Deledio or Franklin?

[Danny_CFC]

Cant decide.

 

[Carlton Kid]

Deledio

 

[Spartan]

Neither.

 

[strategy]

Franklin easily.
This S/C along with all the comps is just a lottery re players average etc.

 

[Tigerrific]

I don't think you can go wrong either way. Both should have a big year

 

[LeFtBehinD]

Deledio easily, but ive got neither.

 

[jfaz515]

probaly franklin

can anyone tell me if deledio is injured i read it on the net and im not really sure

if u no reply A.S.A.P

 

[WatWouldCyrilDo]

Wouldn't pick either. Both could be really good value but both way too inconsistent stat wise. Lids can have his good and bad days, and buddy could have a good day but still give away 5 free kicks

 

[Suds_Mcduff]

probaly franklin

can anyone tell me if deledio is injured i read it on the net and im not really sure

if u no reply A.S.A.P

Deledio is not injured, he has had a huge pre season and will be lining up tomorrow night

 

[Hawkmad]

Was going to ask the same question.
ATM I have both Deledio in the middle & Franklin in the forward line.

Options -
(1) leave them as is.
(2) Trade out Franklin , Deledio to forward line & another mid around 500k
(3) Trade out both (If you choose this one who would you suggest I pick up)

Cheers

 

[HotCoffee]

It's tricky. Both players that could easily have great seasons. For what it's worth, I've gone Deledio out of the 2, mainly because of Buddy's record with giving away free kicks. Also, Deledio's new position as a leading FF/midfielder has been likened to James Hird and Brad Johnson. It's a position that is good for SC points. Should get an even spread of goals/marks/possessions. Plus I read that last year Deledio struggled a fair bit with copping a tag every week. I reckon that won't happen so much this year, now that he's spending more time in the forward line.
On the flipside, I think Buddy will post some great scores. Overall though, I'd wager that Deledio will average higher over the course of the season.