Analysis Defence

[Rainfall]

Probably not, because they wouldn't have had premiership seasons.

That's what im gettin at bro

 

[SJ]

Would you say the same if they were never Cats? and won nothing

I don't understand your point.

 

[Rainfall]

I don't understand your point.

What I'm getting at is if they were all decent players at a different club you wouldn't be saying the same, even if one or more pulled of a premiership. If they weren't a part of our squad at one stage they'd mean nothing.

 

[SJ]

What I'm getting at is if they were all decent players at a different club you wouldn't be saying the same, even if one or more pulled of a premiership. If they weren't a part of our squad at one stage they'd mean nothing.

Disagree.

 

[BlitzenTrapper]

He needs to. Gets an awful lot of praise for someone who hasn't actually done much yet.

Being consistently injured for a large portion of his career hasn't helped.

But I agree with what your saying. Needs to step up next year. Time will tell I suppose

 

[speedybundy]

Anyone else here think Rivers should make the AA squad? NOT saying the final team, but I think his been our most consistent defender for the year and has been extremely valuable. May not make it and is probably borderline, but I'm very happy with him continuing to slip under the radar

 

[Partridge]

Being consistently injured for a large portion of his career hasn't helped.

But I agree with what your saying. Needs to step up next year. Time will tell I suppose

Unfortunately there are about half a dozen players on our list right now you can say the same thing for.

 

[dazbroncos]

Unfortunately there are about half a dozen players on our list right now you can say the same thing for.

I can think of 3
Cowan, Menzel, Hmac.

Maybe Bates….

Go Catters

 

[FredLeDeux]

I can think of 3
Cowan, Menzel, Hmac.

Maybe Bates….

Go Catters

Brown, McCarthy, Simpson

 

[Partridge]

I can think of 3
Cowan, Menzel, Hmac.

Maybe Bates….

Go Catters

McIntosh had 3 years wrecked but either side of that at least has had a career.

For me it would be Cowan, Menzel, Vardy, Brown, Simpson, McCarthy. Although it seems Brown is over his injury troubles now, Simpson sort of, and hopefully Vardy will be next year. Hope I haven't missed anyone.