Remove this Banner Ad

Delist Lachie Murphy

Would you de-list Murphy?


  • Total voters
    57
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

When he grabbed that one I thought "Yep, here's his gimme goal when the game is done that seals his selection in future."

And then he does that.

Disappointed Malcolm In The Middle GIF by Malcolm France

Was sitting in line with that one - never thought he was a chance, made the comment to my partner that at least it was a throw in, almost gave him the benefit of the doubt that it was done on purpose as a smart move.
 
Terrible sub performance as expected.

His highlights:
  • A no look handball to no one
  • Didn’t make the distance with a snap from 25 metres out under no pressure
  • Terrible kick inside 50
  • Fumbled the ball twice without picking it up

The list could go on but I tuned out a bit towards the end.
If he retains his spot next week and we haver Taylor kicking 4 in the SANFL who can very much play his spot, Taylor should be seeking a move at seasons end as it will be a p155 take from the coach
 
If he retains his spot next week and we haver Taylor kicking 4 in the SANFL who can very much play his spot, Taylor should be seeking a move at seasons end as it will be a p155 take from the coach
"Yeah look, after the bye and being sub Lachy really needs that run of a full game in his legs. So Lachy will start in the 22 against Melbourne and Zachy will stay in the SANFL this week. We just ask him to keep performing and waiting for his chance, because it WILL come. He just needs to be ready for it."
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

L. Murphy.
1 solitary kick in the last quarter. Found time and space as a small forward 30 metres out directly in front of goal on his preferred foot. Snaps for goal and …… doesn’t make the difference.
This was a great example of his positioning and reading play is pretty good ie decent Footy IQ.

And his skillset not matching it.
 
This was a great example of his positioning and reading play is pretty good ie decent Footy IQ.

And his skillset not matching it.
Sometimes he can get in good positions like that play at the end of the Showdown where Dawson ended up with his kick after the siren.

Murphy roved the pack well, then inexplicably fumbled and then got smashed by the Port player for a free kick.

It worked out perfectly in the end. If he doesn’t fumble it, he throws it on the boot and nothing happens, but he fumbles get clobbered and he takes one for the team and walks off the pitch letting Dawson kick the winning goal.
 
This was a great example of his positioning and reading play is pretty good ie decent Footy IQ.

And his skillset not matching it.
He had 1 kick and a couple of handballs to no-one against a VFL side. I’ll never be convinced of a good footy IQ with him. I do know he can’t mentally handle the speed of the game. Something he’s never been able to handle from game 1. How can well established AFL coaches not see that ??
 
He had 1 kick and a couple of handballs to no-one against a VFL side. I’ll never be convinced of a good footy IQ with him. I do know he can’t mentally handle the speed of the game. Something he’s never been able to handle from game 1. How can well established AFL coaches not see that ??
He is one of those who are a pretty good SANFL level player but not really up to it at AFL level. Nothing wrong with that and who knows, if he is delisted and heads to Sturt next year and wins a magarey and leads us to a flag i will have completely changed my mind on him😉😁
 
Sometimes he can get in good positions like that play at the end of the Showdown where Dawson ended up with his kick after the siren.

Murphy roved the pack well, then inexplicably fumbled and then got smashed by the Port player for a free kick.

It worked out perfectly in the end. If he doesn’t fumble it, he throws it on the boot and nothing happens, but he fumbles get clobbered and he takes one for the team and walks off the pitch letting Dawson kick the winning goal.
His one attribute is reading play and Footy IQ.

He would be no where near AFL level if he didn't have that ability to get into the "right" spots.

Just not skilfull or physically good enough at the AFL level.
 
His one attribute is reading play and Footy IQ.

He would be no where near AFL level if he didn't have that ability to get into the "right" spots.

Just not skilfull or physically good enough at the AFL level.

What? Murphy has terrible football IQ, it's why he constantly makes mistakes and can't get near it
 

Remove this Banner Ad

What? Murphy has terrible football IQ, it's why he constantly makes mistakes and can't get near it
He does get near it.

That is the issue. When u see us play live you can see how well he does position himself.

But he is too slow and skilkset not good enough for AFL. Struggles to really be involved.

Like Jimmy Rowe and Mitch Grigg. Can read play and get into good spots.

If Murphy played for another SANFL club he would win a Magarey.

But should not be on an AFL list.
 
He does get near it.

That is the issue. When u see us play live you can see how well he does position himself.

But he is too slow and skilkset not good enough for AFL. Struggles to really be involved.

Like Jimmy Rowe and Mitch Grigg. Can read play and get into good spots.

If Murphy played for another SANFL club he would win a Magarey.


But should not be on an AFL list.
Cheers.🍻
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Remove this Banner Ad

Delist Lachie Murphy

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top