Deledio Vs Murphy

[Burzum]

At least we made a laughing stock of the Dons no-talent midfield. That was funny.

What's funny is that we still beat you. lol.

 

[THE_GUN]

Sounds a bit like Tambling...except with Richie "pulled a heart string" Tambo its 0 good games....in 4 years...

TAMBLING IS MILES AHEAD OF WALKER IN EVERYBODYS EYES EXCEPT CARLTON SUPPORTERS EYES ( OPEN YOUR EYES WALKER IS NO GOOD)

 

[parrot]

TAMBLING IS MILES....

Even Richmond supporters know Tambling is a dud, and openly admit it on your own Floodmond board. Not only did you let Franklin slip, but you're now stuck with a very ordinary player, who is only being played to save face. It's just a complete disaster.

 

[marcmurphy3]

TAMBLING IS MILES AHEAD OF WALKER IN EVERYBODYS EYES EXCEPT CARLTON SUPPORTERS EYES ( OPEN YOUR EYES WALKER IS NO GOOD)

Now that is crap. I'll admit Walker is not close to Cooney from 03 at this stage but he has done far more than Tambling.

and may I say again. THIS THREAD IS DELEDIO VS MURPHY

 

[Jeremias]

TAMBLING IS MILES AHEAD OF WALKER IN EVERYBODYS EYES EXCEPT CARLTON SUPPORTERS EYES ( OPEN YOUR EYES WALKER IS NO GOOD)

Oh please

Walker may not be a great player, but he knows when to go for the ball and put his body on the line.

He's shown much more than Tambling who really struggles.

 

[THE_GUN]

to the last 3 carlton posts, did you see the game against freo.
just a sample of what bling can do he has been very consistant & is getting better every year with his best yet to come .

he has been a better player than walker already even though he has 20 games less experiance than walker.

 

[TigerGlory]

Considering Walker was taken a year before Tambling, and hasnt had the complications of injury and mental stress, then i wouldnt be bragging to much as a Carlton supporter.

Yes Walker may be ahead of Tambo, but it wouldnt be by much. Theres been alot of negativity about Walker, and for good reason, the guy isnt very good.

 

[Jeremias]

Considering Walker was taken a year before Tambling, and hasnt had the complications of injury and mental stress, then i wouldnt be bragging to much as a Carlton supporter.

Yes Walker may be ahead of Tambo, but it wouldnt be by much. Theres been alot of negativity about Walker, and for good reason, the guy isnt very good.

I'm pretty sure that if you weren't already regarded as an idiot, then the first sentence would have made up the minds of most BigFooty posters.

Hasn't had injury complications? It might help you if you actually knew something about football before trying to sound smart.

Tambling is an average player and let's be honest, if he was taken at pick 60 odd he would have been delisted already. His high draft status is the only thing keeping him in the Richmond team.

 

[TigerGlory]

Tambling is an average player and let's be honest, if he was taken at pick 60 odd he would have been delisted already. His high draft status is the only thing keeping him in the Richmond team.

Has not had a single injury free pre-season.

Dont go around calling people idiots, take a look at yourself buddo.

 

[Jeremias]

Has not had a single injury free pre-season.

Dont go around calling people idiots, take a look at yourself buddo.

I didn't say that he didn't have an injury.

You're the one that made an ass of themselves by saying Walker had never had injury complications.

Thanks for showing us that you don't know what you're talking about. We know now not to take you seriously.

 

[TigerGlory]

I didn't say that he didn't have an injury.

You're the one that made an ass of themselves by saying Walker had never had injury complications.

Thanks for showing us that you don't know what you're talking about. We know now not to take you seriously.

You cant seriously compare Walker's injuries to Tamblings?

Tambling has had something wrong with him, every pre-season except 08.

He also hurt himself half way through 06 as well.

Come on mate, Walkers been injured a couple of times maybe. But nothing on the scale of Tambo.

 

[Drunken Wookie]

You cant seriously compare Walker's injuries to Tamblings?

Tambling has had something wrong with him, every pre-season except 08.

He also hurt himself half way through 06 as well.

Come on mate, Walkers been injured a couple of times maybe. But nothing on the scale of Tambo.

Walker's had a broken talent-bone his whole career.

 

[THE_GUN]

parrot rates walker & the ohalphins as rare talents whith supreme athletic ability that are off the scales walker 22 done nothing ohalphin1 25 clearly not even in carltons top 25 ohalphin2 hasnt even made a debut after how many years .

 

[marcmurphy3]

lol. I thought this was the Deledio vs Murphy thread.

 

[parrot]

parrot rates walker ...

Yes, a future superstar. Without doubt. What else would you like to know?

 

[HBK619]

Yes, a future superstar. Without doubt. What else would you like to know?

Looking forward to your appearance on this thread.

J.Riewoldt vs J.Sellar:
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=285248&page=11

 

[HBK619]

lol. I thought this was the Deledio vs Murphy thread.

Yeah, and we already figured out Deledio is better...now back to the Walker Vs Tambling disscusion...

 

[parrot]

Looking forward to your appearance on this thread.

J.Riewoldt vs J.Sellar:
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=285248&page=11

I wouldn't get too excited about a high-scoring no-defense Bulldogs Intra-Club game. Bulldogs A and B were both losers today. lol.

 

[RichosGuns]

I wouldn't get too excited about a high-scoring no-defense Bulldogs Intra-Club game. Bulldogs A and B were both losers today. lol.

An you would get excited about a Melbourne no defense, no midfield, no foward line game? Lol @ you

btw, Deledio 24 disposals 2 goals > Murphys 21 dispsoals 1 goal

 

[parrot]

An you would get excited about a Melbourne no defense, no midfield, no foward line game? ..

Correct. I am not excited at all. I don't view any of our wins as good enough. We should have beaten the Dees by over 100 points, and beaten the Pies by over 50 points. I am disappointed, but know we're headed in the right direction. We are only playing to about 10% of our potential at this stage. But the upside is just massive.

 

[HBK619]

I wouldn't get too excited about a high-scoring no-defense Bulldogs Intra-Club game. Bulldogs A and B were both losers today. lol.

Wow, you just pull out this stuff from your arse don't you.

Richmond = 10 times better than Carlton.

Not to mention Deledio>>>Murphy

 

[parrot]

Wow, you just pull out this stuff from your arse don't you.

Richmond = 10 time...

lol. You couldn't even beat the Bulldog A team today. They're hardly world-beaters.

 

[RichosGuns]

lol. You couldn't even beat the Bulldog A team today. They're hardly world-beaters.

West was out for the doggies, he was their only star who didn't play today. Guys like Everitt who are still up and commers hardly count

Btw, at 4 - 1 - 0 they may not be world beaters, but up to this week they have beaten every team they have played against

 

[marcmurphy3]

An you would get excited about a Melbourne no defense, no midfield, no foward line game? Lol @ you

btw, Deledio 24 disposals 2 goals > Murphys 21 dispsoals 1 goal

Murph has been better overall this season and I've watched all games from both teams.

Will be interesting to watch there careers unfold however I'm pretty happy with Murph.

 

[TigerGlory]

Murph has been better overall this season and I've watched all games from both teams.

Will be interesting to watch there careers unfold however I'm pretty happy with Murph.

I disagree.

Deledio started slowly, but his form, particularly his last two weeks have been exceptional.

I would rate Deledio's season higher than Murphy's at this stage.