many people will just vote Palmer inspite of you creating these ****ing threads.

What a waste of valuable internets.

 

[whoknows]

\well, it will last forever these comparrisons unless they are broken down. Hawks will always say overall Rioli is better, but everyone else will always say Palmer is better... least this way we can see just where each player is better

Fixed.

 

[Team Mo']

Why did we need 7 threads on Rioli and Palmer?

They are absolutely nothing alike.

Surely you compare a mid to a mid or a small forward to a forward?

Wasted my time!

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Why did we need 7 threads on Rioli and Palmer?

They are absolutely nothing alike.

Surely you compare a mid to a mid or a small forward to a forward?

Wasted my time!

well since the start of the season we have had fans arguing over the better player. breaking down parts of their game I thought it could at least see where each player is better (but of corse, if people do not say why they have voted for player x, it sort of defeats the purpose...

 

[Team Mo']

well since the start of the season we have had fans arguing over the better player. breaking down parts of their game I thought it could at least see where each player is better (but of corse, if people do not say why they have voted for player x, it sort of defeats the purpose...

i'll give you a tip.

Don't ever start a poll again.

No-one except for Hawthorn fans care about these polls.

And don't attack people when they have voiced their opinion. Kind of defeats the purspose to a "poll"


w***er.