Another problem with Neale is that he's a bit of a tweener in terms of position.
From what I know his best spot is as an inside mid but he probably doesn't have the ability to do much good there at AFL level. That's probably size related.
On the other hand, he can't play many other positions. I know Fremantle have moved him to the forward line in the past (and probably still do) but then his game isn't ideal for that.
It's a bit like Kobe Stevens. Not good enough to be one of your main ball winners, not versatile enough to contribute while he waits to pinch hit.
EDIT: Having said that, I haven't watched him in ages and I know underdog watches a lot of Swans Districts footy.